Archive for September, 2008

Sabi ni Panlilio, Huwag Magsisinungaling

September 30, 2008

HUWAG MAGSISINUNGALING!

Ito ang esensya ng talumpating ilinahad ni Pampanga Governor Ed Panlilio, kilala bilang Among Ed, sa pinaka-unang paglulunsad ng kombensyon ng Sangguniang Laiko ng Pilipinas (SLP) sa labas ng Luzon.

Binaybay ng Gobernador ang temang “Ang Laiko: Pangunahing Ahente ng Pagbabago Tungo sa Katapatan at Integridad para sa Mabuting Pamamahala” ng Linggo ng Laiko sa Pilipinas (National Laity Week ’08), gamit ang kanyang personal na karanasan sa pagsabak sa larangan ng politika.

Ayon kay Panlilio, hindi lang pari ang kailangang huwag magsinungaling, kundi ang buong sambayanang Katoliko. Aniya, ito ang pinaka-pangunahing hakbang sa pagpigil sa pag-usbong ng korapsyon sa loob ng mga tanggapan ng pamahalaan.

Kailangan aniya ng masusing gawaing pormasyon sa arena ng tinatawag niyang “ministry of politics.” Pabiro pa niyang nabanggit sa mga Obispong nakikinig ang malaki aniyang pangangailangan na magbuo ng batayang kurso sa politika na ibibigay sa masang kasapian ng Laiko sa buong bansa.

Dagdag pa ni Among Ed, “kailangan ding magkaroon ng masusi at tuluy-tuloy na pormasyon ng mga laikong gumagampan ng gawaing apostoliko sa loob ng mga tanggapan ng gobyerno.

Lubos namang napuno ng palakpakan ang benyu ng aktibidad, nang ideklara ng Gobernador na babalik agad siya sa pagkapari pagkatapos ng kanyang termino bilang Gobernador ng Pampanga.

Samantala, nangako ang Sangguniang Laiko ng Pilipinas na magpapasa ito ng resolusyon na nagpapahayag ng suporta kay Among Ed laban sa kinakaharap niya ngayong “Recall Petition” na ilinunsad ng kanyang mga kalaban sa politika.

Ang Jaro Archdiocese ang siyang punong-abala sa naturang pambansang kombensyon ng LAIKO ngayong taon. Ang pagdiriwang ngayon ng Linggo ng Laiko sa Pilipinas ay bilang paggunita na rin sa kamartiran nina San Lorenzo Ruiz ats Blessed Pedro Calungsod, ang mga halimbawa ng martir na Laiko sa Pilipinas.

Brgy RP Advisory

September 28, 2008

We are going ut for three days to attend a national activity.  I can’t be able to update this blog for that period of time.

Please feel-free though to visit and leave comments.

I will attend to it as soon as I’m free of other matters. :)   Thanks!

TO WRITE IS ALREADY TO CHOOSE!

Editorial Cartoon: (Presidentiable War) Who’s The Victim?

September 28, 2008

We always are.

Rights group hit military use of air raids in Samar

September 28, 2008

By Joey A. Gabieta
Visayas Bureau
First Posted 19:28:00 09/27/2008

TACLOBAN CITY — A HUMAN RIGHTS group in Eastern Visayas has accused the military of conducting air raids in remote villages of two Samar towns that resulted in the dislocation of families.

The Eastern Visayas chapter of Karapatan claimed that government troops conducted the air strikes in the villages of Bay-ang in San Jorge and in Hagbay in San Jose de Buan on Sept. 16 and 18.

The human rights group also alleged that aside from dropping bombs on these villages, the military also arrested and detained civilians.

“These acts are clear indications that the military is not considering the lives of the civilians and the people whom they are mandated to protect,” the group’s regional secretary general Kathrina Castillo said in an e-mail.

While the military admitted having conducted air strikes, they maintained it was only done in one village in San Jorge town as part of the support for the soldiers pursuing suspected rebels.

Maj. Magintonong Tocalo, chief of the 8th Infantry Division civil-military office, said the allegations were lies that were part of Karapatan’s efforts to malign the Armed Forces of the Philippines before the public.

“It’s nothing but fabricated lies. While it was true that there was such an incident, it was part of our legitimate operations as we hunt down members of the New People’s Army in the area,” Tocalo said in a phone interview on Thursday.

He said the military conducted air raids and bombings in the second week of September but these were done only in Bay-ang village.

Tocalo also clarified that nobody was living in the area that was bombed by the military, which he said was two kilometers away from the barangay proper.

“We have discovered in the area some (abandoned) camps of the rebels. It serves as the base of the rebels operating in Samar,” Tocalo said.

Tocalo also denied that they arrested and detained civilians since there were no people living in the area.

‘Tagaytay 5’ slams attempt to jail them anew

September 28, 2008

By Niña Catherine Calleja
Southern Luzon Bureau
First Posted 19:25:00 09/27/2008

CALAMBA CITY — THE FIVE POLITICAL prisoners known as “Tagaytay 5,” who were recently ordered freed by the lower court, lambasted the recent attempt of the police to jail them for the second time.

On Sept. 8, the Tagaytay City Prosecutors’ Office, through prosecutors Ernesto B. Vida and Edgar A. Ambagan, filed a motion for reconsideration with the Tagaytay Regional Trial Court Branch 18, challenging the dismissal of the rebellion charges against the five filed two years ago.

The Department of Justice and the Philippine National Police charged the five of rebellion for allegedly planning to overthrow the Arroyo administration.

In a statement sent to the Inquirer, the “Tagaytay 5” called the motion a “legal maneuver” of the prosecutors’ office to hound them and send them back to prison.

“In effect, what the DOJ and the PNP are asking the court is our baseless rearrest and unjust imprisonment,” it said.

Tagaytay Judge Edwin G. Larida Jr. ruled that the five farmers were innocent of the charge of rebellion, and consequently ordered their release from incarceration on Aug. 20.

In a phone interview Saturday morning, lawyer Jose Manuel I. Diokno said the motion was a mere scrap of paper.

“It would be a double jeopardy as the case against the ‘Tagaytay 5’ was duly tried and dismissed,” he said.

The lawyers of the five filed a manifestation opposing the motion for reconsideration on Sept. 19.

6,000 OFWs stranded on Oman-UAE border

September 28, 2008

By Cynthia Balana
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 02:15:00 09/28/2008

THE DEPARTMENT OF FOREIGN Affairs Saturday ordered its embassies in the Middle East to extend assistance to some 6,000 overseas Filipino workers stranded on the border of Oman and the United Arab Emirates.

Acting Foreign Secretary Esteban Conejos Jr. said the OFWs were stranded on the border because of recent changes in the UAE’s visa rules which took effect on July 29.

The new policy directs previous holders of visas to the UAE to reapply as tourists, resulting in the rejection of thousands of visa applications from Filipinos.

“The Filipinos had been warned since March (about the new rule),” said Conejos.

Nevetheless, he said, the DFA would appeal to the UAE government not to drive them away.

At any rate, the DFA would first coordinate with UAE officials before deciding whether or not to repatriate the Filipinos, Conejos said.

He stressed repatriation would be a last resort considering the big number of OFWs involved.

Embassy officials in Muscat, Tehran and Abu Dhabi, as well as the Philippine consulate in Dubai, have been mobilized to deal with the problem.

“(The decision to repatriate the OFWs) will depend on how the UAE government responds to our request for leniency,” Conejos said.

Conejos said that since Sept. 23, a four-man consular team from the embassy in Muscat has been going to various hotels in Al Buraimi, along the border with Oman.

Nearly 1,000 OFWs were reportedly holed up at the Al Buraimi Hotel alone.

The stranded OFWs said they were being asked by the hotels to deposit their passports upon checking in.

The OFWs who exited from Al Ain in the UAE as a result of the change in visa policy entered Oman using three-day tourist visas issued by Omani authorities. However, their visas expired before they could get fresh UAE visit visas to enter UAE.

Starting Aug. 1 this year, Oman also stopped the practice of issuing visas to regular exit visitors.

Aminah Marduen, the coordinator at the embassy in Oman, said that Filipinos and many other foreign nationals entered Oman without being aware of the new Omani immigration law.

Environment groups demand probe on Crew Minerals for Masara tragedy

September 28, 2008

BY DAISY C. GONZALES
Davao Today

DAVAO CITY–Southern Mindanao environment groups demand a probe on the Canadian mining firm Crew Minerals for the September 6 landslide in Masara that killed 24 and displaced thousands.

Francis Morales, spokesperson of the environment group Panalipdan, said that along with the rescue missions, government should also investigate the Masara mines of Apex Mining Corp (Apex), which Crew Gold Corp, known here as Crew Minerals, took over in 2005 after it bought the Filipino company’s majority shares.

“Monsoon rains ordinarily happen but landslides are easily triggered in areas where man-made intervention or aggression occurs,” Morales said in a statement.

Panalipdan said Crew Minerals has been “extensively aggressive” in its mining operations since it bought majority shares from Apex Mining.

Reports from the mining firm’s website (www.apexmining.com) said Crew Minerals upgraded Apex’s processing plant, targeting to process 2,400 metric tons of ore daily, from its present daily full capacity of only 500 metric tons (MT). The plant, according to Apex, is geared towards hitting its target.

The company’s drilling operations have also reached 32 kilometers below ground. “Its operation is in high gear as it wants increased target production by the end of this year,” Panalipdan said.

“Portals and ramp systems are continuously being opened as the company gears for increased production,” Morales said, hinting that it might have triggered the collapse.

“Large-scale mining corporations should not be left off the hook too quickly,” Morales said.

The Davao city chapter of the anti-mining alliance Alyansa Tigil Mina (Alyansa) also echoed similar call. Alyansa wants the government to investigate mining companies “for possible environmental safeguards that may have been violated.”

Last week’s landslides that instantly hit Masara village, a mining enclave in Maco town, claimed 24 lives, countless injured, and at least 5,000 residents homeless, creating two ghost communities in Maco, Compostela Valley Province, some four-hour drive northeast from this city.

Crew Minerals targets 85,000 to 180,000 ounces of gold and 500,000 to 600,000 ounces of silver this year, according to reports gathered by Panalipdan. At the minimum, 85,000 ounces of gold (2,409.665 kilograms of gold) is as heavy as the combined 48 sacks of a 50-kilo sack of milled staple rice.

Crew Minerals’ mining operations cover the landslide-prone Masara village in Maco town in Southern Mindanao. It is considered “principal asset” of the Canadian firm in the country, as stated in the company website.

The Canadian company took over the Filipino-owned Apex Mining Company after buying the majority shares. Crew Minerals and its Philippine partner Mapula Creek Gold Corp now holds 72.8 percent of Apex that operated in Maco since the 70s.

Maco mines, formerly called Masara Mines, was purchased from Apex at 6.6 million dollars in 2005 and has since been one of the 24 priority mining projects being pushed by President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo.

The government’s Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) approved the company’s MPSAs in 2005 and 2007 which cover 2,237 hectares previously occupied by Apex.

“Extensive drilling” operations early last year proved to be more positive compared to 2006, the company reported on its website.

According to www.apexmining.com, estimated gold on site as of last year was 1.462 million MT at 6.5 grams per MT. ”Inferred” mineral resources or positive estimates based on Maco mines geology samples were higher at 9.066 million MT at six grams per metric tons. In 2004, MGB has valued Apex mines at 33.2 million dollars.

The anti-mining group Alyansa said the mining operations and expansion of Crew Minerals in the Maco mines have already cost the company 36.58 million dollars in the period of three years since 2004.

As the Crew Minerals ore production goes full swing this year, Panalipdan’s Morales dismissed MGB’s pronouncements that immediately exonerated mining firms and their operations from the Masara tragedy.

Panalipdan, an umbrella of 25-member organizations in Southern Mindanao, said that killer landslides are most frequent in areas where there are mining operations. The group cited the mining operations in King-King in Pantukan and the infamous Diwalwal mines in Monkayo, all in Compostela Valley Province. Both are also listed as priority mining projects of the President.

“Civilian lives are at stake due to the relentless issuance of mining permits to foreign mining companies amidst the sinful leniency and negligence of environmental safeguards, and dogged obeisance to mining capitalists,” said Morales.

Panalipdan reiterates its call to scrap the Philippine Mining Act of 1995 that gives license to foreign big mining companies to own, operate and mine the country’s resources “at the expense of patrimony and national sovereignty.” (Daisy C. Gonzales/davaotoday.com)

Drive launched vs mining in Guimaras

September 28, 2008

By Nestor P. Burgos Jr.
Visayas Bureau
First Posted 19:25:00 09/27/2008

ILOILO CITY — GUIMARAS RESIDENTS AND OFFICIALS have launched a signature campaign against applications for large-scale mining on the island-province.

Led by Church groups and officials, the campaign coupled with an education drive in villages seeks to pressure government agencies to disapprove mining operations on the island that still has to recover from the massive oil spill two years ago.

Guimaras Gov. Felipe Nava said they would continue their campaign against mining applications even though the Department of Environment and Natural Resources had already said it would consider the stand and sentiments of the residents when they evaluate the mining applications.

“There is still no guarantee that mining applications will not be approved and that efforts of mining companies to come in and operate will stop. We will never rest until this is clear,” Nava told the Inquirer at the sidelines of a multi-sectoral assembly on large-scale mining held in Jordan, Guimaras, on Friday.

The assembly was attended by leaders of local governments, religious groups, nongovernment groups and people’s organizations.

Nava said three applications for mining covered 65 percent of the island or around 37,000 hectares. The mining applications were for areas located in 22 villages in Nueva Valencia town, 13 in Sibunag, 12 in San Lorenzo, six in Buenavista and five in the capital town of Jordan.

The Fil-Asian Strategic Resources and Properties Corp., a subsidiary of the Australia-based Rusina Mining NL, has exploration plans for gold and copper deposits in a 2,400-hectare area covering nine of the 20 villages of Nueva Valencia.

Its application included the villages of Napandong, Sto. Domingo, Lucmayan, San Roque, Salvacion, La Paz, Cabalagnan, Canhawan and Igdarapdap.

Nava said they would step up their advocacy against mining operations even if the DENR does not approve the applications.

“We cannot let our guard down. We have to be vigilant,” he said.

Fr. Jose Manuel Escanlar, parish priest of Jordan, said they were standing by the pastoral letter of the Catholic Bishops Conference of the Philippines against mining.

“These will destroy the whole island,” said Escanlar who was among the Church leaders who attended the assembly.

Fr. Remy Barredo, of the Sibunag parish of the Iglesia Filipina Independiente, said he also opposed the mining applications because these will threaten communities.

“We do not oppose development but these should not be at the cost of losing our resources,” said Pepito Jose Cerrillo, a director of the Jordan Motorboat association.

Fr. Maloney Gotera, parish priest of Nueva Valencia, said lessons should be learned from communities that were destroyed by mining operations.

Provincial environment officer Gualberto Galia and health officer Dr. Felicito Lozarita also warned that mining operations could pollute water sources and lead to mercury poisoning.

Activist of ’70s now chief of PNP

September 28, 2008

By Alcuin Papa
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 02:02:00 09/28/2008

THE NEW CHIEF OF THE PHILIPPINE NATIONAL Police was an activist in his freshman year at the University of the Philippines in Diliman, Quezon City, in 1972.

“That was shortly before martial law, when activism was at its height,” Jesus Verzosa said, recalling how, as a gangly 18-year-old, he stood out in protest rallies.

But the luster of student activism began to fade for Verzosa after martial law was declared in September of that year. “I wasn’t a real advocate of armed struggle, only of cultural change. Also, I began to see there was no future in the movement. It offered no alternative solution,” he said.

The next year, his father, a military colonel, convinced him to take the entrance exams at the Philippine Military Academy.

“Before that, I knew nothing of the PMA. All I knew was that it was involved in parades. The first time I stepped into the PMA was my first time in Baguio,” Verzosa recalled with a chuckle.

He graduated from the PMA in 1976. Yesterday, he assumed command of the 125,000-strong national police force.

Marching order

President Macapagal-Arroyo’s first marching order to Verzosa, 54, is to help in her administration’s mission to bring peace to the troubled South.

Verzosa has previously been assigned in Basilan and Maguindanao, provinces where the Moro Islamic Liberation Front and the bandit group Abu Sayyaf are known to operate.

In her speech during yesterday’s turnover ceremony at Camp Crame, the President said Verzosa had the experience “valuable to what we are seeking to do today—that is, to do everything possible to bring lasting peace in Mindanao and end 40 years of fighting that has killed more than 120,000 people.”

Ms Arroyo also reiterated her administration’s goal to pursue the stalled peace process in Mindanao.

“[We are committed] to end the violence that has held the southern part of our country back,” she said.

The President also said she expected the PNP under Verzosa to play “a very strong role” in enforcing “disarmament, demobilization and rehabilitation” in certain parts of Mindanao, where government troops are hunting down MILF Commanders Ameril Ombra Kato, Abdullah Macapaar alias Bravo and Aleem Sulaiman Pangalian, who led deadly attacks against civilians in August.

“After all,” the current operations against the renegade MILF commanders are “a law enforcement exercise, not an all-out war,” she said.

Maximize deployment

At a press conference later yesterday, Verzosa said he would order more police resources and personnel to Mindanao.

He said that in order to maximize the deployment, he would advocate the formation of an interim police group that would integrate various regions in certain areas, similar to the area commands of the Armed Forces.

He promised to spend time talking with Gen. Alexander Yano, the AFP chief of staff and his classmate at the PMA, on how to solve the problem in Mindanao.

Jogging interviews

“We are going to be jogging and talking together on Mindanao. He is also a fitness buff like me,” Verzosa said.

He invited reporters to jog with him every morning, saying these sessions would be open for interviews.

In his assumption speech, Verzosa said he would make “effective leadership” a way of life in the police force.

This, he said, would make the delivery of police services more effective and PNP commanders less dependent on national headquarters.

Verzosa also promised to be a hands-on leader and to spend more time visiting policemen in the field.

“We shall develop leaders at all levels. And I shall lead these leaders … We shall hit the ground running by enhancing police services where they matter most,” he said.

High-profile cases

Verzosa’s star rose quickly when he joined the PNP, where he is known as a tenacious investigator and an intelligence expert.

He has gone up against urban terrorists, robbery gangs and kidnap-for-ransom groups.

Verzosa has held vital positions in the PNP, including commander of Region IV-A (Calabarzon, considered a hotbed of crime syndicates), the Criminal Investigation and Detection Group (or CIDG, the premier investigation unit), and the Intelligence Group (or IG, the primary unit against terrorists and ranking members of insurgent groups like the New People’s Army).

As Region IV-A commander, Verzosa and his team cracked the rape case that led to the arrest and prosecution of then Mayor Antonio Sanchez of Calauan, Laguna.

Among the many sensational cases he has handled as CIDG chief is the murder of actress Nida Blanca.

As IG chief, Verzosa directed operations that led to the arrest of terrorists Fathur Rohman Al-Ghozi and Muklis.

He has also brought down crime groups like the Johnny Ong drug ring and the Villacer kidnap-for-ransom gang.

Critics already

But this early, Verzosa has had his share of criticism.

Cause-oriented groups have raised his involvement in the enforcement of martial law in its later years, and challenged him to improve the PNP’s human rights record.

To this, Verzosa said: “We already have a human rights program existing and we have plans of strengthening it. We are closely coordinating with Commission on Human Rights Chair Leila de Lima.”

He said the PNP had also banned the practice of making a public presentation of suspects “who are considered innocent until proven guilty by a court,” and had established its own Human Rights Affairs Office.

As for the escape of Al-Ghozi from a detention cell in Camp Crame in 2003, Verzosa had this to say: “I gave up my position as IG chief to give way to an impartial investigation by a fact-finding body headed by Sedfrey Ordoñez. I was exonerated.”

He said he led efforts to recapture Al-Ghozi, but “unluckily,” the man was killed.

Eye-opener

But Al-Ghozi’s escape was an eye-opener for Verzosa that led him to discover the “dysfunction” in the PNP systems: “I saw the sorry state of our jails and buildings, and procedural lapses.”

Al-Ghozi’s escape resulted in the formation of the PNP Reform Commission, which made a study on the dysfunction that Verzosa saw.

That, combined with the 2004 UN Development Program study of the police force, led to the establishment of the PNP’s Transformation Program and its implementing arm, the Program Management Office.

“The Al-Ghozi incident became a springboard for further reforms in the PNP. I guess you can say it was providential,” Verzosa said.

Managerial training

As PNP chief, Verzosa intends to make the force more efficient by training all 1,600 chiefs of police, 80 provincial commanders and 17 regional commanders to become managers.

“That will be our main agenda, to implement our program of building leadership from the chiefs of police up. That is what we lack in critical crime-prone areas and in places with an insurgency problem,” he said.

According to Verzosa, leadership at the top will result in efficiency. And a more efficient and better led police force will be capable of bringing down the crime rate and improving its anticrime campaign.

“All commanders will be accountable and responsible for the anticrime campaigns in their areas,” he said.

Verzosa is convinced that training in management will allow commanders to link up with other stakeholders in the community to help in the prevention and solution of crimes in their areas.

The focus on management is the crux of the PNP’s Transformation Program, which Verzosa spearheaded during his term as deputy chief for administration, the PNP’s second highest post.

He also headed the Program Management Office.

To the max

“This time, as PNP chief, we will implement the transformation program to the max,” Verzosa said.

He said the program would make every police chief and unit commander an effective manager, and all the members of the force “men and women of integrity and self-sacrifice.”

Verzosa also said he would push for the modernization program started by his predecessor, Avelino Razon.

Armed with a P10-billion fund from the President, the PNP aims to improve and modernize its “ shoot, move, communicate and investigate” capability, he said.

‘MILF did not provoke aerial attack’

September 28, 2008

By Alcuin Papa
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 02:01:00 09/28/2008

COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS CHAIR Leila de Lima said the initial CHR investigation into the deaths of six civilians in an aerial attack in Datu Piang, Maguindanao, on Sept. 8 showed the attack was not provoked by members of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF).

This contradicted the military’s claim that the MILF had fired at their plane, leading the pilot to fire back, killing the civilians, among them, two children and a pregnant teenager, in Barangay Tee, Datu Piang.

In a talk with reporters during the change of police command ceremonies in Camp Crame, De Lima said witnesses had told the CHR there was no exchange of gunfire between the military plane and the MILF.

“Witnesses have told us that they heard two loud explosions which were not preceded by any gunfire. So the fire (from the military plane) was not in retaliation of anything,” she said.

But De Lima stressed that this was just the result of an initial investigation which would need a “further probe.”

She also said their independent probe confirmed the deaths of the six civilians and that they had died due to bullet wounds. De Lima explained that they have yet to determine if the two loud explosions were caused by a rocket attack or high-caliber fire.

The military had said there was no way of knowing how the six had died because, according to Muslim tradition, the bodies were buried before sundown after death. It also claimed the MILF members were trying to escape on bancas with some civilians, probably their relatives, when the plane on reconnaissance patrol spotted them. The MILF members, the military said, fired at the plane.

No sanctions on pilot

Early this week, Armed Forces Chief of Staff Gen. Alexander Yano said no sanctions would be slapped on the military pilot who flew the plane since the plane was under hostile fire and had to fire back.

An Inquirer I-team report after the incident quoted 60-year-old Mandi Bangkong as saying explosions in and around Sitio Dagaring in Barangay Tee had sent many residents fleeing on bancas. He himself had herded his extended family and put them on three boats.

2 rockets fired

Mandi said he was about 100 meters behind the first boat when a Philippine Air Force plane appeared. “I saw this plane dive and head for my grandchildren and fire two rockets.”

Shrapnel killed five of his six grandchildren—two boys and three girls, including a pregnant 18-year-old. Four died instantly. Another succumbed to wounds in the hospital. Another grandson was seriously wounded. Their father, Daya Manunggal Mandi, disappeared in the water and was presumed to have died.

Photographs made available to the Inquirer showed the mortally wounded, including close-ups of flesh ripped apart.

The NDCC reported that the fighting that erupted in central Mindanao after a peace agreement between the government and the MILF collapsed has so far claimed 71 lives — all civilians except for a colonel and three soldiers.

MILF calls for an independent body to look into civilian casualties

September 28, 2008

Q & A with Mohagher Iqbal, MILF panel chief negotiator

Part One

Earlier reports have put the blame on Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) commanders Ameril Ombra Kato in North Cotabato and Abdullah Macapaar, also known as Kumander Bravo, in Lanao del Norte for launching the attacks in August that reportedly killed civilians and forced the government to change tack in the peace talks.

The attacks came after the failed signing of the memorandum of agreement on ancestral domain (MOA-AD), which would have given the MILF authority over the areas identified under the proposed Bangsamoro Juridical Entity (BJE).

Even in the holy month of Ramadhan, the AFP continues its military operations in Moro communities in pursuit of the two renegade commanders.

But what really triggered the attacks? Were Ombra Kato and Bravo solely to blame?

In this interview, MILF chief negotiator Mohagher Iqbal told Davao Today the unreported MILF side of the story.

Q: Some MILF commanders were reported to be on a rampage after the failed signing of the MOA-AD. What really happened?

When the Philippines failed to sign the MOA, there were commanders who, at the beginning, did not really want the peace process because, according to them, the Philippines cannot be trusted, anyway. The government will not implement what it has committed. So when it was not signed, our two commanders concluded that the government of the Philippines did not really want the peaceful process. So, they decided by themselves without the sanction of the high leaders of the MILF. That’s when the problem came.

But we have to distinguish between North Cotabato and Lanao del Norte.

In North Cotabato, it was the government of the Philippines who clearly started it. On July 1, they attacked our forces in Aleosan, some 2.5 kilometers away from the highway. That was how the war started in North Cotabato. Then, there were burning of houses. There were elements who joined the MILF who also burned some houses.

As for the Cafgus (Civilian Armed Forces Geographic Unit), the CVOs (Civilian Volunteers Organization) and the military, they also burned houses. If you come to think of it, there were more houses burned among the Moros, than those among the settlers.

What we are trying to say is that, since they filed charges against Kato, why not also file charges against the Cafgus and CVOs, who were also guilty of burning houses?

In fact, they burned a lot more houses than the MILF. We are saying that if the government still treat the Moros as constituents of the Republic of the Philippines, they should also file charges against Cafgus and CVOs.

In the case of Lanao del Norte, we have to admit that it was initiated by Kumander Bravo. But as to the reported incidence of deaths of civilians, let me clarify that there were three kinds: First, there were Cafgus and CVOs. How do you classify them? They were armed combatants, therefore, enemies in times of war.

Second, there were those caught in the crossfire, especially the kid from Pagadian (a city in the province of Zamboanga del Sur). It was a crossfire, so, we do not really know who hit them.

Third, there were other civilians who were not very careful. We really feel sorry for that and we condemn the killing of unarmed civilians.

But it’s no secret to us that in Lanao del Norte, there is a fanatic group called Good Shepherds. They owe the Moro a lot. They took lands away from the Moros. There were people killed. Some of them joined the MILF. They took revenge against the people. Maybe, this is hard to believe but we are trying to ask the government to allow an impartial group, most probably the international monitoring team, to conduct an investigation so we would know, once and for all, what is the truth. It should be an impartial group so that nobody doubts the result of the investigation.

The government doesn’t allow this, yet, but this is what we want.

Q: Has there been an investigation done by the MILF leadership as regards the two commanders?

Well it becomes moot and academic. When (the MILF attacks) happened, the government countered. As a result, there were more houses destroyed, more properties of civilians lost, or taken. There were indiscriminate bombings, shelling and excessive use of force in Maguindanao and Lanao del Norte. So (to investigate our two commanders) becomes moot and academic. But still, the MILF would want the incident, the killing of the civilians, investigated. There should be justice for all victims of the attacks.

If we have to count the number of casualties, only one percent died among the settlers. There were more casualties on our part. I can cite to you some examples. In Manili massacre (which happened in 1971), 72 Muslims died, in the Tabuk Massacre and the Kauswagan Massacre, 73. In Palengla (1974), 1000 Moros were massacred inside the mosque, in Pata Island (1981), 2000 Moros, in Patikul, 700.

Were they given justice? I’m not saying the death of those killed in Lanao del Norte meant nothing because they must also be given justice. But first, you have to give justice to the Moro. Our people have been denied justice for far too long.


Q: We read in the MILF website www.luwaran.com that the MILF is already dealing with the two commanders. May we know some updates regarding the actions that the MILF has taken on them?

Well, we don’t want to imitate the government of the Philippines, during the February 4 massacre in Maimbung, (Sulu) early this year, where 15 civilians were killed.

The Human Rights Commission (sic) found the Marines responsible for or guilty of the crime but later, the Armed Forces of the Philippines came up with its own investigating team and came out with a report that the Marines were not guilty.

That is why we are saying, it should not be the CHR who should investigate because it is still an agency of the government. And besides, the findings might be reversed.

As to our commanders, we have internal rules to follow. We have our policies, our military discipline. We have the disciplinary board, we have Shariah Court. We should be the judge on this.

Secondly, as to the rules of engagement, the only thing that regulates our relationship with the government is the ceasefire agreement of 1997 and 2001.

In that ceasefire agreement, the opposing parties are responsible for the violations of their own members. If the violators are members of the MILF, then it should be the MILF who punishes them. If it is the government who committed the violation of the ceasefire, then they should deal with their own ranks, too.

There is no rule agreed by both parties in the ceasefire agreement that will require us to turn our erring commanders over to the government. Since there is none, what can we do? The MILF is a revolutionary organization. It has policy, it has ideology, integrity. What will happen to us if we turn them over?

Q: So do you mean that the two commanders had already been dealt with by the MILF leadership?

Well, that is internal to us. If I can cite an example in 2005, the Marines launched attacks in Palembang, Sultan Kudarat, and one of those killed was a member of the 106th (Base Command of the Bangsamoro Islamic Armed Forces) under Ombra Kato.

What Kato did after that was he exacted revenge in Maguindanao. There were soldiers killed. So, because they did a very clear violation of the ceasefire beyond reasonable doubt, we had to suspend the whole unit. We also suspended the direct commanders involved. We suspended them for more than one year.

Now, amid the violations and accusations hurled against government troops, the government refused to punish its men. They only assigned them (the violators) to other places.


Q: So, at least, Sir, there is an assurance that the MILF has already been dealing with the two commanders…

Well basically, that’s more on discipline. We cannot say it (the two commanders’ action) is a criminal act or not. I’m not saying that. But the MILF has to make necessary disciplinary actions against them. (To be continued) (davaotoday.com)

Drilon bares Arroyo’s P13-B pork barrel in 2009 budget

September 28, 2008

By Carla Gomez
Visayas Bureau
First Posted 18:50:00 09/28/2008

BACOLOD CITY — Former Senate president Franklin Drilon bared on Sunday what he called a P13-billion pork barrel allocation for President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo in the 2009 national budget proposal.

Drilon said the P13 billion was inserted into the social service sector budget.

The former senator said the funds to be placed at the President’s disposal consisted of cash assistance, rice subsidies, feeding and nutrition programs under the Department of Social Welfare and Development and the National Nutrition Council.

“It is like writing a blank check (in favor of the President),” said Drilon, currently the president of Liberal Party, who was here to speak in Saturday’s meeting of the Rotary Club of Bacolod Central.

Drilon said that under the 2009 proposed national budget currently being debated on in the House, the “Malusog na Simula, Yaman ng Bansa (Healthy Start, Wealth of the Nation)” Nutrition Program would get a lump sum of P4.3 billion.

A cash dole-out program called Pangtawid Pamilya Pilipino (Cash Subsidy for the Filipino Family) Program has been allocated P5 billion, also in lump sum, he said.

The budget would also include lump-sum allocations of P1 billion for a National Targeting System; P1 billion for the Kalayaan Barangay (Freedom Village) Program Fund; P1 billion for the Kilos Asenso (Movement for Progress) Support Fund; P375 million for the core shelter program; and P2.8 billion for the President’s calamity and contingent fund, he said.

Drilon warned the public that the Department of Agriculture, which has been mired in big-budget irregularities under the Arroyo government, has been allocated P7 billion for the Ginintuang Masagana Ani (Golden Bountiful Harvest) Program, or GMA, including P3.3 billion for fertilizers.

“This is the famous GMA rice and corn program which Jocjoc Bolante transformed into a P728-fertilizer scam during the 2004 election,” he pointed out.

Drilon also revealed allocations of P4.3 billion for farm to market roads, P12.5 billion for irrigation, and P9 billion for seeds, he said.

“The issue here is transparency and accountability. These are blatantly huge sum appropriations, where accountability becomes very difficult, especially considering that 2010 is an election year,” he said.

“There is so much discretion here that the President can use this to favor her political allies and to even to give them as dole outs for amendments to the Constitution,” he said.

Drilon called for a stop to this style of budgeting, which spawned the multi-million-peso fertilizer scam in 2004 that allegedly favored administration candidates and which has been continuing until today as what the Commission on Audit recently revealed.
“Fictitious foundations were made conduits in 2007 for releases of funds, resulting in massive corruption,” he said.

The issue of corruption has been hounding the Arroyo administration, he said, citing the recent survey of the Social Weather Station that placed the President’s popularity rating at negative 38 percent.

“To my mind this is due to corruption and blatant disregard of the rule of law,” he said.

Drilon also took note of a Makati Business Club study, which showed that as much as P29.5 billion in government capital spending was lost annually to corruption.

Citing reports of the World Bank and Transparency International, Drilon said retired Supreme Court Chief Justice Artemio Panganiban wrote that the “Philippines is perceived as the most corrupt in Asia and among the worst in the world.”

Drilon echoed Panganiban’s assessment that massive corruption in government has been aggravating poverty and social inequities in the country.

He cited the government’s Family Income and Expenditures Survey showing that no less than five million Filipino families have been living below the poverty line, compared to only four million Filipino families in 2003.

This means that for every 100 Filipinos, at least 33 are very poor, according to Drilon.

No less than 10 million of the country’s labor force is unemployed and underemployed today, and 7.5 million Filipinos are abroad for lack of employment opportunities in the Philippines, official figures cited by Drilon show.

The national budget, which has been pegged at P1.4 trillion for 2009, would be critical to solving poverty and it would be important for the public to be vigilant about where their taxes would go, the former senator said.

Drilon warned about the growing frustration, hopelessness and disappointment among the people because “nobody gets jailed for the well-documented corrupt deals” and the administration “consistently displayed a knack for ignoring the rule of law just to have a firm grip on power.”

This, he said, was manifested in the recent outcry over the Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain with the Moro Islamic Liberation Front.

Drilon has gone to the Supreme Court to question the legality of the MOA. The Supreme Court might decide on the case by next week, he said.

Razon headed to NSC–Palace source

September 28, 2008

By Christine Avendaño
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 19:47:00 09/28/2008

MANILA — President Macapagal-Arroyo is poised to appoint newly retired Philippine National Police Director General Avelino Razon to the National Security Council (NSC), a Malacañang source has revealed.

“Razon will be a deputy to National Security Adviser Norberto Gonzales at the NSC,” said the official, who asked not to be identified for not having been assigned to speak on the matter.

Razon retired from the police service on Sept. 27 and was replaced by Deputy Director General Jesus Versoza.

But both Gonzales and Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita could not confirm Razon’s appointment to the NSC.

“I have no idea,” Ermita said.

In a separate phone interview, Gonzales said on Sunday he had not been apprised of Razon’s appointment.

But if it were true that Razon was going to the NSC, then he would be appointed deputy director general, according to Gonzales, who is director general of the agency.

Gonzales said Razon’s entry to the NSC would be welcome as “he has a reputation of being a good police officer.’’

Actually, Gonzales said, he already had something in mind for Razon should he be named to the NSC.

He said that with his police experience, Razon could look into the sudden rise in petty crimes in the country, a common complaint made to him by local government executives.

“I promised to look at it and this could be a good opportunity should General Razon come in,’’ Gonzales said.

Gonzales has lost three deputies — retired Gen. Victor Mayo, Pedro Cabuay, who is now chief of the National Intelligence Coordinating Agency, and retired Gen. Romeo Tolentino, who is going to the Philippine National Oil Co.

His deputies now include Senior Deputy Adviser Milo Ibrado, Deputy Adviser Luis “Chavit” Singson and Arturo Lomibao, another former PNP chief.

Gonzales said Singson would like to do special assignments while Lomibao has been assigned to anti-terrorism work.

===========

My Take:

Now, at least we see loyalty here.  PGMA is more loyal to PDSP than to the military.  Razon as Gonzales’ deputy?  Can Mamang Pulis stomach that kind of insult?

Just asking…

Road toward 2010 to be bumpy with Cha-cha–US think-tank

September 28, 2008

By Doris Dumlao
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 20:35:00 09/28/2008

MANILA — The Philippines’ political scene is facing a rough road ahead toward the 2010 presidential elections due to fresh initiatives to tinker with the 1987 Constitution and heightened economic risks from the global financial crisis, according to a New York-based think tank.

But remittances from overseas Filipino workers would continue to keep the domestic economy afloat, Global Source said in a paper titled “Minefields on the Road to 2010” dated Sept. 26.

“The road to the 2010 presidential election is not expected to be a smooth one,” said the commentary written by Filipino economists Romeo Bernardo and Marie-Christine Tang.

Mounting a Charter change (Cha-cha) initiative, even if eventually blocked or pulled back, is seen as a way to save President Macapagal-Arroyo from becoming a “lame duck” during her remaining 20 months in office.

“Thus, this is a no-lose strategy for the leadership,” the paper said.

While local financial markets have been able to shrug off these political developments until now, Global Source said “it would be rash though to discount current moves as mere political noise.”

It reckoned that amending the Constitution would be a difficult process. “This is something that its crafters in all likelihood intended. Several previous failed attempts, going back to the 1990s during the time of President Ramos, attest to this,” it said.

The think tank also noted that the outlook for global growth dimmed since the most recent US financial crisis, which was expected to affect developing countries’ exports and growth prospects.

“Higher domestic inflation can exert pressure on wages anew, which firms may not be able to accommodate at this time given the poor business climate. This may lead to some labor unrest, increasing political tension further,” the report said.

But unlike in the 1980s when a confluence of unfavorable external conditions and internal political turmoil led to a debt crisis and the end of the 20-year Marcos regime, Global Source expressed confidence that remittances would continue to provide “buffer from the storm.”

Right before Wall Street’s crisis hit the headlines, Global Source observed that Philippine dailies dwelt extensively on Cha-cha ahead of the 2010 presidential elections. There are three ways—people’s initiative, constitutional convention, constituent assembly—to introduce amendments to the Constitution.

The last attempt at Cha-cha, in 2006, went for a people’s initiative, purportedly showing the signatures of some 6.3 million voters favoring amendments, but the initiative was junked by the Supreme Court as a “gigantic fraud.”

Global Source said opposition to Charter change appeared to stem from fears that it was a mere ploy to keep the current administration in power, either through term extension or a shift to a parliamentary form of government that would allow the incumbent to run for prime minister.

Suspicions over motives for Cha-cha led a broad segment of society, which recognized the need to adapt various economic provisions of the Constitution to changing global economic realities, to propose postponing any discussion of amendment to post-2010 election, the paper said.

Global Source also observed that the leadership’s unpopularity fanned suspicions that Cha-cha was intended to preserve political power for the President and her congressional allies (many of whom are also legally impeded from running for reelection) rather than to reflect the public’s will.

“While there is disconnect now between political developments and market movements, we think that the line in the sand for people to take to the streets is any obvious move to tinker with the rules to do away with the 2010 elections,” the report said.

The report also noted that the current leadership was accused of trying to engineer Charter change through a proposed peace pact with the Moro Islamic Liberation Front. The Arroyo administration earlier announced support for Charter change in order to move to a federal system on grounds that this will lead to more responsive governance at the local level.

Global Source said that while there was much controversy on what was seen as creating a state for the Moro people with all its complications, the principal issue for many was that it would open doors for other constitutional changes, specifically moving to a parliamentary system without term limits that would concentrate power in the Lower House and do away with the Senate.

The peace agreement was in the end set aside, the paper said, leading to “unfortunate” consequences for the peace process.

Global Source, nevertheless, noted that members of Congress, allies of the leadership, already put forward an explicit proposal to amend the Constitution and shift to a parliamentary form of government.

This was to be achieved by convening Congress as a constituent assembly where, through a vote of three-fourths of its members, proposed changes would then be submitted to a referendum.

“Cha-cha moves have since gained momentum and more maneuvers may be expected in the coming months,” Global Source said.

While there are many roadblocks, including getting the nod of the Supreme Court and winning the referendum, some quarters believed that the current move would have a fair chance of passing within the relatively short timeframe before 2010, it said.

Some have even conjured up a Marcosian scheme in which emergency rule or martial law will be imposed to obtain the needed majority in the referendum.

Others have argued that a no-election scenario could materialize should current officials be retained during the transition to a parliamentary system.

“Analysts liken recent exercises to a horse race, with the leadership, seeing limited downside, allowing the race to go on and betting on a preferred horse—until events conspire to eliminate it in the running which would then require switching bets to the next preferred horse,” Global Source said.

“That is to say that if opposition, including from the Church, influential business groups and civil society (the groups that in the past have visibly shown outrage and taken people power action that led to the ouster of Marcos in 1986 and resignation of Estrada in 2001), turn out to be strong, the leadership will shift to alternative maneuvers to keep political influence beyond 2010,” it said.

Part of Diwalwal’s 8,100 hectare mining reserve up for bidding

September 28, 2008

DAVAO CITY—Oliver Butalid, the president of the Philippine Mining Development Corporation (PMDC) announced the upcoming public bidding for the Upper Ulip Paraiso in Diwalwal for large-scale mining investors.

Butalid said the government corporation has set the deadline for the submission of prequalification bidding requirements on October 14 this year. “We want to draw as many participants as possible,” he said.

He said the bidding is expected to draw large-scale foreign firms because the mining site of Upper Ulip and Paraiso are “very attractive mining investments” in Diwalwal with the highest value at present.

But Butalid, in a mining summit here, continued to deny earlier reports on the secret deal allegedly signed between the government and the Chinese firm ZTE, a subsidiary of the NBN-ZTE company that figured in the alleged bribery scandal of the present administration.

“I have denied it for the nth time,” Butalid said. “I assure you all our deals are transparent. I don’t know why it keeps coming back on the papers.”

He said PMDC could not open the area for bidding if the reported MOU with the ZTE were already a done deal.

Upper Ulip and Paraiso is located directly above the gold rush area of Diwalwal, which the government has opened to big mining firms because drilling in the area is already beyond the capacity of small scale miners.

He said that the government offer can be very attractive because the mining firm that will win the bid can already start exploration as soon as it is awarded the contract. “They can start as soon as they’re awarded the contract because the environment clearance certificate in the area has already been secured,” he said.

Once operation starts, the mining company will pay a royalty of five per cent minimum content fee of US$5.5 million.

“We open the bidding to foreign companies and local companies who will qualify,” Butalid said, “We hope to draw as many bidders as possible because the area at its highest value at present, a very attractive property.”

PMDC, a government owned and controlled corporation took over the operation of Diwalwal mines.

Butalid said that the corporation is also talking with tunnel owners outside the gold rush area to make their operations legal. “We want them to make their operations more viable, we want them to reduce cost, by convincing them to become contractual partners of PMDC,” he said.

Government has declared the 8,100 hectares, which included the gold rush site of Diwalwal, as a mineral reserve, taking over full control of its operation. Government has divided the area into three zones, the 729 hectare gold rush site operated by the small miners, another zone open for large scale investors and the tribal section, where indigenous peoples who formerly owned the land are allowed to operate. (Germelina Lacorte/davaotoday.com)

AFP eyes supplemental budget for Mindanao war

September 28, 2008

By Nikko Dizon
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 20:37:00 09/28/2008

MANILA — The Armed Forces has stressed the need to replenish the ammunition of soldiers in Central Mindanao in order to sustain its pursuit operations against commanders of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF), who had led attacks on civilian communities.

“If we are to sustain our operations and increase our operational tempo, there is a need to replenish our expended ammunition,” Lieutenant Colonel Ernesto Torres, Jr. told reporters on Sunday.

Asked if there was a need for a supplemental budget for the military campaign, Torres said “it may be expected” but quickly added that he had no detailed information yet on the “request of the Armed Forces regarding this campaign.”

The defense department has proposed a P56.54 billion regular budget for 2009, more than half of which is for the Philippine Army whose troops are in the frontlines of the government’s campaigns against communist and Muslim insurgencies.

Torres said that in the last one-and-a-half months of operations in Central Mindanao, the military already expended a significant amount of ammunition.

The soldiers’ continued mobility needed to be ensured as well, Torres said, pointing out that the military recently lost a C-130 Hercules cargo plane in a devastating crash last August.

“We will proportionately increase our operational tempo so as not to allow the LMGs (lawless MILF groups) to hurt more people and destroy more properties,” Torres said, when asked if fighting could intensify with the end of the holy month of Ramadan in a few days.

In a separate statement, the Philippine Navy said on Sunday that its Landing Tank, BRP Benguet (LT507), left the Navy port in Cavite on Sunday to transport 220 tons of ammunition and 23 Army vehicles in support of the operations in Mindanao.

There were also relief goods for the soldiers under the 103rd, 104th and 403rd Brigades in Iligan City from the AFP Civil Relations Service office, said Capt. Leopoldo Alano, commander of the Naval Task Force 80, in the press statement.

The ship also brought truckloads of relief goods for typhoon victims in Visayas and evacuees displaced by the fighting in Mindanao.

The military is hunting down MILF commanders Ameril Ombra Kato, Abdullah Macapaar alias Bravo, and Aleem Sulaiman Pangalian who led their men in a rampage in North Cotabato, Lanao del Norte, and Saranggani province last August in protest of the scuttled signing of the agreement on ancestral domain between the government and the Moro rebel group.

The MILF rebels’ attacks left scores of civilians dead and displaced hundreds and thousands of residents in the impoverished Central Mindanao provinces.

==========

My Take:

Now what?

After commiting grave humn rights abuses and killing civilians with thier aerial bombings, they want us to shell out more money to sustain their wrong doings?

Just asking…

CA dismisses murder case vs detained, tortured pastor

September 28, 2008

By Leila Salaverria
Philippine Daily Inquirer
First Posted 21:51:00 09/28/2008

MANILA — The Court of Appeals has ordered the dismissal of a murder case filed against a Protestant pastor who had accused police of beating him up while he was in detention.

The appellate court’s third division, in a September 23 ruling penned by Justice Martin Villarama Jr., said the Bacoor regional trial court failed to conduct a proper preliminary investigation of the charge against Pastor Berlin Guerrero of the United Church of Christ in the Philippines.

The appellate court said Guerrero was not given the chance to refute the allegations against him and was not notified of the proceedings in the murder case.

It criticized Carmona municipal circuit trial court Judge Myrna Lim-Verano, who handled the preliminary investigation of the murder case, for not giving Guerrero the chance to defend himself and allowing the case to proceed despite weak evidence.

It also pointed out that Guerrero had been living normally and publicly, carrying out his duties as pastor, when the case was revived after 15 years. It supported the claims of the pastor, who was arrested in May 2007, that he was abducted, physically tortured, interrogated and accused of being a communist and leftist leader.

“The Court cannot condone such injustice and travesty of rights of an ordinary citizen charged with a serious crime during and after preliminary investigation when the information based on an invalid proceeding had been filed in court. The patent disregard of the laws and rules in the conduct of preliminary investigation by the investigating Judge clearly constitutes grave abuse of discretion that warrants the exercise of this Court’s corrective power,” it said in a September 23 ruling.

Justices Noel Tijam and Arturo Tayag of the third division, concurred with the decision penned by Villarama.

It came weeks after the appellate court also ordered the provisional release of Guerrero to former Senate president Jovito Salonga and his lawyer, Emilio Capulong, while deliberating on his petition that sought to dismiss the murder case against him.

When the order for release came, Guerrero had been in detention for more than a year.

In its decision, the appellate court said Lim-Verano violated the then-prevailing 1985 Rules of Procedure when she failed to subpoena Guerrero so that he could study the case and refute the allegations against him.

It also said Lim-Verano just took note of the fact that the pastor did not file his counter-affidavit, and allowed the case to proceed despite weak evidence.

“Such actuation betrays Judge Lim-Verano’s disregard of the accused’s basic right to due process, which is particularly appalling considering her awareness of the weak evidentiary basis for probable cause against accused Berlin Guerrero,” it said.

The court added that Lim-Verrano accepted the witness’ sworn statement as sufficient without the witness being brought before her.

The appellate court also cited the Supreme Court decision that had dismissed the government’s rebellion cases against militant lawmakers because political considerations had tainted the Department of Justice’s preliminary investigation of the complaints.

It said the ruling stressed that procedures for preliminary investigations should be followed scrupulously to protect people’s rights.

Although generally, criminal proceedings could not be stopped, exceptions were given when the proceedings turned into a case of prosecution, the court said.

The Court of Appeals pointed to an ongoing campaign by the judiciary to uphold human rights in the light of abuses committed by the military and police in their counter-insurgency operations.

Arroyo to intensify bid for stay in power in 2009–Drilon

September 28, 2008

By Carla Gomez
Visayas Bureau
First Posted 21:54:00 09/28/2008

BACOLOD CITY — Former Senate President Franklin Drilon warned the public on Sunday of intensified efforts by the Arroyo administration to amend the Constitution and extend the term of President Macapagal-Arroyo in the last 12 months before the 2010 polls.

Drilon said he was challenging Ms Arroyo to say that she was not in favor of any term extension, lifting of term limits and amending the Constitution in the remaining months of her administration.

Drilon, who is also chair of the Liberal Party, also challenged Vice President Noli de Castro, Senate President Manuel Villar and Speaker Prospero Nograles to state that they would oppose any amendment to the Constitution before 2010. “That is the only way by which the people can be comfortable,” he said at a press conference here.

Any Charter change (Cha-cha) should be done after 2010 when the country’s leadership would have a fresh mandate, he said.

Drilon said amending the Constitution before 2010 could only be perceived as an attempt to extend Ms Arroyo’s stay in power.

The people, he said, “will not accept that.”

A House committee on constitutional amendments headed by La Union Rep. Victor Francisco Ortega has started hearing proposed amendments to the Constitution. Drilon said he was informed that the instructions of the Speaker was for congressmen to consult with their constituencies before Nov. 30.

The proposed amendments included a resolution filed by Nograles that purportedly proposed only amendments to the economic provisions of the Constitution, he said.

But Drilon said it would be easy to suspect that this was just a ruse and that the ultimate objective was to amend the Constitution to extend the President’s term.

“I would predict that the issue of whether or not both chambers will vote separately or jointly (on the proposed amendments) when they convene themselves as a constituent assembly will be brought to the Supreme Court by January of 2009,” he said.

Drilon said that with six vacancies in the Supreme Court in 2009, “the temptation to pack the Supreme Court with partisan justices will very tempting because of this issue of amendments to the Constitution.”

“It is up to the people to be vigilant against any sinister move to amend the Constitution next year,” he said.

Environmentalists increasingly anxious over the effects of mining in Davao Gulf

September 28, 2008

DAVAO CITY—A top official of the island garden city of Samal cracked a joke about the fish of Davao Gulf before a recent mining conference here to raise a point on the need to protect the environment amidst the flurry of activities in mining.

“The fish that we’re going to eat for lunch already contains an intolerable level of cyanide,” Samal vice mayor Orly Amit said in jest, as he presented the environment group results after a workshop at the Waterfront Hotel here. “We’re going to eat it all, even those of us involved in mining.”

Participants composed of foreign and local mining executives and government officials burst out laughing but Amit said everything in Davao Gulf will be affected once mining go full blast without strong regard for the environment.

“Even if we don’t have mines on Samal island, we are all affected so we have to join hands together,” he said. “The fish in Davao Gulf doesn’t stay in one place, you know, it can also reach Governor Malanyaon’s city of Mati and other parts of the ocean.”

He defined responsible mining as “borrowing the land from future generation,” that’s why those who are involved have to make sure to safeguard the environment to “eventually return it safe and sound” in the future. He earned applause from the pro-mining participants, who vowed to only allow responsible mining in Davao Gulf.

Environment groups, however, are not easily convinced.

Jo Villanueva, member of the nationwide group Alyansa Tigil Mina, said that without sufficient safeguards put in place, there is always a danger of government restrictions being ignored. “How can DENR (Department of Environment and Natural Resources), for instance, monitor all of 300 mining permit holders in the country?” Villanueva said in another forum joined in by anti-mining groups.

Villanueva said that groups opposed to the entry of foreign mining in the country is now circulating a draft proposal for an alternative mining bill that will not threaten the environment and safeguard food security in the country. “It will address issues which were missed out in the 1995 Philippine Mining Act, that allowed the entry of big foreign mining firms in the country,” she said.

Among others, the draft bill will require stringent implementation of environment and land use laws to ensure that mining companies will not leave a tail of disasters in areas where they operate, she said. It will also call for actual, and not just token, participation of the communities in the mining projects.

“Most of all, we will no longer allow the entry of foreign mining firms,” Villanueva said.

Although there seems to be a hype in the mining activities in the country, Villanueva said that most of the companies applying mining permits are mere prospectors who do not really plan to embark in actual mining projects but are only waiting for a chance to sell their mining permits to big mining firms.

She also said that most foreign mining firms are also using these prospectors to clear the area and only decide to come in later after these “social issues” are ironed out.

Rep. Lorenzo Tanada III, a member of the committee on the environment in the House of Representatives agreed. “There seems to be a lot of selling here and there, no matter whether there is an actual deposit or not in the area,” Tanada said in the anti-mining forum at the Grand Menseng Hotel.

He said that government only tried to assuage the fear of civic organizations about the adverse impact of mining in the environment. “Even the so-called community participation and community consultations are nothing but lip service,” he said, “In cases where communities are strongly against mining, they’re actually being ignored.”

Victor Agustin, the regional director of the National Economic Development Authority (Neda) earlier complained that the mining industry has been attracting only a few “real” investors despite the opening of the country to foreign mining firms.

Agustin said that most of those who applied for mining permits were only speculators who were not really planning to go into actual mining projects.

He said that the jobs targeted for mining in the Davao region failed to meet their midterm targets because the actual activities in mining were not really as good as their projections.

“A lot of speculators who don’t know anything about the technical implications are selling mining areas to global corporations whose only interest is to rake profits,” said Villanueva.

She said that the mergers and acquisitions frequently happening among global mining companies these days aggravate these threats, considering the loose implementation of environment laws in the country.

“It’s becoming such a very risky business,” said Villanueva, “We’re becoming subject to the whims of the global market. In the communities, mining is not just about profit,” she said. “It’s about the survival.” (Germelina Lacorte/.davaotoday.com)

Editorial Cartoon: Ganti-Ganti Lang

September 28, 2008

Their day tehee!

Photos: Tagaytay 5 Salo-Salo

September 28, 2008

HULING LAGAPAK NG KANDADO

ni Axel Pinpin

Kumupas at kumupis ang kalendaryo
Kumalampag at ipininid ang kandado
Kumupad at bumilis ang oras
Nagasgas at numipis ang rehas
Dumatal at umalis ang lamig
Sumagad at umibis ang init
Nangutya at tiniis ang inip
Nanuya at nanikis ang inis

Walong daan at limampu’t siyam na araw
Paulit-ulit, paikid-ikid lamang na galaw

Dalawang taon at apat na buwan
Pabalik-balik, paikit-ikit lamang na kawalan

Ninakaw, inagaw ang kalayaang inakalang
maitatangkal sa kalaliman ng kadiliman
ng libingan ng mga buhay at matatabunan
ng tambak ng batas na butas
na nauna pang maagnas at ipag-aguniyas
ang kamatayan ng sirkerong testigo na di-bihasa
sa kinabisang panulayan at panimbangan.
Ay! Nagkandudulas sa lubid ng kasinungalingang
ibinuhol ng buhong na piskal, nagkandabulol
at nagkandahulog ang katwiran
na nagiging mahika-blanka
sa tuwing kabulaanan ang bumubulagang
sorpresa sa kahon ng ebidensya at hindi
kunehong puti na sana’y mabilis at malinis
na lilinlang sa namanghang mga
mamamayang bantay sa katarungan
sa sala ng Hukom na nagmistulang karnabal.

Walong daan at limampu’t siyam na araw
Paulit-ulit, paikid-ikid lamang na galaw

Dalawang taon at apat na buwan
Pabalik-balik, paikit-ikit lamang na kawalan

At sa isang iglap, walang nakakurap,
Tapos na ang palabas!

*Kalalaya lamang ng awtor mula sa bilangguan noong Agosto 28, 2008. Si Pinpin ay kabilang sa tinaguriang ‘Tagaytay 5′ na hinuli at ibinilanggo ng mga pulis noong Abril 28, 2006 dahil sa kasong ‘ rebelyon’ na sa huli’y ibinasura ng korte.

CASE NO: 00001

PETITIONERS: Raymond Manalo, et. al

RESPONDENTS: The Secretary of National Defense, the Chief of Staff, Armed Forces of the Philippines

DATE FILED: 8-23-07 (filed with SC)

PERSONS IN WHOSE FAVOR THE WRIT IS BEING SOUGHT: Raymond Manalo and Reynaldo Manalo

PERSONALITY: sons of Rolando Manalo, also known as Ka Bestre, political activist

NOTE: Originated as a special proceedings for habeas corpus commenced on 5-12-06; decision of the Court of Appeals was elevated to the Supreme Court; petition was considered as a petition for the writ of amparo after the Amparo Rule took effect on 10-27-07.

ALLEGATIONS:

On 2-14-06, unidentified armed men [allegedly military personnel and Citizens Armed Forces Geographical Unit (CAFGU) auxillaries] forcibly took the petitioners from their home in Bulacan. During torture, the soldiers asked Raymond if he was a member of the NPA; where his comrades were, how many soldiers he had killed and how (many) NPA members he had helped. Gen. Palparan allegedly talked to them to tell their parents never to attend the hearing [on the Petition for Habeas Corpus], rallies and not to seek help from the Karapatan and the “Human Right.” Raymond was brought to his house to talk to his parents. One Hilario also told his parents that if they disobey, they will not see their children again. On 8-13-07, the petitioners escaped. The Court of Appeals, in its Decision of 21-26-07, granted the privilege of the Writ of Amparo.

DECISION/REMARKS:

  1. Promulgated 12-26-07 – Privilege of Amparo GRANTED; Writ Petition for Review on Certiorari file before the Supreme Court.

  1. Petition filed 8-23-07

  1. Decision 12-26-07

- Privilege of the Writ of Amapro GRANTED

- The respondents SECRETARY OF NATIONAL DEFENSE and AFP CHIEF OF STAFF are hereby REQUIRED:

1) To furnish to the petitioners and to this Court within five days from notice of this decision all official and unofficial reports of the investigation undertaken in connection with their case, except those already on file herein;

2) To confirm in writing the present places of official assignment of M/Sgt Hilario aka Rollie Castillo, and Donal Caigas within five days from notice of this decision.

3) To cause to be produced to this Court all medical reports, records and charts, reports of any treatment given or recommended and medicines prescribed, if any, to the petitioners, to include a list of medical and personnel (military and civilian) who attended to them from February 14, 2006 until August 12, 2007 within five days from notice of this decision.”

————–

Press Release – August 28, 2008

Dismissal of trumped-up charges and release of Tagaytay 5, a victory for human rights – KARAPATAN

The human rights alliance KARAPATAN expressed elation over the release of Tagaytay 5 and the dismissal of the trumped-up rebellion raps filed against them.

“The dismissal of trumped-up charges and release of Tagaytay 5 is a victory for human rights,” said Ruth Cervantes, KARAPATAN Public Information Officer.

Aris Sarmiento, Axel Pinpin, Riel Custodio, Michael Masayes and Rico Ybañez, collectively known as the Tagaytay 5 were released from prison at 4PM today, August 28 (Thursday).

Cervantes said of the decision to dismiss the case and free the five, “The stroke of the judge’s pen is a vindication of our conviction that those who work for a better society must not be criminalized and must be set free.”

“We congratulate those who have worked for the freedom of Tagaytay 5 and those who continue to fight the Arroyo regime’s sinister moves to foist false cases against social activists who fight for people’s rights,” Cervantes said.

KARAPATAN welcomes Tagaytay 5 to their new-found freedom and urged them to file criminal charges against state security forces that abducted them, kept them incommunicado and detained them despite their innocence.

“Human rights violations continue to be committed under this regime and it is justified to fight back and combat impunity,” Cervantes said.

KARAPATAN also reiterated their call to implement UN Special Rapporteur Philip Alston’s recommendations to abolish the Inter-Agency Legal Action Group (IALAG) that is orchestrating the fabrication of criminal charges against activists and critics of the Arroyo regime.###

KUNG PAANO PASLANGIN ANG PAGKABAGOT SA LOOB NG KARSEL

ni Alex Pinpin

Ipunin ang agiw sa kisameng kabelya
At isupot sa plastik ng rasyong patola.

Is-isin ang lagkit sa malamig na pader
At kulapulan ng irap ang nakahubong poster.

Dangkalin ang sahig at kunin ang distansya
Ng langit at impyernong tinamasa sa lupa.

Aralin ang kultura ng ipis, langgam at daga,
Ihambing sa buhay mong sa bilibid nakalungga.

Magsubo ng sigarilyo pero huwag sindihan
Hayaang maluray sa ngitngit ng bagang.

Magbunot ng balbas at idikit sa salamin,
Tarahan ang araw nang kawalang-kapiling.

Sagutan ang crossword, Su Doku’t blind item;
Makipagsagutan sa bantay, kalampagin ang karsel.

Taluntunin ang radyo at makinig sa drama,
Lumiham kay Tiya Dely at magpadala ng tula.

Maghinuko, maghiso, maligo at maghinuli;
Masdan ang kuko, ngipin, katawan at hinugasang budhi.

Humiga nang patihaya saka dume-kuwatro.
(Ganito ang sunod na gawin, pero wag magpabuko:)

Hintaying magka-agiw ang ipis sa kisame, sipingan ang langgam sa dingding;
Makipagniig sa daga sa sahig, sigarilyo’y muling sipsipin.

Kapain ang kinis ng pisngi, ikumot ang bali-balita;
Wag nang buhayin ang radyo, palayain ang diwa.

At saka ka makipaghabulan sa bagal ng oras
At sa di-maabutang kupad nang gulong ng batas.

(Mapapawi ngayon ang limbo ng iyong panglaw
At malilimutan mong wala na sa iyong dumadalaw.)


ON THE RELEASE (Finally!) OF THE TAGAYTAY FIVE

Today, e-mails went back and forth with the happy news that Riel R. CUSTODIO, Aristides Q. SARMIENTO, Axel Alejandro A.PINPIN, Enrico Y. YBANEZ, and Michael M. MASAYES, collectively known as the “Tagaytay Five,” have all been released from detention and that the rebellion charges against them have been dismissed in court!

It has been a difficult period for these political prisoners from the day of their illegal arrest in April 28, 2006 and all throughout their detention. They were tortured, rendered incommunicado and denied counsel for days after their arrest, subjected to inhumane prison conditions and plagued with numerous delays to have their day in court. For their work with the peasants and farmers, they have been targeted and vilified as terrorists. As political prisoners, they were treated by the military and the government as being guilty until proven innocent.

Men of lesser principles would have succumbed to despair but not these men. The “Tagaytay Five” fought with the weapons they wielded behind bars – their fasting and hunger strike, their poetry, and their militancy. Their fierce determination and strong faith that pressure from inside and outside of prison would ultimately unlock their prison doors never wavered.

While the judicial ruling released the “Tagaytay Five,” we see this order as the culmination of the arduous campaign that these detainees, their families, supporters, human rights groups and people’s organizations have worked on for over two years.

Truth is stronger than evil. Truth outweighs lies and falsehoods anytime, anywhere. Truth finds allies and friends everywhere in the world. And the “Tagaytay Five” proved just that.

However, justice for these detainees will not be complete until punishment is meted out to those state security forces who abducted them, tortured them, kept them incommunicado and detained them despite their innocence. The unjust detention has caused the detainees and their families a lot of emotional suffering as well. No less than the Commission on Human Rights recently recommended the filing of criminal and administrative charges against the Cavite Police and the Naval Intelligence and Security Force for human rights violations committed against the “Tagaytay Five.” It is time that the military learn that they are not above the law.

We join the “Tagaytay Five” and their families in their celebration of their freedom from detention.

29 August 2008
CANADA-PHILIPINES SOLIDARITY FOR HUMAN RIGHTS (CPSHR) Vancouver, B.C. Canada
Email: cps_hr@yahoo.ca

DA MISADBENTYUR OP BILLY

ni Axel Pinpin

Humagunot ang hagot ng putok

magkalabang panig ay napalunok

isa man sa kanila’y walang tepok

Pak-pak! Lagapak ang rat-ratan

nang sa gitna’y may tumimbwang

Hiyaw: Huwag! ‘Wag! Si Billy yan!

Nag-init ang daliri sa gatilyo

ang malansang dugo ay sumubo

Patay! Sabing si Billy yan! Hesusmiyo!

Nag-ceasefire: tumambak ang kaswalti

Kulang ang body bag para kay Billy.

ANADER MISADBENTYUR OP BILLY

ni Axel Pinpin

Dalwampung magsasaka’y dinakip

Kinargang parang baboy sa dyip

Ser! Si Billy yan! Hesusmaryosep!

Limang biyahero’y diniskaril

sa Camp Vicente Lim ay ikinarsel

Nakupo! Sinabing si Billy yan. Ser!

Patas ang bilang ng pinapaslang,

Dinukot at nasa bilangguan

Susme! Si Billy yan! Si Billy yan!

Binuriki ng baril ang lawanit

dugo ni Billy ang sumilarit

INA KA NAMIN

ni Axel Pinpin

O, Inang Gloriang maluwalhati

Ina ka ng lahat

Ina ng awa

Sa kayraming naging kaawa-awa

Ina ng laging saklolo

Sa iyong asawa, anak, kaanak, inaanak

O, Ina, Ina ka ng lahat

Kaina-Inahan kang nagluwal ng

Inalipin

Inaba

Inapi

Inabuso

Inaglahi

Inagawan

Inalimura

Inalipusta

Inakupu! Tanging Ina ka namin

Bukod tangi ka nang walang inamin.

Arkibong Bayan

Movie Review: Stop-Loss

September 28, 2008

Movie Review: Stop-Loss

Cast: Ryan Philippe, Abbie Cornish, Channing Tatum, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Ciaran Hinds, Timothy Oliphant, Victor Rasuk, Rob Brown, Josef Sommer, Linda Emond,

Directed by: Kimberly Pierce

Ang Stop-Loss ay pelikulang tumatalakay sa isang partikular na sitwasyong kinasadlakan ng libu-libong sundalong Amerikanong ipinadala para manalakay sa bansang Iraq.

Ang stop-loss ay isang terminong ginagamit sa sandatahang lakas ng Amerika na ang ibig sabihin ay “pagpigil sa pag-alis ng isang batikang sundalo” (stop the loss of good soldiers).

Ang stop-loss ay ginagawa sa mga sundalong nakapagtapos ng kanilang kontrata (kung saan isinasaad ang isang takdang haba ng panahon ng kanyang paggampan ng tungkulin) at nakatakdang umalis na sa serbisyo. Karaniwan itong ginagawa sa mga sundalong naging epektibo sa paggampan sa mga utos na ibinababa sa kanila ng kanilang mga kumander.

Ang Stop-Loss ay sumubok na sumubaybay sa buhay ng isang karakter na paalis na sana ng Army. Matapos ang kanyang matagumpay na kampanya (tagumpay dahil siya’y buhay), sarado na ang isip niya sa pagbabalik sa tungkulin at pagpatay ng mga sibilyan. Ngunit sa araw ng kanyang pag-alis, nalaman niyang siya pala ay na-stop-loss.

Ninanis ng Stop-Loss na ipakita sa lahat na ang Pangulo ng Amerika ang pinaka-numero unong terorista sa mundo. Una kasi sa lahat ng kanyang mga biktima, ay ang kanyang mga matitino at batikang sundalo lalo na pag oras ng digma. Ipinakita ng pelikula na ang pumirma sa kontratang nagsasaad ng isang takdang haba ng panahong serbisyo ng sundalo, at ang lansakang pagpapawalang-bisa sa kontratang ito sa pamamagitan ng stop-loss , ay ang pangulo ng Amerika mismo.

Ninais din ng Stop-Loss na ipahayag na may mga matitinong sundalo ang tumuligsa at walang takot na lumaban sa ganitong klaseng militaristang patakaran. Ngunit ayon sa Stop-Loss, wala ni isa man sa kanila ang nabigyan ng katarungan, pinanigan ng batas, at tinulungan ng mga taga-gobyernong nauna nang nagdeklara sa kanila bilang mga “bayani ng Amerika.”

Ang ilang hindi yumukod sa presyur ng military at pamahalaang Amerika, ay napilitang magtago at manirahan sa Mehiko. Ang ilan, tulad ng nangyari sa pangunahing karakter ng pelikula, ay napilitang bumalik sa serbisyo, at buong tapang na lunukin ang kanyang pagkatao.

Ngunit ang Stop-Loss ay hindi nagbigay ng paghuhusga sa karakter na ito. Bagkus, tinapos ang Stop-Loss sa pamamagitan ng mga tekstong naglalahad kung ilampung libong sundalong Amerikano ang nabiktima ng stop-loss, at kung ilampung libong bagong tropa ang ipinadala pa ng pangulo ng Amerika para manalakay at manupil sa Iraq.

Ang Stop-Loss kung gayon ay isang pelikulang nananawagan ng katarungan para sa hanay ng mga sundalong Amerikano. Ang Stop-Loss ay isang pelikulang tumutuligsa sa mapanupil na patakarang militar ng Amerika

Mensahe ng Stop-Loss: “Stop the Loss of American Life, Stop the Loss of Human Life, Stop the War”

Panambitan / Elehiya para kay Ka Leony

September 28, 2008

NI E. SAN JUAN, JR.
Inilathala ng Bulatlat

(In Memoriam: Maria Theresa “Cherith” Dayrit-Garcia (1957-2000); Unang Pagsubok)

Nakahimpil kami noon pansamantala kina Helen nang mabalitaang nangyari nga–
ang dating ng balita’y pagkagulat
sandaling sumalisi ang di pagkapaniwala
sumapot ang lagim at bigat ng panghihinayang….

Nabuwal ka noong 16 Hulyo 2000 sa sitio Bagis, baryo Napoleong, Isabela–
di katulad dito sa hardin ng Root Glen, dating lupaing inaruga ng tribung Oneida,
doo’y tiyak na masukal madawag hitik sa anumang maaaring tumubo
sagana sa araw hayup ganda–kahit ano’y mabubuhay doon sa gubat–
Ngunit bawat kurba ng landas dito’y nagpapagunita ng iyong pagkamatay….

Mariing bira tila matinding sampal
Kumikirot pa rin hanggang ngayon
Di matiis hanggang utak ay namanhid

Sa burol mo’y nagpugay ang madla maraming kasama sa Macliing at iba’t ibang dako
Taos-pusong parangal sa iyong kabayanihan
mula sa masang pinaghandugan mo ng buhay
Ngunit maari bang mabatid
ang halaga ng isang inialay na buhay tulad ng sa iyo?
Sinong makatatarok ng iyong paghahandog, ng iyong payak at likas na pagkatao?

Sadyang nagbabago’t nag-iiba ang buhay ng isang tao
sandaling sumakabilang-buhay siya
dahil natapos na, binigyan ng kaganapan, ang proseso ng buhay,
at samakatwid ang perspektiba ay naiba na,
sumasaklaw sa buong pag-iral ng tao mula pagsilang hanggang pagkamatay.

Tiyak na lahat tungkol sa iyo, tapos na, lamang di kita makakausap pa o matatanong.
Ngunit bagamat hindi lahat ay malalaman, nasa atin na iyon:
tayo ngayon ang nakataya’t dapat sumipat, tumimbang, sumuri,
kumilatis at maghusga kung kailangan–kakailanganin….
Walang sentimentalismo o daya ng relihiyon, pagbigyan natin siya–
nais kong magpahinga ka, kung pwede?

Sa pagpanaw mo, Ka Leony, pagkaraan ng engkwentro. biglang nawala ka–
Gumulong at sumadsad ang katawan mo sa libis ng bundok
nahulog nagtago’t sumilong sa pusod ng mga bulaklak at bungang nagkalat…
Itinago ng militar ang bangkay mo–
sugatan ka, walang awang pinaslang ka ng militar–
bago isinuko sa asawa’t kamag-anak…
Umuusok pa hanggang ngayon ang punglong bumiyak sa iyong ulo’t dibdib.

Kumikirot pa rin habang tinatahak ang balantok ng landas
Mahapding dagok ang balita nakapangingilo
Pasikut-sikot tayo sa daang ito tumutusok ang pighati
Lumilihis pabaling-baling ang lagusan

Kanlungan ng pag-ibig sa kapwa’y natabunan ng sukal at yagit sa laberinto ng gubat….

Sa bawat sulok ng hardin hinahagilap ang katuturan ng iyong nagawa–
Sinisikap masapol sa pagitan ng mga halaman ang kahulugan ng iyong buhay
Sa tanglaw ng krisis ng diktadurang Marcos hanggang sa kasalukuyang kagipitan–
isang saglit ng katotohanan, iglap ng pagtutuos,
kung saan lahat ay makikilala sa sinag at titig ng sambayanan–
Kailangan bang hukayin sa gunita, ramdam pa hanggang ngayon
ang panghihinayang sa iyong pagkasawi–
Bumabagabag itong interogasyon: Ilan pang kasama ang dapat isakripisyo?
Anong bisa ng pagka-martir? Sila ba’y madaling palitan?
Karapat-dapat ba ang hahalili? Sino ang may desisyon? Sino ang may pananagutan?

Nagsisikip sa galit habang lumiliko lumilihis
Kumikirot ngunit sinisikap magtimpi
Sa bingit ng pangamba di maibsan ang dalamhati

Oo, nagpugay ang madla sa iyong libing, di mabilang na kamag-aral kasama kaibigan
Ngunit–tanong ko muli:
maari bang matarok matimbang ang singularidad mo, Ka Leony?
Nasubukan ka na, ngunit sa lipunan natin, lahat ay komoditi at nabibili,
walang pamantayan o kakayahang kumilatis ito sa halaga ng buhay mo,
laluna sa alyenasyo’t karahasang namamayani–Wala, wala nga….
Paano masusukat ang iyong nagawa’t naisakatuparan sa panahong naglingkod ka sa
kilusan?
Paano makikilatis ang bisa’t bunga ng iyong pakikipagsapalaran?

Kumikirot ang sariwang hiwa ng sugat sa alaala
bagamat malayo itong harding dating bukid na pag-aari ng katutubong Oneida–
lumikas na sila rito
Di matingkalang pagdurusa ng puso’t kamalayan
Sa liku-likong landas anino mo’y mahiwagang pumapatnubay….

Sa mga kapatid mo’t kamag-anak ikaw pa rin ang dating Cherith, hindi nagbago–
kung baga sa bato, matigas pa rin kung baga sa rosas,
mabango’t busilak pa rin–
At tila walang saysay ang partikular na pag-unlad ng iyong isip at konsiyensya
bunga ng ating karanasan sa daigdig na ito–wala nang iba pa–
Ngunit sa kanila, walang kwenta iyon, ikaw ang dating kapatid na laging mahal
at di magbabago magpakailan pa man….
Ngunit bakit pa tayo humihinga kung walang pagbabago’t transpormasyon?
Totoong hindi ka lang kapatid o asawa,
ikaw ay partikular na nilalang, namukadkad at namukod, gumagalaw, kumikilos tulad
ng mga bulaklak–
Hayan, hayun–bawa’t isa’y partikular sa gitna ng palumpon
at natatangi sa pusod ng kalikasan…..
Hinubog ang iyong isip damdamin budhi sa katawang nakihamok sa lungsod at baryong
larangan ng digmaan ng uri sa Gitna’t Hilagang Luzon….
Nagka-ugat at tumubo ang identidad mo
sa isang tiyak na lugar sa isang tiyak na yugto ng kasaysayan ng bansa
at ng progresibong himagsikan ng humanidad laban sa Kapital–
Ibig kong sabihin, sa mundong ito naging Ka Leony ka, nagkaroon ka ng pangalan.

Kumikirot pa rin umaantak sa bawat hakbang
Tinatalunton ang kurba’t ikot ng landas sa hardin ng Root Glen
Pulso ng gunita’y umaalingawngaw
Nagpuputok ang puso sa iyong pagkasawi

Sa dalumat ko’y di kita makilala sa ritwal ng pagdakilang dulot ng Partido’t kapatid
Gaano man taimtim iyon, nawawala ka pa rin sa lilim ng lipunang nabubulok
Nakatago pa rin ang kasiyaan at identidad mo
sa hiwaga ng gubat, sa himig ng dalit taghoy ng kalungkutan sa iyong pagburol-
Dito sa lupang tinubuan ng Indyang Oneida nagninilay ako, ipinaglilirip
kung paano ang isang taong nilikhang tulad mo
ay katulad ng iba, karaniwan ngunit natatangi–
ang konkretong diyalektiko ng partikular at kalahatan–
Kaya nga’t bawat taong nakiramay ay may kanya-kanyang impresyon sa iyo,
iba’t ibang imahen
at kakintalang mailalagom lamang
sa paraan ng materyalismong diyalektikal at istorikal.

Nawawala–sino? Si Ka Leony? O si Ka Ada? Baka si Ka Eryl o si Ka Chiqui?
Sa antak ng dalamhati, paano hahanapin?
Sa hapdi ng lumbay, saan matatagpuan?
Sa masakit na pangungulila, saan? Paano?

Halika’t lakbayin ang agwat ng kahapon at kinabukasan sa liblib na pook sa Root Glen,
Clinton, New York.
Baka matunton ang bakas ni Ka Leony sa aspaltong lansangang bumabagtas dito.
Siyasatin sa likod ng dawag sa labak at dalisdis ng parang at kahuyan
Suriin ang tabing ng mga halaman mga sanga ng punong-kahoy at baging na gumagapang
Imbestigahin ang naiwang labi marka o anumang palatandaan–
kahit bahid ng libag o bakat ng ngipin sa prutas na kinagat–sa pinaghimpilang lugar ng kanyang katawan….
Saliksikin ang mga sulok mga liblib na lagusan
lihim na tawiran nalingid na daan dito sa lupaing napariwara’t
sinamsam ng ganid na dayuhan

Nanlilisik ang mga mata sa bawat butas ng tabing at bigkis ng sukal sa ilang na ito
kung saan ang multo ng mga ninuno ng Oneida ay naggala, dumadalaw….
Galugarin sa kaloob-looban ng gubat ang lihim ng pakikipag-ugnay
upang matarok ang ugat ng pagkatao ni Ka Leony…
upang ang nawawala’y matagpuan….

Hanapin si Ka Leony sa gitna ng masidhing kalungkutang umiiral
Hanapin si Ka Eryl sa kabila ng matinding panaghoy
Hanapin si Ka Ada sa gitna ng pananangis
Hanapin si Ka Chiqui sa pusod ng ligalig at hilahil
Nawawala ba si Ka Cherith? Nawawala ba ang katarungan at kalayaan?

Dahil sa budhi umaasa akong matatamo natin ang minimithing adhika
Bagamat sa isip may lambong ng pag-aalinlangan at balisa
Dahil sa determinasyon, batid kong makakamit natin ang kolektibong panaginip ng
kasarinlan pambansang demokrasya radikal na pagkakapantay-pantay
Bagamat sa isip malabo ang pagsulong sa hinaharap
Dahil sa pangangailangan, lumilingap ako sa pagsapit ng maluwalhating katubusan
Bagamat may pasubali na baka di maganap ang ninanais at pinipithaya sa ating panahon.

Gayunpaman–bakit hindi?–
Mahinahon nating abangan ang pagdating niya sa gilid ng baybayin at dalampasigan
Maingat na antabayanan ang pagsungaw niya sa bunganga ng bangin
dito sa teritoryong nawaglit naihiwalay dating lupang tinubuan ng mga Oneida….

Sa bawat kirot nalalaglag ang mga piraso ng belo’t kortina
Sa bawat hikbi nahahawi ang tabing
Sa bawat hibik natatanggal ang balatkayo
Sa bawat daing nabubuksan at nakikita

Sa pagkawala mo, Ka Leony, umabot ang iyong pahatid:
Isinisiwalat ang krimen at kabuktutan ng rehimeng imperyalista’t komprador–
Ibinubunyag ang kasamaan–916 biktima, 195 dinukot ng Estadong terorista–
Inilalabas ang katiwalian panunulsol panlilinlang ng ordeng naghahari
Sa pagpanaw mo, Ka Leony,
Inilalantad ang kabulukan ng mga nagmamay-aring mapagsamantala–
Sa paglisan mo, Ka Leony,
Itinatambad ang paniniiil pangungulimbat pambubusabos–
Sa pagkamatay mo, Ka Leony,
Itinatampok ang dapat gawin upang maputol ang karahasang naghahari–

Bagamat kumikirot pa rin tumitiim ang hapdi
Ngunit patuloy ang pagtalunton sa mahabang landas
Tumitibok ang pait saklap ngunit sulong pa rin
Bawat hakbang sa matarik na landas
Naisasakatuparan ang nararapat gawin–
O, nagbago ka nga, ikaw nga si Cherith at tunay na walang iba!

Kapit-bisig nating ipagdiwang ang giting at kabayanihan ni Ka Leony–
Ang dakilang birtud ng rebolusyonaryong pakikisangkot at pakikihamok–
Naikubli ng kalikasan ang gerilyang nangahas humamon sa ordeng malupit,
Kinupkop at inalagaan ang tumakas na kaluluwa ng pulang mandirigma
Sa bawat liko’t indayog ng daan dito kapiling ang bansang Oneidang lumalaban–
Kaakbay tayo ni Ka Leony sa masalimuot na pakikibaka–Mabuhay ka, tiwalang kabiyak!
Kadaupang-palad
sa hirap at ligaya,
lungkot at saya,
ng mapagpalayang pakikibaka.

Isang Palatandaan ang Iyong Kamatayan

September 28, 2008

NI TERENCE KRISHNA LOPEZ
Inilathala ng Bulatlat

Wari’y pinipilas
Ang bawat kong kalamnan,
Pinipigtas ang bawat kong ugat
Sa paggunita sa iyo

Anong giting
Anong tapang
Anong tatag
Ng iyong pag-ibig
Na handa’t humarap
Sa digmaan
Tinanganan ang sandata
Para sa bayan

Ah,
Humihikbi ang bawat gabi
May pighati
maging ang mga sandaling
sumusikat ang araw,
nagdadalamhati
sa pagkalagas
ng isang mabuting anak
nilang isinilang.

May hapdi,
May pightai,
Ngunit may ngiting uusbong
Mula sa lupang inagusan
Ng iyong dugo’t kinabuwalan
Ng bata mong katawan.

Ang iyong kamatayan ay
Isang palatandaang
Patuloy ang kabataan!

Nakikibaka
Malagutan man ng hininga!

Two Peasant Organizers in Bataan Missing

September 28, 2008

BY BULATLAT

Two peasant organizers in Bataan province have been missing, Desaperacidos (Families of Desaparecidos for Justice) disclosed.

The group said suspected military men abducted Nelson Balmaña on Sept. 21 and Florencia Espiritu on Sept. 22. Both are organizers of the Sto. Niño Lubao Farmers’ Association (SLFA). The victims have been organizing peasants from Lubao, Pampanga, an adjacent barangay (village) to Hermosa, Bataan.

Desaperacidos’ account said the two victims were supposed to meet on Sept. 21 at a house in Purok 2, Brgy. Daan Bago, Dinalupihan in Bataan, but Nelson sent a text message to Florencia that he could not make it and would meet her the following day instead.

The next day, Florencia left the house at 10:30 am and was boarding a tricycle, when at least six armed men believed to be elements of the 24th Infantry Battalion of the Philippine Army took her and forced her into a white L300 FB Mitsubishi.  Four of the men were armed with .45 caliber pistols, while one carried an armalite.

The abductors fled towards the direction of Pampanga-Metro-Manila.  After Florencia’s abduction, witnesses said a man fitting Nelson’s description was abducted at 5 p.m.the day before at the same spot, and was taken by the same getaway vehicle.

Desaperacidos said the recent abductions placed to 199 the number of the disappeared under the Arroyo regime

On Sept. 17, another victim, James Balao of the Cordillera People’s Alliance disappeared in Baguio City.  James left his home in Fairview, Baguio City to go to La Trinidad, Benguet at 7am and was not heard of since.

Mary Guy Portajada, spokesperson of Desaperacidos, revealed that three have been abducted in a just six days.

“The Armed Forces of the Philippines clearly shows that it is untouchable, and continues to carry out enforced disappearances, even after the Court of Appeals had ruled that it is guilty of the disappearance of Sherlyn Cadapan, Karen Empeño and Manuel Meriño,” said Portajada.

Another victim, Elmer dela Cruz was reported missing on August 23 in Hermosa, Bataan.  He is still missing as of this writing.

Meanwhile, in another statement, the Kilusang Magbubukid ng Pilipinas (KMP) condemned the recent abductions.

Willy Marbella, KMP deputy secretary general for internal affairs, hit the military for ‘wreaking havoc on the peasant movement.’  “After forcibly disappearing our Bulacan leader-organizer Jonas Burgos, our National Council member Nilo Arado, framing up Tagaytay 5 and our deputy secretary general for external affairs Randall Echanis, here they go again, abducting our organizers in Bataan,” said Marbella.

Marbella said the ‘counter-insurgency program Oplan Bantay Laya II (Operation Freedom Watch II) has been targeting the legal democratic movement, particularly, the peasant movement.’

Portajada called on the people to be vigilant, as ‘this government does not sleep as it commits human rights violations.’ “Impunity reigns as Gloria Arroyo and her military remain unpunished for its crimes,” she said. (Bulatlat)

Diagnosing Sickness and Fear in Guihulngan

September 28, 2008

Fifteen doctors who recently joined a humanitarian mission in Guihulngan, Negros Oriental shared that many of the residents’ diseases have been caused by fear of gun toting soldiers roaming their villages.

BY RONALYN V. OLEA
HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH
Bulatlat

Fifteen doctors who recently joined a humanitarian mission in Guihulngan, Negros Oriental shared their observation that many of the residents’ diseases have been caused by fear of gun toting soldiers roaming their villages.

Doctor Merry Mia, director of the Health and Training Services Department of the Council for Health and Development (CHD), disclosed this in a lugawan (porridge) –forum for the benefit of Guihulngan residents held at the St. Scholastica’s College, Sept. 23.

Mia was among the 70-member Negros Mercy Mission who went to the said province from Sept. 12 to 15. The mission attended to 1,035 patients from 12 barangays (villages)- Trinidad, Binobohan, Mani-ak, Sandayao, Kalupaan, Tacpao, Hilaitan, Banwage, Balogo, Linantuyan, Plogastasano, and Imelda.

The mission, split into three clusters, administered medical consultations, pre-natal checkups, minor surgeries (cyst extraction, circumcision), dental services and psycho-social counseling.

Mia said, “It is a common observation by doctors that patients with hypertension, hyperacidity, muscle pains, headache and insomnia were also those who expressed fear of government troops.”

She said that one of the pronounced cases in the counseling activities includes fear of being shot by military men who fire their guns indiscriminately within residential areas. These incidents occurred at Barangays Trinidad, Imelda and Banwague.

High stress levels

Mia noted that those who live near military detachments have high stress levels. “They have difficulty sleeping and are afraid to go through their daily activities,” she said.

Residents interviewed by the mission’s volunteers related that the soldiers would fire their guns around 2 a.m. or 3 a.m. almost daily. The soldiers always say that they had an encounter with the rebels. The residents, however, said there have been no exchanges of fire.

Mia said the residents’ movements have been restricted. “The military has imposed a curfew. Every morning, the soldiers would check all the residents. These have hampered the people’s activities and livelihood.”

Another doctor, Edelina dela Paz, vice chairperson of Health Alliance for Human Rights (HAHR), cited the case of a pregnant woman from Bgy. Linantuyan. She said soldiers pointed a gun at the poor woman.

“The fear in her mind can affect her baby,” said dela Paz. She said it was good the woman is strong enough.

Dela Paz underscored the importance of psycho-social counseling in areas like these. “You have to make them ventilate their fears. The military aims to intimidate the people so that the people won’t say anything any more,” she said.

Other patients complained of cough and colds, epigastric pain, musculoskeletal pains and upper respiratory tract infection.

She said that the nearest health center has no doctor and no medicines. “There was no health education among the people, too.”

Mia said the Franciscan Mountain Clinics in Bgy. Trinidad and Banwage have been frequently visited by soldiers. “People are afraid to go to these alternative health clinics because of the military.”

Securing the area?

In fact, Mia said that during the first day of the mission, nine soldiers from the 11th Infantry Battalion attempted to enter the premises of the Franciscan Mountain Clinic in Kalabaklabakan, Brgy. Trinidad.

When physician Mark Chito Molina, member of the Health Alliance for Democracy –Cebu chapter, Cynthia Vargas of the CHD and Amy Tapales, staff of the Franciscan Mountain Clinic prevented the military from entering the clinic premises, Lt. Jade Cañete, commander of the unit, insisted that they have to get in to “secure the area.”

Mia said, “Secure from whom? They are the ones who sow fear among the people.”

The soldiers attempted three times to enter the premises, causing delay to the delivery of medical services.

Poverty

Mia also said that many of the diseases they diagnosed are preventable if only the people have the money to obtain their basic needs and health care services.

Mia said that cases of stress and insecurity are also brought about by problems of daily survival and separation from family members. She said that some of the residents’ loved ones have left Guihulngan in search of additional income elsewhere.

Rolando Libang, executive assistant of the CPDG, said landlessness remains to be the major problem of farmers in Guihulngan. He said that 90 percent of the farmers are tenants.

Agricultural workers receive only P45 ($0.855 at an exchange rate of $1=P46.745) a day, said Libang. Farmers are paid P200 ($4.278) for three days’ work of weeding out grass in sugar plantations.

Libang said farmers have no food security at all. They harvest palay (rice grains) only once a year because of the soil’s acidity. The farmers harvest only 2,000 kernels of corn per cropping season.

Malnutrition

Dela Paz said that most of the children she examined complained of pain in the stomach. “It is ironic that the children of farmers, who are the producers of food, are malnourished.”

She lamented the eating patterns of the children. Most of the schoolchildren would eat ground corn with ginamos (salted fish) before leaving for school. “Kung may bigas, maswerte na.” (If they have rice, they are lucky.)

The children, dela Paz said, would eat nothing for morning snacks. “I found out that they reserve kamote (sweet potato) or saging (banana) for lunch,” said dela Paz.

Prescription

Katharina Anne Berza, CHD advocacy officer, said, “In its prescription, the mission underscored the need for the people to have access to their right to health and economic alleviation.”

She said further, “A clear health program must be implemented to battle the health problems the communities face instead of having army troops who spread fear and anxiety. Genuine land reform is definitely a necessity and not the presence of soldiers in full battle gear.” (Bulatlat)

Surface James Balao Now!

September 28, 2008

BY THE ALL UP ACADEMIC EMPLOYEES UNION-BAGUIO CHAPTER
ALL UP ACADEMIC EMPLOYEES UNION NATIONAL
DEMOCRATIC SPACE

2008 is the Centennial Year of the University of the Philippines. Since January, the entire University System has been celebrating. In fact, in UP Baguio, one of the culminating activities is a Grand Alumni Homecoming on December 5, 2008. But Alas! The preparations to turn this activity into a memorable, major celebration is threatened. One of the University of the Philippines Baguio’s harvests of intelligent minds, of true Iskolars ng Bayan who take to task genuine service to the people, is missing.

James Balao graduated in1981 with a degree in B.S. Psychology. As a student, he served as editor-in-chief of the official student paper, Outcrop. After graduation, James involved himself in research and writing projects for both academic and non-government organizations. One of his major research outputs has to do with “The Land Problem of the Cordillera National Minorities.”

No one could just disappear in thin air. James could not disappear voluntarily without informing his family and friends. James loves life. In fact, he has been an advocate of the defense of life and land of the Cordillera peoples, for the protection of his people from oppression and exploitation. James could have only disappeared involuntarily, forcibly.


CONGRESS LOBBY. The Balao siblings (left) asked Bayan Muna Rep. Teddy Casiño some assistance for their brother’s enforced disappearance case. (Photo by Cye Reyes/NORDIS)

The UP community appeals to the highest authorities of the Philippines to find the whereabouts of James and send clear signs of the Government’s adherence to justice by surfacing him immediately. If any state agency suspects him of any violations of the laws of the Philippines, James must be allowed to defend himself. The law enforcers must adhere to due process.

We also appeal to all concerned individuals and organizations to sign the on line petition at http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/CPAjamesbalao/. You may also forward letters of solidarity to the Balao family through and through the Cordillera Human Rights Association email address (chra@cpaphils.org)

Justice for Rachelle Mae Palang (1986-2008): Press Freedom Fighter and Nurse of the People

September 28, 2008

BY THE COLLEGE EDITORS GUILD OF THE PHILIPPINES
DEMOCRATIC SPACE
Posted by Bulatlat

The College Editors Guild of the Philippines, in behalf of its National Office, regional formations and chapters, all member publications and affiliate organizations nationwide and across the globe, expresses its most heartfelt condolences to the family, friends and colleagues of Rachelle Mae Palang (1986-2008).

Rachelle, or Mae-Mae to her closest friends and colleagues, was beloved to the Guild for her bubbly, tongue-in-cheek demeanor. She graced the Guild’s gatherings with her easy banter and infectious smile, but was always brisk and business-like in her leadership. She has served as a valuable pillar and driving force in all of the conventions and gatherings she has attended and helped organize. To most Guilders, she was not only a colleague but a precious friend and confidante.

Shock about her untimely demise are evident in her Friendster and Multiply accounts, riddled with comments ranging from disbelief, grief, and even anger – all directed at her, as if to attest that even at the time of her death her friends and colleagues still go to her for conciliation.

Such was Mae-Mae’s legacy and brand of leadership. She has always been easy to approach, a rational adviser and generous in her time and efforts.

Mae-Mae was also an outstanding student at the Velez College in Cebu City where she took up and finished her nursing degree. She became editor-in-chief of Vital Signs, the official campus publication. As campus journalist and student leader, she exemplified deep commitment to uphold press freedom, freedom of speech and students’ democratic rights and welfare. She is respected by her fellow campus journalists nationwide for her wit, intelligence and sharp grasp of issues.

She was elected as vice president for the Visayas during CEGP’s 67th National Student Press Convention and 33rd Biennial Student Press Congress held in Albay, Bicol in 2005. She served her term for three consecutive years before she finally relinquished her post in May of this year. The CEGP will without end be honored and grateful to have had someone as dedicated as Mae-Mae as one of its leading officers.

Mae-Mae worked hard to help re-open closed campus publications, establish student papers in universities which had none, and expose and fight campus press freedom violations as well as other forms of campus repression nationwide. She led, organized and participated in countless poetry readings, cultural nights, Writers’ Trips, journalist skills workshops and protest actions and activities. Even after her stint as VP for the Visayas, she proved instrumental in gathering and collating cases of campus press freedom violations in the region for CEGP’s quarterly digest.

Mae-Mae had to cut short her attendance in CEGPs’ 68th National Student Press Convention and 34th Biennial Student Press Congress in Davao City for her scheduled nursing licensure exams in May 2008. She passed with flying colors and eventually became a registered nurse. Even before she left, she announced to the Guild her desire to pursue an alternative medical career, one that she would devote to the less-privileged. Mae-Mae also took and passed the National Medical Admission Test. She dreamt of becoming a doctor.

It therefore did not come as a surprise to the Guild to learn that upon achieving her nursing license Mae-Mae immediately volunteered for a three-month medical mission to the hinterlands of Negros. Mae-Mae barely finished her volunteer work in Negros when her dreams died with her.

Mae-Mae was killed by elements of the Armed Forces of the Philippines on Sept. 18 in an alleged encounter with New People’s Army rebels. Her face was barely recognizable; she was shot at point-blank range. Her feet and legs were black and bruised, signs of torture evident elsewhere in her beaten body.

Mae-Mae’s untimely demise reminds the Guild all too painfully of the same fate that another CEGP alumnae suffered under the hands of the AFP.

In April 2002, Benjaline ‘Beng’ Hernandez, former CEGP vice president for Mindanao and a human rights volunteer, was murdered by the military while conducting a fact-finding mission in North Cotabato. Investigations revealed that the AFP shot her at close range. The AFP later on insisted that Beng was an NPA rebel.

Beng, like Mae-Mae, was also only 22 years old when she died.

The CEGP condemns in strongest terms accusations and insinuations by the AFP that Mae-Mae was armed and a combatant. She was in Negros in her capacity as a registered nurse and circumstances surrounding her brutal killing should be independently investigated.

The CEGP, in this regard, welcomes initiatives by the Commission on Human Rights Regional Office to conduct an investigation on Mae-Mae’s case.

The CEGP is also reviled at the AFP’s gall to celebrate Mae-Mae’s death by bestowing incentives and acclaim to her killers. It is an awful and terrible reminder of the state and characteristic of our security forces. They who are supposed to protect civilians are the main enemies of human rights defenders and social workers.

The CEGP also condemns in strongest terms the AFP’s malicious attempts to malign the Guild’s name through red-tagging and nasty insinuations. It is precisely this kind of twisted mentality that gives license to the military to repress, harass, silence and kill with impunity. Journalists are easily treated and branded as rebels simply because they are exposed to the ills of society.

The CEGP calls on all its member publications and fellow journalist organizations nationwide and abroad to collectively wield their pens and raise their voices to denounce Mae-Mae’s killers.

The CEGP regards the likes of Beng and Mae-Mae as heroes of the present generation, young martyrs who have chosen to exchange their lives of comfort for their noble convictions.

Highest tribute to Rachelle Mae Palang!
Justice for Beng and Mae-Mae!

US Bankruptcies, A Portend of Worse Things to Come

September 28, 2008

The bankruptcy of five global financial services firms based in the US is not yet the worst that could happen. There is yet no end in sight to the current convulsion of the crisis in the US. If things do not bode well for the US, more so for the Philippines. There is not truth to the claims of the Arroyo government that the country would hardly be affected by the crisis in the US as the exposure of local banks to Lehman Brothers is limited. The impact of the recession and bankruptcies in the US on the Philippine economy is far greater than that.

BY BENJIE OLIVEROS
ANALYSIS
Bulatlat

Bear and Stearns, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Lehman Brothers, Merrill Lynch, and AIG are global giants that, a few years back, seem to be unassailable. Bear and Stearns, which was founded in 1923, survived the Great Depression to become one of the largest global investment bank, and securities trading and brokerage firm. But on March 2008 – on the brink of collapse – it was bought at a bargain price of $10, or was it $2?, per share by J.P. Morgan Chase.

Fannie Mae, which was established in 1938 as part of Roosevelt’s New Deal, and Freddie Mac, which was organized in 1970 – both government-sponsored enterprises- controlled 90 percent of the US’ second mortgage market. The value of their combined assets in 2003 was 45 percent greater than that of the largest bank in the US. By September, 2008 the US government had to take over the two mortgage companies to prevent it from folding up.

Lehman Brothers, a global financial services firm that started out as a dry goods store in 1844, was named as the number one dealer in the London Stock Exchange for three years, from 2004-2007, the “Most Admired Securities Firm” by Fortune magazine, and the top performer among the largest companies in US and Canada by the Barron’s 500 annual survey in 2006. It was managing $175 billion worth of assets in 2006. Just last week, it has declared bankruptcy.

Merrill Lynch, another giant in global financial services, was founded in 1914. It handled as much as $1.8 trillion in assets, and operated in more than 40 countries around the world. By September, it was bought for $50 billion by the Bank of America.

The AIG or American International Group, which was founded in 1919, is among the biggest insurance and financial services firms in the US and the 18th largest company in the world. It operates in more than 130 countries. By September, the US Federal government had to extend an $85 billion loan facility to AIG to prevent it from going under.

These are not simple cases of mismanagement by overpaid executives. These reveal the enormity of the global crisis. While the fall of these companies are attributed to the sub-prime mortgage crisis, the US, mortgage crisis itself is but a symptom of the economic crisis enveloping the US and the world.

The world economic recession and crisis since the 1980s pushed investors into a speculation frenzy: investing in real estate, which resulted in the 1997 Southeast Asian financial crisis, in high tech stocks leading to the bursting of the hi-tech bubble in 2000, and in mortgage-backed securities or collateralized debt obligations resulting in the sub-prime mortgage crisis. Financial investments also went into commodity futures markets pushing the prices of food and oil up until it “overheated”: prices going so high resulting in the dampening of demand. With every convulsion of the crisis, billions of dollars are lost.

There is yet no end in sight to the current convulsion of the crisis in the US. Analysts fear a further contraction of credit, which, in turn, would lead to a further slowing down of manufacturing and production. Already, exports, which is the main factor enabling the US to keep its head above the water, is in danger of sliding with the contraction of the economies of Europe and Japan during the second quarter of the year. Worse, a tightening of credit would also serve to dampen US domestic consumption. These problems would make matters worse for the world’s largest economy, the US, as its growth during the last decade or so has been fueled by debt and is consumer-driven.

If things to do not bode well for the US, more so for the Philippines. There is not truth to the claims of the Arroyo government that the country would hardly be affected by the crisis in the US as the exposure of local banks to Lehman Brothers is limited. The impact of the recession and bankruptcies in the US on the Philippine economy is far greater than that.

The US is the country’s top export destination and main trading partner. Around 18 percent of the country’s exports go to the US. It consistently ranks among the top three sources of foreign investments. According to IBON Foundation, 90 percent of the country’s revenues from Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) – the only sector keeping the unemployment situation from getting worse – is from contracts from US companies. US companies also hold two-thirds of foreign equity in the BPO sector. The US is also the biggest source of overseas remittances amounting to $4,728,920,000 or 49 percent of the total from January to July 2008.

We are now feeling the effects of the US crisis on the country. For the first eight months of the year, the country experienced a net outflow of portfolio investments amounting to $209.5 million; the Philippine stock market is experiencing losses; the value of the peso is being dragged down by the US dollar. Exports to the US and the entry of foreign direct investments would expectedly slow down as the recession in the US deepens, and the worsening unemployment there would definitely have an impact on remittances from overseas Filipinos. Likewise, sources of foreign debt, which is keeping the country afloat, would also tighten.

Neither could the country seek relief in its trade with other countries. Japan, the country’s second largest trading partner, and which is among the top three sources of foreign investments is frantically injecting funds into its money market to cushion the impact of the bankruptcies in the US. Its economy contracted during the second quarter of the year and is not expected to grow much in the next two years with projections constant at 2.1 percent. European economies, to include Germany, are also in recession. The Halifax Bank of Scotland almost went under and was bought by Lloyds TSB. World central banks are infusing $300 billion in currency swap facilities to cushion the impact of the financial crisis.

The situation the Philippine economy is in, is the consequence of its orientation towards exports instead of production for local consumption; its dependence on imports for capital and consumer goods; its reliance on debt to cover its trade and budgetary deficits; its dependence on foreign direct investments for capital, and portfolio investments and remittances of overseas Filipinos for the foreign currencies it needs.

We thought and we have hoped that we have seen the worst of the crisis in the country during the last nine months of the year with the run-away inflation and worsening unemployment. Unfortunately, the worst is yet to come. (Bulatlat)

Oil Speculation and Under-Recoveries

September 28, 2008

Whatever happens with oil speculation, the big oil companies are always at the winning end. As oil prices go up, so do the profits of oil companies. How then can they claim for under-recoveries?

BY BENJIE OLIVEROS
ANALYSIS
Bulatlat

After going down steadily after reaching a peak of $147 per barrel in July, oil prices are threatening to rise up again. World oil prices have already gone down to around $90 per barrel when news of the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, the purchase of Merrill Lynch, and the bail out of AIG broke out. This caused the volatility of oil prices once again. The announcement of Bush’s $700 billion bailout plan triggered a reduction then an increase in oil prices.

Oil contracts for October delivery, in electronic trading on the New York Mercantile Exchange in Singapore, surged to $130 a barrel before settling down to $120.92 on Monday September 22. Contracts for November delivery of oil, however, went down to $107.41 a barrel before settling at $109.37 during trading last September 23. Were there expectations of a storm, an attack on oil wells in Nigeria, or a war on Iran that would disrupt supplies? Is a surge in demand in China or the US being expected? No.

An analyst said that investors are looking for a “safe haven” in oil after the series of bankruptcies indicating the extent of the financial crisis. It was also said that uncertainties on the effects of the $700 billion bailout plan on the US economy – worsening the US government deficit, fall in the value of the dollar, among others – also triggered investments in oil futures. If this is not a manifestation of the effects of speculative investments in the oil futures market then what is?

As a “by the way”, analysts also cited the decision of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) to cut production and the effects of Hurricane Ike and Gustav during early September for “having helped” spark increases in oil prices.

Oil traders doubling as analysts have consistently denied that speculation is pushing oil prices up, and for obvious reasons. Often cited for the oil price spikes were geopolitical tensions such as in Iran and Nigeria, anticipation of increases in demand, and the “Peak Oil” theory. Promoters of the Peak Oil theory, which asserts that world oil production and reserves are going down and in danger of being depleted in the near future thereby triggering volatility in oil prices had their heyday till July when oil prices reached its peak at $147 per barrel. Sounding like doomsayers, they predicted that oil prices would reach $200 per barrel while laughing their way to the bank; a closer look at the proponents of this theory such as a T. Boone Pickens, a former oil producer and current chair of BP Capital Management, which invests and trades in oil futures, reveals that they profit from oil price spikes. Even when oil prices started going down, they still insisted that it would go up to $200 per barrel. When oil prices went down to around $90 per barrel, they became conspicuously silent.

A June 2006 US Senate report has concluded that around 25 to 30 percent in the $60 per barrel price of oil then was due to speculation. More recently, F. William Engdahl, an Associate for the Center for Research on Globalization and author of A Century of War: Anglo-American Oil Politics and the New World Order, concluded in an article published at the website of Global Research May 2008 that an astonishing 60 percent of the price of oil is due to speculation.

Undoubtedly, investors in oil futures would have wanted and profited from a continuous increase in oil prices. That is why they kept on pushing oil prices up. But real demand, which fell because oil became too expensive, caught up with them. By then, the big investment banks that were able to sell on time have gained enormous profits through the price differences while those caught holding the bag (highly priced oil futures contracts) when prices fell may have experienced losses.

What about the oil companies?

Whatever happens with oil speculation, the big oil companies are always at the winning end. As oil prices go up, so do the profits of oil companies. Whenever oil prices go way beyond the cost of production plus the average rate of profit because of speculation, oil companies are able to gobble up super profits. In August 2005, one analyst estimated that the $60 per barrel price of oil should only be $25 per barrel without speculation. That means oil companies earned an extra $35 per barrel in profits. Using the same computation, Engdahl estimated that with the prevailing $115 per barrel price of oil in May 2008, $50 to $60 was due to speculation. Thus, by selling at $115 per barrel, oil companies earned additional profits of from 77 to 100 percent.

It is then not surprising that six oil companies – Exxon Mobil, Royal Dutch Shell, BP, Chevron, Total, ConocoPhillips- are among the top 10 corporations of Fortune Magazine’s Global 500. But that is only in terms of revenues. In terms of profits, oil companies occupy the top 2, the 4th, 7th and 8th positions. Other profitable companies included General Electric, HSBC Holdings, the Russian energy firm Gazprom, JP Morgan, and Royal Bank of Scotland. With the fall of investment banks, oil companies would surely be the ones who are left standing.

The big three local oil companies are mere subsidiaries of the oil giants. Caltex is the local subsidiary of Chevron Texaco; Royal Dutch Shell is the mother company of Shell Philippines; Aramco owns 40 percent of Petron. Local subsidiaries source or import oil from their mother companies, and their transactions could be treated as intra-corporate transfers. They do not have to source their supply of oil from the spot and futures markets. It is then a wonder why they say that they sacrificed their profits – and thus have to claim for under-recoveries- with the spike in world crude prices during the first half of the year when they increased pump prices every week, and their mother companies need not base their pass- on price to their local subsidiaries on the speculation-boosted price in the world market.

If oil companies were not so greedy, they should have based their pass-on price on the actual cost of production, freight and marketing costs plus the average rate of profit. Their claim that they could not roll back local pump prices immediately at the price level reflective of current world crude prices is the height of callousness. It is also a wonder why small players like SeaOil could offer lower prices and reduce local pump prices faster when they have to import their supply of petroleum products.

However, the small players could not survive without establishing partnerships with oil industry giants. They serve as marketing arm of the big oil giants. For example SeaOil has a partnership with Paramins for its lubricants, and Paramins is owned by Exxon Mobil, which in turn, entered into a joint venture with Shell Additives. On the other hand, Chevron Additives bought a product line of Exxon Chemicals.

The oil giants control the whole industry from exploration, drilling, production, to refinement, marketing, and distribution of all petroleum products. Everything about oil starts and ends with them. How can they lose?

The greed of oil companies has been fueled further with the Downstream Oil Industry Deregulation Act of 1996. With the deregulation of the oil industry, they are able to increase prices at will when world crude prices go up and delay the reduction of pump prices when world prices go down. And the government could not do anything about it. But of course, the Arroyo government could not be expected to take the side of the Filipino people and force oil companies to roll back pump prices. It likewise profits with the spike in oil prices with the Value-Added Tax on petroleum products: the higher the pump price of oil, the bigger is its collections. Only the Filipino people could force its hand to do so. (Bulatlat)

Editorial Cartoon: (Local Politics) Panlilio’s Loo

September 27, 2008

And he’s being swallowed down… down… down…

Malling at Rali

September 27, 2008

Ang malling ay hindi na lamang malling, ang malling ay isang anyo ng kontra-rebolusyonaryo na kalakaran na ang pang-araw-araw na politika ay makamayagpag, at maetsapwera ang politikal na lohika ng ating panlipunan at historikal na relasyon sa mall at karanasan.

NI ROLAND TOLENTINO
Bulatlat

Ganito nagsimula ang pagninilay na ito.  Banggit ng mga kaibigang Sarah at RC, sa exhibit ng anibersaryo ng SM (ShoeMart), may paulit-ulit na video na naka-play sa mga lobby nito.  Kasama sa video ang panayam kay Henry Sy, ang tagapagtatag ng SM.  Tinanong siya kung ano ang palagay niya sa mga nagrarali, yung nagproprotesta (at hindi ko na tiyak ang pagpadaloy nitong tanong), kung ito ba ay kabawasan sa kita ng kanyang negosyo, o kung ang protesta ay patungkol sa polisiya ng subcontracting ng malaking mayorya ng kanyang manggagawa, at ang pangangamkam ng lupa para sa kanyang mall.

Ang tugon ni Sy ay parang ganito:  pabor nga sa kanya ang rali dahil matapos nito ay tumutuloy ang nagrarali sa kanyang malls.  Sa isip ni Sy, may padaloy (flow) ang paggrugrupo ng mga tao para sa interes ng kanyang negosyo.  Kaya nga kahit liblib na lugar, dinadayo pa rin ito ng mga tao.  Mula sa talahiban ng EDSA North, naging mayor na ruta ito.  Mula sa bakanteng lote sa reclaimed area, ang Mall of Asia (MOA) ang bagong ikutan ng mga sasakyan sa EDSA.

Tunay na tama ang wika ng karakter ni Kevin Coster sa Field of Dreams (1989) ukol sa isang majestikong plano ng baseball aficionado na nagtayo ng baseball field sa gitna ng kanyang sakahan ng mais, “If you build it, they will come.”  At dinayo nga ito ng malapit at malayong komunidad.  Kakatwa na bulong lang ang nagsabi nito sa karakter.  At dahil sinunod niya ang kanyang panaginip, nagkatotoo ito.  Nagkaroon ng lunan ng Amerikanong aktibidad ang pamayanan.

Hindi nga ba’t ang populasyon ng mallers sa Megamall na kalahating milyon araw-araw, at kulang sa isang milyon kapag Sabado’t Linggo ay populasyon na ng malaking syudad?  Na ang maller ay may realisasyon ng kanyang pagkamamamayan (citizenship) sa malls ni Sy dahil mas ligtas, mas moderno ang kapaligiran, mas maraming pagpipilian, mas sentral sa kolektibong karanasan rito?  Kung gayon, may afinidad ang malling sa rali—pareho itong dinadagsa ng mga tao para sa kolektibong karanasan.

Parang nagrarali rin ang malling dahil may “harmony” ang karanasan ng pagpasok at paglabas, ng kolektibong pagmamartsa kahit hindi magkakakilala, ng pag-takeon ng mallers sa espasyo ng mall, akuin itong parang sa kanila, makaramdam na sila man ay pwedeng magpahayag sa kanilang karanasan sa malling ng citizenship claim bilang bahagi ng pamayanan sa fantasya ni Sy.  Politika ng pang-araw-araw ang malling, ang pagdanas sa alternatibong karanasan sa espasyo ng konsumerismo at postmodernismo.

Samantala, ang pagrarali ay politikal na pang-araw-araw na aktibidad, konsolidasyon ng pagtaas ng kamulatan at ng pag-oorganisa para sa kilusang masa.  Politikal ito dahil may layon ng panlipunang at historikal na transformasyon.  At malamang, totoo rin ang daloy sa fantasya ni Sy.  Sa isang rali sa Mayo Uno sa Liwasan Bonifacio, dahil sa init ng araw, natagpuan naming sumasaglit sa SM-Manila para mananghalian sa fastfood nito.  At hindi lang kami ang kumbiyenteng gumawa nito mula sa nagrarali.  Maraming unyonista at iba pang sektor ang nasa loob rin ng aircon na kainan ni Sy.

Ang fantasya ni Sy ay neoliberal na fantasya ng kawalan ng tunggalian sa uri.  Na ang rali ay pwedeng itransforma sa isang pangyayaring hindi na lamang maari kundi tungo na sa higit pang kita.  Ang pagplantsa ng kontradiksyon ay pandadaot sa rali, ang pagpapahina ng politikal tungo sa politika ng pang-araw-araw.  Na walang pinagkaiba ang rali sa dagsa-dagsang bilang ng mamamayan sa kanyang itinakdang sityo ng pagkamamamayan.

At ito ang praktikal na adbentahe ni Sy laban sa mga mall ng Ayala at Gokongwei.  May aktwal na pagpapatupad si Sy na magtatag ng SM sa bawat kalahating oras na biyahe sa Metro Manila.  “Integrated” o swak sa karanasang kanyang itinatag ang taktikang bilang at lokasyon ng malls.  Sa kanyang arkitektonika nabuo ang malling bilang isang di lamang pang-araw-araw na karanasan kundi isang integrated na karanasan sa pang-araw-araw.  Mapapadaan at mapapadaan ang mga mamamayan sa malls ni Sy kada nagbibiyahe sila.

At maging ito ay malamang kontento na si Sy, ang makapagdulot ng awareness sa kanyang malls.  Hindi ba’t may mga anunsyo na hinggil sa renobasyon tungo sa pagpapalaki ng malalaki nang mall, tulad sa SM North bilang isa sa tatlong pinakamalaking malls sa Asia?  O ang mismong harapan ng kanyang malls ay binabanderitas ng mga higanteng tarpaulin para sa mga produktong matatagpuan sa loob nito?  Ang mall ni Sy ay nagiging magnet sa konsumerismo dahil nakakapagpalapit ito ng mga produkto at serbisyong inaakalang tatangkilikin ng mapapadaan at mapapaloob sa karanasang ito.

Sino nga ba ang aayaw o tatanggi sa kumbinyenteng dulot ng karanasan sa malling?  Ang ligtas na pagdaan sa espasyo nito tungo sa sakayan, o ang intermittent na kapasidad makagawa ng errands sa loob nito bago at matapos pumasok sa opisina at umuwi sa bahay?  O matiwasay na mananghalian dito kapag may rali?  Taktikal ang integrasyon ng malling sa pang-araw-araw na pagpapadaloy ng buhay, na maari pa ngang sabihin na malling na ang sentral sa buhay ng maraming mamamayan.

Sabi ng isa pang kaibigan, sa mall na raw tumatambay ang runners para magkita-kita matapos ng kanilang run.  May nakapagsabi rin na rito na nag-eehersisyo ang mga matatanda, nagpapalipas ng oras sa paglalakad bilang cardio-vascular na aktibidad.  Kaya rin may gym, restaurants, grocery, dentista, facial care, foot spa, health care, sinehan at iba pang negosyo sa loob ng mall—para mahimok tayong dito na lamang kaysa sa iba, ipaloob na lamang sa mall kaysa ipalabas ang daloy ng karanasan sa araw-araw.

Ang hindi sinasabi ni Sy ay ligtas ang mall dahil sa heavy surveillance rito.  Sandamakmak ang indibidwal na gwardya.  May regular na police patrol, kasama ang mga aso.  At ang presensya ng pulis at militar, bitbit ang mga high-powered na baril, ay ang isa pang integrasyon ng pambansang fantasya:  ang integrated na karanasan ng militar sa negosyo ni Sy.  At malamang, sandamakmak ang surveillance cameras sa mga establisyimento kundi man sa mismong mall.

Kaya sa mall, kahit hindi kay Sy, dinukot si Jonas Burgos, isang aktibista.  Na kahit magsisigaw siyang “Aktibista lang po ako” ay hindi ito isinaalang-alang ng mga dumukot sa kanya.  Na tila sistematiko ang pagkawala ng witnesses sa okasyon.  At kung nagkaganito, epektibong counter-insurgency na mekanismo na rin ang malls.  Siyang nangangako ng kaligtasan sa kanyang mamimili ay may kapasidad na ring makapagbigay na rin ng sityo at mekanismo ng counter-insurgency para sa estado.

Ang pag-nega (negation) sa politikal ni Sy ay hindi na ampaw na pananalita na lamang.  Ito ang reverse discourse ni Foucault, na sa pamamagitan ng pagtalaga ng espasyo bilang sityo ng konsumerismo at politika ng pang-araw-araw, itinatalaga na rin ito bilang iba pang bagay—ang substansya ng direktang ugnay sa pagka-estado nito.  Na ang kapangyarihan ni Sy ay mas di na hiwalay sa interes ng estado.  OK ang rali sa labas ng mall dahil kapag pumasok naman sa mall ay wala na ang identidad ng raliyista.

Temporaryong lusaw ang kolektibo ng politikal para umugma sa panananghalian, o pagset sa sityo ng mall bilang tipunan o meeting, at iba pang bagay para sa kilusan.  Pero hindi OK sa malls ni Sy ang politikal—hindi nga ba’t ang imahen ng marahas na dispersal ng piket ng nakaunipormeng manggagawa laban sa pulis at security guards ni Sy sa SM-Makati ay nananatiling dokumento ng direktang pagnega sa aktwalidad ng politikal na makapasok sa mall niya?

O ang snake rali sa loob ng SM-North nang mag-piket ang kanyang manggagawa, nagmistulang habulan ng pusa at daga ang manaka-nakang pagkakataong ito?  Truck-truck ng militar ang umano ay ipinadala raw ni Erap (Joseph Estrada) para i-disperse ang picket sa loob nito.  OK ang rali kay Sy kung ang daloy ay ang negation ng politikal tungo sa politika ng pagiging maller.  OK ang rali kung hindi dinadala ang isyu sa loob ng mall.

Nang una akong maglektura hinggil sa malls, sa partikular ang karanasan ni Sy at SM, parating ang idinidiin ay ang subersibong potensyal nito.  Limitado lamang ang maaring magawang pagbabalikwas sa mall:  pedestrian malling (o dumadaan lamang sa loob ng mall para tumungo sa mga sakayan), window shopping, sityo ng subkultural na formasyon (punkista, hiphop, sex workers, at iba pa), shoplifting, at iba pa.  Naalaala nabanggit kong kahit alam naman ang estadong interes ng mall, mismong mga aktibista ay hindi maihihiwalay ang sarili sa happy na karanasan sa mall.

Paano nga naman iisipin ang mall bilang hindi ibang sityo maliban sa kasiyahan ng konsumerismo?  Na mayoryang kalakhan ng manggagawa rito ay subcontractual labor na sistematikong maliligwak kada limang buwan?  Na malaki ang sexual harassment issue sa mga manggagawang kinakapkapan ng security guards?  Na may aksidente at nakawan ding nangyayari sa loob nito?  Na mapanupil ito kundi man epektibo ang formasyon ng docile subjects para sa interes ng estado?

Naalaala ko ring nabanggit ko na wala namang magpipiket sa nakikinig.  O hindi naman literal na matitibag ng piket ang mall.  Walang pagkakataong makapagdala ng maso at tibagin ang mall.  O sa pangkalahatan, walang magtatapon ng cellphone nila, hindi na kakain sa fastfood, hindi na magpapa-xerox o manigarilyo, at iba pa.  Ang nagawa ng malling ay epektibo tayong na-implicate sa karanasang binabatikos at gustong palitan.

Sa moral na uniberso, sino ang hindi nabahiran ng “dumi” ng malling?  At kung magkagayon, sino ang unang moral na tao na pwedeng bumato sa mall?  Na parang ang tugon ni Sy ay tugon ng mga bumabati sa fastfood, “Welcome to…”  Bagamat welcome ay nagtatalaga rin ng pag-akma ng pag-uugali at pagkilos, ng pagtataya sa karanasan bilang di lampas sa konsumerismo, at ang pagkalusaw ng politikal sa adbentura ng pagtangkilik.

Tama si Sy pero mali rin si Sy.  Sino ang sisisihin?  Manipis ang reverse discourse dahil sa pagpopolisya at panghihimok para sa substansya ng bagay, ang potensyal para sa iba parating naroroon pa rin.  Na ang nilulusaw na politikal ay hindi rin lubos kahit pa in-implicate tayong lahat.  Ang malling ay hindi na lamang malling, ang malling ay isang anyo ng kontra-rebolusyonaryo na kalakaran na ang pang-araw-araw na politika ay makamayagpag, at maetsapwera ang politikal na lohika ng ating panlipunan at historikal na relasyon sa mall at karanasan.

Kung gayon, ang mall ay mas malinaw na sityo ng magkatunggaling uring interes. (Bulatlat)

The Global Financial Crisis and its Implications for Workers of the World

September 27, 2008

As the US falls into recession, the rest of the global economy is being sucked downwards with it. The collapse of credit instruments originating in the U.S. is also weakening the financial balance sheets of banks and other overseas holders of these investments, affecting not just the banking sector but also stock markets abroad. Banks from the underdeveloped countries in the South have less exposure to sub-prime loans and the housing market bust in the US. But the adverse consequences of the current global financial crisis on the welfare and livelihoods of exploited classes in the oppressed countries will be more severe and protracted. But workers are fighting back.

BY PAUL L. QUINTOS
Ecumenical Institute for Labor Education and Research

INTERNATIONAL
Posted by Bulatlat

The worst crisis since the Great Depression

“The world economy has entered new and precarious territory”, opens the latest World Economic Outlook published by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) last April 2008. It describes the current financial crisis that erupted in August 2007 as “the largest financial shock since the Great Depression, inflicting heavy damage on markets and institutions at the core of the financial system.”

Other commentators have described the current crisis as a “systemic financial meltdown”, a “financial tsunami”, a “tipping point” in the world economy or even “the Very Great Depression” in the making.

When even the most optimistic defenders of the ruling system speak of a “systemic crisis”, then something of historical significance must be happening in our midst. Our task is to grasp the significance of the current crisis in the world capitalist system for the laboring classes, and draw lessons for our struggle against imperialism.

Bubblenomics

Mainstream economists explain the current crisis as the bursting of the housing bubble that had inflated to unprecedented levels since 2001. The Economist described this bubble in 2005 thus: “the total value of residential property in developed economies rose by more than $30 trillion over the past five years, to over $70 trillion, an increase equivalent to 100 percent of those countries’ combined GDPs. Not only does this dwarf any previous house-price boom, it is larger than the global stock market bubble in the late 1990s (an increase over five years of 80 percent of GDP) or America’s stock market bubble in the late 1920s (55 percent of GDP). In other words, it looks like the biggest bubble in history.”

This boom in house prices had been deliberately encouraged by the low-interest rate policy of the US Federal Reserve as a way of containing the impact of the dotcom bust in 2001. In the same way that asset inflation in tech stocks underpinned the growth of the US economy in the second half of the 1990s, the booming housing market propped up the US economy in the first half of this decade. Rising house prices and low interest rates encouraged millions of Americans — whose wages had been stagnant or declining since the 1970s — to borrow money using their houses as collateral and use this for consumer spending, thus boosting effective demand in an otherwise stagnant US economy. “Consumer spending and residential construction accounted for 90 percent of the total growth in US GDP from 2001 to 2005. And over two-fifths of all private-sector jobs created over the same period had been in housing-related sectors, such as construction, real estate and mortgage broking.”

Mortgage lending had become so profitable that banks and brokers began lending to “subprime borrowers” — those with lower incomes or poorer credit histories — with nary a credit investigation, down payment or even collateral. This high-risk or subprime mortgage lending spread hand in hand with the broader securitization strategy of finance capitalists. This refers to the now rampant and unregulated practice of investment banks and financial institutions of issuing loans, slicing and dicing these loans, then repackaging them as “mortgage-backed securities”, “asset-backed securities”, “collateralized debt obligations” (CDO), “collateralized loan obligations” and other synthetic financial instruments which are then sold to other capitalists in search of investment opportunities for their surplus capital. This allows the originators of these loans to transfer the risks associated with these loans while securing greater returns on their portfolio investments. This encouraged risky lending throughout the system, particularly in the booming housing market where subprime loans had expanded to 20 percent of all mortgages by 2006, up from 9 percent a decade earlier. It also magnified the likelihood of system-wide contagion in the event of widespread credit defaults.

Indeed as house prices started to plateau in 2005 and as interest rates started to rise, default rates and home foreclosures in the US started to climb in the latter part of 2006. This led to the collapse of scores of mortgage brokers and a number of mid-sized lending institutions with a large share of sub-prime mortgages in their loan portfolio. Unfazed, US Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke announced in June 2007 that the crisis in the subprime sector “seem unlikely to seriously spill over to the broader economy or the financial system.”

Bubbles burst

By August 2007, subprime mortgage backed securities began imploding in the portfolios of banks and hedge funds from around the world. Since then, one major bank after another has announced credit losses in the tens of billions. As of the middle of September 2008, three of Wall Street’s top five investment banks and icons of finance capitalism – Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers and Merrill Lynch – have disappeared as independent entities. Other major banks, including Morgan Stanley and Washington Mutual, are facing the same fate.

The current financial turmoil is forcing central banks to step in and bailout those financial institutions that are simply “too big to fail”. The Bank of England, for instance, extended a L25 billion emergency loan to the ailing Northern Rock last year. Last March 14, 2008 the US Federal Reserve guaranteed the loans of JP Morgan to rescue Bear Stearns, the fifth largest investment bank in the US with $2.5 trillion worth of trading contracts with firms from around the world. Even more momentous was the US government’s decision last September 7, 2008 to take over the two biggest mortgage lending agencies in the country — Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac – effectively placing US housing finance under direct government control and increasing the gross liabilities of the US government by $5.4 trillion, a sum equal to 40 per cent of GDP. Nine days later, the US Federal Reserve agreed to provide American International Group (AIG) – among the world’s largest private insurers with operations in 130 countries — with an $85 billion loan to help it stave off bankruptcy. This rattled stock markets across the globe, plunging share prices and prodding private banks to hold on to their reserves. This has forced the world’s leading central banks to band together and inject $300 billion into the global financial system to ease the credit crunch and prevent further panic – for now.

But this means that taxes from working people are once again being used to rescue capitalists, demonstrating the boundless parasitism of financial elites. Nouriel Roubini, a New York University economist, describes this as “socialism for the rich, the well-connected and Wall Street (i.e. where profits are privatized and losses are socialized).” Meanwhile, the biggest finance capitalists like JP Morgan are gobbling up these distressed capitals at firesale prices — further concentrating capital in the hands of a tiny finance oligarchy.

The current global financial crisis — with the US economy at its epicenter — is merely the latest and so far most severe in a series of financial crises that have erupted since the 1970s. Economists from the World Bank note no fewer than 117 systemic banking crises (defined as ones in which much or all of bank capital was exhausted) in 93 countries (that is, half the world) since the late 1970s. “In 27 of the crises for which they have been able to obtain the data, the fiscal cost of the bail out was 10 per cent of GDP, or more, sometimes vastly more.”

In the heartland of the global capitalist system, Paul Volcker notes that, “today’s financial crisis is the culmination, as I count them, of at least five serious breakdowns of systemic significance in the past 25 years – on the average one every five years. Warning enough that something rather basic is amiss.”

Indeed, these series of boom-busts in the financial sector are not merely events that are resolved after each episode. Rather they are generated by persistent and worsening contradictions in the real economy.

“Globalization” and “Financialization”

The unprecedented devastation of productive forces wrought by the last inter-imperialist war cleared the stage for around two decades of relatively stable and sustained growth in the advanced capitalist countries. But by the late 1960s, Europe and Japan were fully reconstructed as industrial powers rivaling the United States and worldwide economic growth began to slow just as monopoly capitalist competition intensified. Even as big business continues to invest in new technologies in its drive to extract ever greater profit, growth rates, national productivity rates, capital stock formation and net profit rates have been on the decline since the 1970s. Average net profit rates in the G7 countries fell from 17.6 percent in the 1950-70 period to 13.3 percent in 1970-93.

Only the US economy appeared vigorous in the second half of the 1990s but only on the basis of a speculative build-up in the equities markets using foreign borrowing which fueled over-investment in information technology and buoyed consumer spending. This dotcom bubble went bust in 2001, replaced by the housing bubble which has brought upon us the present crisis.

Underlying this systemic tendency towards crisis is the fundamental contradiction in capitalism itself: between social production which enables great strides in productivity on the one hand, and the private ownership of the means of production which ensures that only a few profit from production by exploiting the many. This contradiction inevitably leads to crises of overproduction – a situation in which there is a glut in commodities relative to the capacity of people to buy them.

The shift to neoliberal economic policies in the 1980s is monopoly capital’s attempt to revive falling profits due to the worsening crisis of overproduction – by forcing open markets, sourcing cheaper labor and raw materials, and securing profitable investment outlets. Through the IMF, the WB and the WTO – all of which are imperialist controlled “multilateral” institutions – liberalization of investments and trade, the privatization of public assets, deregulation of markets and cutbacks in social services and welfare spending, are imposed on client states under the hypocritical slogan of “free-market globalization”.

Combined with the re-integration of the former Soviet Union and China into the global capitalist system, imperialist globalization has truly succeeded in rewarding international monopoly capital. On the other hand, these reforms which aim to maximize profits and minimize wages, benefits and social spending for workers and the people have only resulted in the immiseration of the vast majority in the world. The net result is that by 2000, the richest 1 percent in the world own 40 percent of global assets, the richest 2 percent own 51 percent, while the poorest half of world population own barely 1 percent of global wealth.

Hence the flipside to the crisis of overproduction is the over-accumulation of capital in the hands of the monopoly capitalist elite. With overproduction rendering further investment in new productive capacity (such as factories and employment) increasingly unprofitable, a rapidly rising share of surplus capital is seeking profits not in the real economy but in financial speculation — a process sometimes referred to as the “financialization” of the global economy. This involves the frenetic increase in the trading of currencies, equities, bonds, debt securities, financial derivatives and other complex synthetic financial instruments, taking advantage of even the slightest differentials and momentary changes in bond prices, interest rates, and currency exchange rates in different markets around the world.

In 1980, the value of the world’s financial stock was roughly equal to world GDP, itself bloated. By 1993, it was double the size, and by the end of 2005, it had risen to 316 percent — more than three times world GDP. Government and private debt securities account for more than half of the overall growth in the global financial assets from 2000-2004 – which indicates the role of leverage or debt in driving this process. In 2004, daily derivatives trading amounted to $5.7 trillion while the daily turnover in the foreign exchange market was $1.9 trillion. Together they add up to $7.6 trillion in daily turnover of just two types of portfolio capital flows, exceeding the annual value of global merchandise exports by $300 billion.

This illustrates the increasing alienation of finance from production and explains much of the heightened volatility and instability in today’s global economy. While the value of financial assets is ultimately grounded in the value created by the working class in the process of production in the real economy and cannot diverge too far from it, asset bubbles can form for a period of time driven by “irrational exuberance” (in the words of Alan Greenspan). The positive expectations of financial speculators feed on each other, bidding up asset prices in a seemingly endless virtuous cycle. But like all ponzi schemes, reality eventually takes over and all it takes is one negative development, e.g. rising home foreclosures, to reverse expectations and send the entire the house of cards crashing down.

The fallout

The fallout from the current financial crisis is expected to be without precedent, at least in monetary terms. The IMF estimates that expected losses and write-downs on US assets could total $945 billion — bigger than the entire GDP of Australia — making it the most expensive financial crisis in history. Even so, some analysts believe this is an understatement.

Unfortunately, these massive credit losses and asset write-downs don’t just affect financiers. Indeed, it is ordinary working people that bear the brunt of its devastating consequences. An estimated 2.2 million or 1 in every 50 households in the US face foreclosure. Those who continue to own homes would be 20-30 percent poorer in terms of household wealth as home values drop as a result of the collapse in the housing bubble. According to one estimate, a collapse of 30 percent in US home prices from their over-inflated peak would wipe out $6 trillion of household wealth and leave 10 million households with negative equity in their homes — they owe more on their homes than they are worth — increasing the likelihood of a new round of foreclosures and credit losses.

Savings, health insurance, and retirement funds of millions of ordinary Americans who were enticed to invest in pension funds and assorted financial instruments will also be wiped out as banks and investment houses write-down billions in assets.

Moreover, this financial debacle ultimately impacts on the real economy as even the biggest banks and financial institutions faced with huge uncertainties are now averse to issuing new loans for housing, investment or for the purchase of cars and other durable goods. This means less investment and consumer spending which in turn means slower growth and even recession. The IMF warns that the US economy may shrink by 0.7 per cent over the 1-year period ending the fourth quarter of 2008, despite aggressive rate cuts by the Federal Reserve and a fiscal stimulus package. Recovery would be slight in 2009 with growth expected to be only 1.6 per cent. These estimates have been revised downwards several times and may still prove to be overstated as the crisis unfolds.

Almost 10 percent of the US workforce is now unemployed or underemployed, and job losses continue to mount. The private sector has shed 411,000 jobs over the past six months. Last month alone (May), 26,000 workers lost their jobs in manufacturing, 34,000 in construction, 27,000 in retail trade, and 39,000 in professional services, most of whom were temps. Over 150,000 temps have been terminated over the past year. The nominal rise in employees’ earnings is falling well behind inflation now running at 4 percent. This implies continued losses in the real value of wages or the purchasing power of most workers which has been stagnant or declining since the 1970s.

As the US falls into recession, the rest of the global economy is being sucked downwards with it. The collapse of credit instruments originating in the U.S. is also weakening the financial balance sheets of banks and other overseas holders of these investments, affecting not just the banking sector but also stock markets abroad. Hence the US is exporting a credit crunch overseas and pushing the entire global economy towards recession.

The IMF estimates that the eurozone’s growth will fall to just 0.9 per cent between the fourth quarter of 2007 and the fourth quarter of 2008. Japan’s growth would slow down to 1.4 percent this year and 1.5 percent next year, while Canada’s growth would fall back to 1.3 percent this year and pick up slightly to 1.9 percent next year. On the whole, “the IMF staff now sees a 25 percent chance of growth slowing to 3 percent or less in 2008 and 2009, equivalent to a global recession”.

The International Labour Organisation warns that the global economic slowdown in 2008 will add at least 5 million workers to the ranks of the unemployed worldwide, raising the global unemployment rate to 6.1 per cent. This is based on a more optimistic scenario of 4.8 percent growth in global GDP, which has been revised downwards by the IMF. A deeper recession would add millions more to the 189.9 million unemployed as of 2007.

Impact on working people in oppressed countries

Banks from the underdeveloped countries in the South have less exposure to sub-prime loans and the housing market bust in the US. But the adverse consequences of the current global financial crisis on the welfare and livelihoods of exploited classes in the oppressed countries will be more severe and protracted.

First, the global credit crunch means reduced capital flows for third world countries who are chronically dependent on foreign capital inflows to pay for older debts, sustain imports from the advanced capitalist countries and paper over chronic deficits they incur as imperialist states plunder their economies.

Second, most un-industrialized countries who are dependent on exporting agricultural products, raw materials, minerals, low-value added manufactures and services (e.g. business process outsourcing) to the advanced capitalist countries will be faced with shrinking exports due to the combination of depressed consumption in the North. Un-industrialized countries that are more deeply bound to neo-colonial trade relations with imperialist centers, particularly the US, would be the most severely affected. This includes the so-called newly industrialized economies which export significant volumes to the US by way of China. That is, by exporting parts and equipment of labor-intensive manufactures that are assembled in China before being shipped and sold in the US and EU markets.

Third, aside from being dependent on low-value commodity exports, un-industrialized countries are also dependent on the export of labor, particularly to the wealthy industrialized countries. International labor migration serves as an outlet for the surplus labor that cannot be absorbed by stunted domestic industries in these countries, as well as an important source of foreign exchange remittances that help pay for imports and debt-service. But recessions and rising unemployment in the advanced capitalist countries are invariably associated with the tightening of borders to keep out foreign workers. This means higher unemployment in labor-exporting countries, reduced earnings for foreign remittance-dependent households, and lower consumption spending in the domestic economy.

Fourth, and perhaps most importantly, as financial instruments and stock markets become less attractive to financial investors, speculative capital shifts more into commodities trading such as oil, minerals and agricultural commodities. This is contributing to the precipitous rise in food and energy prices beyond what conditions in the real economy warrant, thereby rapidly eroding the real incomes of the vast majority especially in the third world. Food accounts for 30-40 percent of the consumer-price index in most developing countries, compared with only 15 percent in the G7 economies. The Economist estimated that two-thirds of the world’s population suffer double-digit rates of inflation this season (mid-2008).

This is pushing millions of people deeper in poverty. In the Philippines, for instance, the Asian Development Bank estimates that “for every 10 percent increase in food prices, about 2.3 million more fall into poverty.” They will be joining nearly three billion people — half the world’s population — who are living on less than two dollars a day, including 1.3 billion workers.

In sum, what began as a sub-prime crisis in the US housing market in 2006 exploded into a global financial crisis in 2007 and is now giving rise to the specter of global stagflation — that dreaded combination of no growth and high inflation which has not blighted the imperialist countries since the 1970s.

Monopoly Capital’s offensive

It was precisely the problem of stagflation in the latter half of the 1970s that monopoly capital used as an excuse for ramping up its assault on the working class. Neoliberal economists, then ascendant, blamed workers’ wage demands and government spending on social welfare for causing the phenomenon of stagflation.

In 1979, then US Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker tripled interest rates in order to stem inflation. This also caused a severe recession in the US which drove up unemployment and dampened wage demands. The Reagan administration also dismantled social welfare spending but greatly expanded military spending to finance US imperialist wars of aggression overseas as well as pump-prime the flagging domestic economy. In 1981, Reagan sacked 11,345 air traffic controllers who had gone on strike demanding better working conditions, better pay and a 32-hour workweek — and blacklisted them from federal service for three years. The government also decertified their union. “This was the biggest, most dramatic act of union-busting in 20th-century America. PATCO’s destruction ushered in a decade of lost strikes and lockouts, triggered by management demands for pay and benefit givebacks that continue to this day in a wide range of industries.”

Today, we already hear the prelude to another such offensive against the working class. Jean-Claude Trichet, president of the European Central Bank, recently expressed fears that “higher headline rates could push up inflation expectations, leading to bigger pay demands, and so trigger a wage-price spiral, as in the 1970s.” Hence he called on “all economic agents, whether corporate or social partners, to be as responsible as possible” — a diplomatic warning against workers who dare attempt to cope with inflation by demanding higher wages.

But polite language cannot hide the increasing brutality of capitalists, state forces, paramilitaries and mercenaries-for-hire against workers around the world in order to pass on the burden of the crisis and protect their profits and privileges. The latest Annual Survey of Trade Union Rights Violations published by the ITUC shows an alarming rise in the number of people killed as a result of their trade union activities, from 115 in 2005 to 144 in 2006. And these are just reported figures from 138 countries covered by the survey. In Colombia alone, 78 trade unionists were assassinated in 2006, eight more than in 2005, while many others faced threats, abduction or “disappearance”. In the Philippines, at least 87 unionists and labor organizers have been killed since 2001. Three Nepali unionists were shot dead during mass demonstrations that eventually brought the king’s absolute rule to an end. In Guinea, 137 people were killed and 1,700 wounded in the fierce repression of the strikes and protests of January and February 2007.

In short, monopoly capital is using the present crisis to appropriate more of the people’s (real) wealth, erode and press down on wages and social spending, lay off workers, promote precarious employment, tear up workers rights, clamp down on workers concerted actions and intensify the exploitation of the working class.

Our Struggle against Imperialism

But workers are fighting back. In Vietnam, an unprecedented wave of workers actions has erupted in the country’s export processing zones where at least seven strikes have broken out so far this year — at Panasonic, VICO, Nissei, Asahi Intecc, Yamaha Motor, Sumitomo and Chiyodj Intergre — because wages aren’t meeting even the basic needs of workers. Autoworkers and steelworkers in Romania won substantial wage increases after launching a series of strikes last April to May. In France, hundreds of thousands of workers took to the streets last month in a demonstration against government plans to increase pension contributions. There is also a wave of occupations and strikes at construction sites, cleaning establishments and restaurants by immigrant workers protesting the government’s planned restrictions on immigrants. In the UK, hundreds of thousands of public sector workers are threatening to stage a series of one-day strikes this summer to protest the Gordon government’s 2 percent ceiling on pay hikes. In Norway, state workers at the township level are preparing to strike over pay. Drivers’ strikes are spreading across the globe — in the UK, Portugal, Spain, Egypt, India, Korea and Thailand — in response to skyrocketing petroleum prices.

In the Philippines, protesters are pouring into the streets demanded the scrapping of the value added tax (VAT) on oil, the repeal of the Oil Deregulation Law, and the approval of a legislated P125 across-the-board wage increase. Workers are downing tools, drivers are leaving their vehicles, while students are walking out of their classrooms to join these demonstrations. Egypt is now witnessing the biggest wave of strikes in the country since the 1940s, with women workers at the forefront. Workers are angered by neo-liberal privatization policies carried out by the Nazif government which has resulted in thousands of workers losing their jobs and led to an increase in the inflation rate that is currently estimated at around 12 percent while salaries have not increased since the 1970s. In South Korea, workers are at the forefront of a broad coalition opposing U.S. beef imports comprised of citizens, students and unionists who have mobilized in massive demonstrations and vigils calling for President Lee Myung-bak to step down. In South Africa, COSATU is preparing to strike against the government’s planned anti-inflation measures that would likely lead to deeper indebtedness of working families and more job losses.

The current crisis is but the latest manifestation of fundamental contradictions in the world capitalist system that are intensifying in the era of imperialist globalization. Increasing economic polarization, over-accumulation of capital and overproduction that give rise to economic crises and ultimately ruin society’s productive forces — these are inherent in a system based on the private monopoly control of a few over the social means of production – and no amount of fiscal stimulus or financial regulation can fix these problems. The Bush Administration’s grand plan to solve the current financial crisis is to shift the toxic debt load of private banks onto the federal government, i.e. the American people. While this will surely please the financial elites – witness the stock markets rally upon hearing the news – the rescue plan will sharply increase the government’s budget deficit and the already gargantuan US debt thus worsening fundamental imbalances in the real economy and setting the stage for even bigger convulsions later on. The utter helplessness and inutility of world leaders and policy-makers in resolving the current crisis reveals the total bankruptcy of neoliberalism and the unmitigated destructiveness of imperialist globalization – prodding people to search for real solutions elsewhere.

Hence, for the labor movement the current situation is both a challenge and an opportunity. We must counter monopoly capital’s desperate attempt to shift the burden of the crisis onto the people by consolidating our ranks, reaching out and organizing more workers in the factories, offices and in the communities, building unity with other oppressed and exploited sections in our society and internationally, and waging more strikes and other forms of resistance. We must deepen our understanding of imperialism’s offensives — economic, political, military and ideological — against the working masses throughout the world. We must wage not just economic struggles but raise them to political struggle against the ruling system as a whole, win national freedom and democracy, and build socialism as the alternative to this irredeemably rotten system. (Posted by Bulatlat)

Works Cited

Arnold, C. (2007, August 7). Economists Brace for Worsening Subprime Crisis. Retrieved June 10, 2008, from National Public Radio: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=12561184

Bernanke, B. S. (2007, June 5). The Housing Market and Subprime Lending. Retrieved June 5, 2008, from Federal Reserve: http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/Bernanke20070605a.htm

Bernstein, J. (2008, June 6). Mounting recessionary signs as unemployment rate spikes. Retrieved June 12, 2008, from Economic Policy Institute: http://www.epi.org/content.cfm/webfeatures_econindicators_jobspict_20080606

Brenner, R. (2002). The Boom and the Bubble: The US in the World Economy. New York: Verso.

Caprio, G., & Klingebiel, D. (2003). Episodes of Systemic and Borderline Financial Crises. World Bank.

Chandrasekhar, C. (July 12-14, 2007). Continuity or Change: Finance Capital in Developing Countries a Decade After. Conference on “A Decade After: Recovery and Adjustment since the East Asian Crisis” . Bangkok Thailand: Organised by International Development Economics Associates (IDEAs), Global Sustainability and Environment Institute (GSEI), Action Aid and Focus on the Global South.

Davies, J., Sandström, S., Shorrocks, A., & Wolff, E. (2006). World Distribution of Household Wealth . WIDER UN University.

Dumlao, D. (2008, May 8). High food prices affect poor most, cause more poverty. The Philippine Daily Inquirer .

Early, S. (2006, July 31). An old lesson still holds for unions. The Boston Globe .

Evans-Pritchard, A. (2008, May 18). OECD warning as stagflation goes global. Retrieved June 13, 2008, from Telegraph.co.uk: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/main.jhtml?xml=/money/2008/05/14/bcnoecd.xml

Hielema, B. (2008). International Experts Foresee Collapse of U.S. Economy. Ontario CA: The Intelligencer.

ILO. (2008). Global Employment Trends 2008. Geneva: International Labour Organisation.

IMF. (2008a). World Economic Outlook: Housing and the Business Cycle. April 2008 . Washington D.C.: International Monetary Fund.

IMF. (2008b). Global Financial Stability Report. Washington DC: International Monetary Fund.

ITUC. (2007). Annual Survey of Violations of Trade Union Rights. Geneva: International Trade Union Confederation.

MGI. (2006, January). Mapping the Global Capital Market: Second Annual Report. Retrieved June 11, 2008, from McKinsey Global Institute: http://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/publications/gcmAnnualReport.asp

Roubini, N. (2008, February 5). The Rising Risk of a Systemic Financial Meltdown: The Twelve Steps to Financial Disaster. Retrieved June 8, 2008, from Nouriel Roubini’s Global EconoMonitor: http://www.rgemonitor.com/blog/roubini/242290/

Sorkin, A. R. (2008, April 2). Leveraged Planet. Retrieved June 10, 2008, from The New York Times: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/02/business/02global.html?_r=2&oref=slogin&oref=slogin

The Economist. (2005, June 16). The global housing boom: In come the waves. The Economist .

The Economist. (2008a, May 22). Inflation in emerging economies: An old enemy rears its head. The Economist .

The Economist. (2008b, May 22). The world economy: Inflation is Back. The Economist .

Weisbrot, M. (2008, May 23). U.S. Economy: The Worst is Yet to Come. Retrieved June 13, 2008, from Center for Economic and Policy Research: http://www.cepr.net/index.php/op-eds-columns/op-eds-columns/u.s.-economy-the-worst-is-yet-to-come/

Wolf, M. (2008a, March 7). Paper prepared for the Colloque International de la Banque de France. “Globalisation, Inflation and Monetary Policy”. Hôtel Westin, Paris.

Wolf, M. (2008b, May 6). Seven habits finance regulators must acquire. Financial Times

Wolf, M. (2008c, Sept. 8). No alternative to nationalisation. Financial Times

Capitalism Has Proven Karl Marx Right Again

September 27, 2008

Time for a Marxist interlude. Inherent contradictions of capitalism, anyone? Intrinsic instability? Or perhaps we could risk the simple rhetorical questions Herr Marx somehow forgot to ask. To wit: have you ever seen a poker game in which no-one can ever lose? And would you, in your right mind, ever trust such a game?

BY IAN BELL
INTERNATIONAL
Posted by Bulatlat

Time for a Marxist interlude. Inherent contradictions of capitalism, anyone? Intrinsic instability? Or perhaps we could risk the simple rhetorical questions Herr Marx somehow forgot to ask. To wit: have you ever seen a poker game in which no-one can ever lose? And would you, in your right mind, ever trust such a game?

Capitalism works, so we are assured. This counts as, and possesses the worth of, an article of faith. What is actually meant – and I suggest you find a history book if you doubt me – is that capitalism “works” by failing periodically, and failing catastrophically. Strangely, no-one is ever to blame, far less arrested, for these acts of freakish nature.

Nevertheless, amid the unconscious, accidental poetry of dismal economics you will find the phrase “moral hazard”. It means that you have to be stupid or mendacious to reward stupidity and mendacity. The “system” functions best when there are punishments as well as rewards. If, that is, the system functions.

So it was with Lehman Brothers, fourth largest (until the weekend) of American investment banks. Those masters of the universe had let it be known that they were “too big” to fail. Apostles of the free market, advocates of “light touch” (zero) regulation, they despised state interference until the state – meaning the general population – seemed the lender of last resort. Disabused of that notion, they went bust. Some would call that capitalist efficiency.

Henry “Hank” Paulson, US Treasury Secretary, would be one of those. As a former Goldman Sachs demi-god he saw no contradiction between past life and present when refusing to hand free money to Lehman.
Bear Sterns was one thing; Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (just $5.4 trillion of American mortgage liabilities) another. But an example was to be made of the erstwhile “fourth largest” to keep hazard at bay and maintain a moral core. Pour encourager les autres, you understand.

The fun part, for a journalist, involves paper. Lehman, like its sibling institutions, had a lot of that. “On paper” the bank had $639bn in assets and $613bn in debts. Sustainable, you might have thought. But what did those assets truly amount to, and what did those debts actually mean? Some $40bn to $60bn of the latter are now defined as “toxic” (bad); Lehman has posted a $2.8bn quarterly loss (very bad); and no-one has a clear idea of what the supposed assets might really be worth (incomprehensibly bad).

This part of the paper trail begins and ends – Karl Marx would have been entirely at home – with the selling of insupportable debt to the very poor. It turned, as the first flickering of a bright idea, on the suckering of the disadvantaged, the exploitation of the simple desire for a home, and the fantastic belief that debt can be shuffled eternally. Lehman and Merrill Lynch ($50bn to Bank of America, itself “embattled”) and the rest treated sub-prime reality as a paper concept, pixels on a screen.

These notions were then repackaged, “securitised”, with good debt and bad bundled together like a job lot of tat in a car-boot sale. These “instruments”, sold and resold and sold again, then became the excuse
for still more borrowing, still more debt. Low interest rates – step forward Alan Greenspan and Gordon Brown – kept the party going for a decade. But the poor are a funny lot. They persist in failing to have
money. Hardly worth the pieces of paper on which their names are written, the saps.

In a rational world – not this one – everything just described would count as bonkers. It would be funny, in a Carry On Banking sort of way. People would laugh at the very idea of wealth conjured from thin air and reality as a distraction for hapless civilians. But it has all come to pass. In some quarters they are wondering if the Lehman episode has brought a sorry year to a conclusion. I suggest that they review the autumn of 1929. And then look east.

Wall Street, 80 years ago, did not crash in a day. Week after week, people would tell one another that the crisis was over. Things were looking up. Happy days were here, or there, again. Instead, things went from bad to worse to hellish while the central banks allowed feral markets to hunt down capitalism’s sickly runts. The people claiming to be in charge of Halifax Bank of Scotland this week will know what I mean. A “correction” becomes a purge in the blink of an eye.

Part of capitalism’s problem – there’s more where this came from – is its preference for paper before people. Those who talk seriously of the “real” economy give a flavour of the attitude. They even suggest that one can “decouple” financial markets from the planet occupied by food, heat, jobs, families, petrol prices, children and money you can spend in a shop. They base their behaviour on the assumption that lived reality is a concept best reserved for computer models. Then the clever sums fail to add up.

Britain fell for this fantasy in a very big way. A succession of Thatcher’s Chancellors assured us that times would be better in a post-industrial service economy. Making things, things you could touch and use, was suddenly the oldest of old hats. Financial “services” were the modern alternative in a society that could no
longer get away with paying coolie wages to its proletariat. Besides, you can’t flog credit cards to peasants.

The result is that Britain is uniquely vulnerable to the firestorm. Lehman’s London outpost has just “shed” 5000 jobs. A quarter of a million more inhabit the sprawl they still call the City. Scotland, skull for skull, perhaps has greater exposure, its insurers agog over the travails of American International Group, “the world’s largest” (if broke) in their field. The paper industries that fed GDP that fed the housing market that fed the credit boom that fed Circularity, not to mention sheer deceit, will be themes for months to come.

Those currents of history of which Herr Marx was so fond become apposite, at this point. Wars and impressive munitions have distracted us from the end of the American century. Gore Vidal said it best when he observed that the empire fell, bar the shouting, when the US became the world’s largest debtor nation. That remains the case. We depend on a reserve currency itself dependent on an economy
that is, by any measure, bust. All those creative manoeuvres with collateralised debt obligations mask a fundamental truth: America is broke.

India is not, however. Brazil is not. China, with $1 trillion in foreign, mostly greenback, currency reserves does not have a sub-prime problem. It has a dollar problem. If there is to be – if there is – a catastrophic failure within the US system, Beijing stands to lose a bundle. If hey act to support Washington, however,
the Chinese – and the Indians, the Koreans, the Arabs and the rest – will want assets you can trust and test in return.

It’s what known as a fire sale. In the reasoning of Karl Marx, never actually mistaken about the tendencies of economic actors, it stands as a definitive crisis. The world just changed, ready or not. (Posted by Bulatlat)

Big Banks Go Bust: Time to Reform Wall Street

September 27, 2008

We must go further in fixing the financial sector – most importantly by downsizing it. The financial sector accounted for more than 30 percent of corporate profits in 2004. Back in the 1950’s and 1960’s, the country’s period of most rapid growth, the financial sector accounted for less than 10 percent of corporate profit.

BY DEAN BAKER
The Campaign for America’s Future/Truthout
INTERNATIONAL
Posted by Bulatlat

With the demise of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, IndyMac, Bear Stearns and now Lehman Brothers, we’ve been treated to the failure of more major financial firms than during any year since the Great Depression. The sight of rich bankers getting the boot might be lots of fun if it were just a spectator sport. Unfortunately, we are in the game with these clowns.

As a result of their incompetence, irresponsibility and greed, the housing bubble was allowed to grow to dangerous proportions. Its collapse threw the economy into recession, putting millions of people out of work and lowering the wages of those who still have their jobs. The plunge in house prices has destroyed much of the life savings for tens of millions of people nearing retirement.

Meanwhile, the bankers who messed up and destroyed the companies who hired them are still multimillionaires. Most of them are still in their old jobs getting multimillion-dollar pay packages. This is a sector that badly cries out for reform, and there is no better time than now to put it into place.

The first target for reform should be the outrageous salaries drawn by the top executives at financial firms. The crew that lost tens of billions at Citigroup, Merrill Lynch and the rest have received tens of millions, possibly even hundreds of millions, in compensation for their “work” over the last few years.

There is a general problem in corporate America of stockholders being unable to effectively organize to rein in top management. This problem is most serious in the financial industry.

Thankfully, the credit crisis gives us the tools we need to rein in executive pay. Currently, the major surviving investment banks (e.g. Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs) are operating on life support. They are drawing money at below-market interest rates from the Federal Reserve Board’s discount window. This privilege (for which they pay nothing) can easily be worth billions of dollars a year.

These banks are also operating with an explicit guarantee from Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke to their creditors that he will honor their loans in the event that an investment bank, like Bear Stearns, goes belly up. This guarantee is enormously valuable. Investors who make loans to Merrill Lynch or Morgan Stanley don’t have to worry about the health of these companies because Bernanke has said that, if necessary, he will use public money to pay them back.

While we don’t want a chain reaction of banking collapses on Wall Street, the public should get something in exchange for Bernanke’s generosity. Specifically, he can demand a cap on executive compensation (all compensation) of $2 million a year, in exchange for getting bailed out. For any bank that is not on board, Bernanke could make an explicit promise to their creditors – if the bank goes under, you will get zero from the Fed.

This can be an effective way to restore sanity to the salaries paid on Wall Street. And, this can be a good example for setting executive pay more generally. Any time a company comes to the public for a handout, like tax breaks for oil companies or low-interest loans for auto companies, the $2 million cap on all compensation goes into effect.

This is important directly because much of the country’s wealth has been steered into these folks’ pockets, but also because the outrageous compensation packages on Wall Street distorted pay structures throughout the economy. Presidents of universities often get over $1 million a year, and even top executives at private charities can often earn near $1 million a year. These salaries seem low when compared to their counterparts in the corporate world, but they are outrageous when compared to the paychecks of typical workers.

Of course, we must go further in fixing the financial sector – most importantly by downsizing it. The financial sector accounted for more than 30 percent of corporate profits in 2004. Back in the 1950’s and 1960’s, the country’s period of most rapid growth, the financial sector accounted for less than 10 percent of corporate profit.

The financial sector performs an incredibly important function in allocating savings to those who want to invest in businesses, buy homes or borrow money for other purposes. But shuffling money is not an end in itself. The explosion of the financial sector over the last three decades has led to a proliferation of complex financial instruments, many of which are not even understood by the companies who sell them, as we have painfully discovered.

The best way to bring the sector into line is with a modest financial-transactions tax. Such taxes have long existed in other countries. For example, the United Kingdom charges a tax of 0.25 percent on the purchase or sale of share of stock. This is not a big deal to someone who holds their shares for ten years, but it could be a considerable cost for the folks who buy stocks in the morning that they sell in the afternoon.

Comparable taxes on the transfer of all financial instruments (e.g. options, futures, credit default swaps, etc.) could go a long way in reducing speculation and the volume of trading in financial markets. Such a tax could also raise an enormous amount of money – easily more than $100 billion a year. This would go a long way toward funding national health care insurance or a major green infrastructure project.

And, this tax would be hugely progressive. Middle-income shareholders might take a small hit; but it would be comparable to raising the capital gains tax rate back to 20 percent, where it was before it was cut to 15 percent in 2003. The real hit would be on the big speculators and the Wall Street boys, the folks who gave us the housing crisis. Given what the Wall Street crew has done for us, this is change that we can believe in. (Posted by Bulatlat)

Dean Baker is the co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR). He is the author of “The Conservative Nanny State: How the Wealthy Use the Government to Stay Rich and Get Richer” (www.conservativenannystate.org). He also has a blog, “Beat the Press,” where he discusses the media’s coverage of economic issues. You can find it at the American Prospect’s web site.

Salary Standardization Law 3: For Whose Benefit?

September 27, 2008

The Confederation for the Unity, Recognition and Advancement of Government Employees (Courage) says that the proposed salary adjustment by the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) is totally unfair for the 1.4 million employees who toil for almost 12 hours everyday despite the low salary.

BY NOEL SALES BARCELONA
Bulatlat

During the Sept. 3 National Budget hearing in the House of Representatives, Budget Secretary Rolando G. Andaya Jr., said that the national government has earmarked, for the proposed Salary Standardization Law 3 (SSL3), P20 billion (US$428.68 million) from the proposed P1.4 trillion ($30.07 billion at the Sept. 19 exchange rate of $1:P46.56) national budget for next year. This, he said, will be used for the first tranche of the SSL3 in 2009.

The SSL3 will be implemented over a four-year period, beginning next year, according to Andaya.

According to Andaya, if the SSL3 is implemented, those who hold the rank of Teacher I and Nurse I in 2009, will have a salary increase from P12,026 to P13,542 or 12.6 percent higher than their current salary rates.

When SSL3 is implemented in full, their rate shall be at P18,088 per month.

On the other hand, Medical Officers I (doctors) and Legal Officers I (lawyers) will have an increase by 79.2 percent from P15,181 to P27,198, said Andaya.

The budget secretary also said that the two grade levels for teachers and nurses will also be upgraded from Grade 10 to Grade 11, while for doctors and lawyers are from Grade 14 to Grade 16.

Utility workers and those who are in clerical positions will on the average receive a 30-percent salary increase.

Unfair

However, the Confederation for the Unity, Recognition and Advancement of Government Employees (Courage) says that the proposed salary adjustment by the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) is totally unfair for the 1.4 million employees who toil for almost 12 hours everyday despite the low salary.

Calling the SSL3 a “recycled version” of the Government Classification and Compensation Act earlier filed in Congress, which essentially gave higher compensation to professionals and executives and “starvation pay” to the rank and file as benchmark, Courage national president Ferdinand R. Gaite said implementing SSL3 would be like giving more meat to those who are already full while at the same time throwing only crumbs to those who are really hungry.

“Those who need the increase more should get the higher adjustments. The P20-billion allotment for pay hikes in the proposed national budget should benefit the metro aides, clerks, drivers, machine operators, public school teachers, nurses and other public health workers and other employees who are at the front-line of delivering vital services to the public. Otherwise, it will be another self-serving piece of legislation and an affront to the employees,” he explained.

Gaite accused the Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo government of driving a wedge between those who earn more and have allowances, pork barrel, discretionary funds and other privileges at their disposal.

The militant leader also said that any salary increase, both for private and public sector workers, must be on the basis of social justice, not patronage.

In 2006 the government implemented a what was supposed to be a P1,000 across-the-board salary increase grant. But not all government employees benefited from it.

“Most of the workers from the local government units (LGUs) did not get increases in their salary,” he said. Gaite added that many local government employees who got salary increases did so through the savings of their respective LGUs.

Gaite said that government workers’ unions must be strong and united to be able to negotiate for salary increases.

To date, the lowest paid government employee receives a gross pay of around P6,126, sans mandatory deductions like withholding tax, GSIS and PAG-IBIG premiums, etc.

Gaite stressed that they are still for a P3,000 across-the-board nationwide salary increase but definitely shall oppose the “outrageous pay hike biased for top officials.” (Bulatlat)

Bill Pushes for Gov’t Use of Free Software

September 27, 2008

A bill mandating the government to use free/open source software (FOSS) has been filed at the House of Representatives. Bayan Muna Representative Teddy Casiño said the use of FOSS will help the government save from its spending on computer software and licenses.

BY BULATLAT

Bayan Muna Rep. Teddy Casiño, principal author of House Bill No. 1716 or the Free/Open Source Software Act, said the use of free/open software (FOSS) will help the government save from 15 to as much as 70 percent from its spending on computer software and licenses.

He said that while there is no existing inventory on government expenditures on software, businesses using FOSS are able to save 15 to 35 percent. He said these businesses spend for migration, training of technicians and users. “Savings can actually be more than that, it could reach as much as 70 to 80 percent,” said Casiño.

The bill mandates government to use FOSS except in cases where there are no equivalent software available.

He said that the House of Representatives’ database and website are open source. He said it was by necessity because they lack budget. Some local government units also use FOSS, he said.

Advantages

Casiño said that FOSS is inter-operable meaning it can work across many platforms and systems.

FOSS equivalents for such expensive programs like Microsoft Windows and Microsoft Office are readily available and downloadable for free over the Internet.

“The era of expensive software with oppressive license and patent restrictions are over. We are now entering a world where software itself is free and users pay only for the services of creating or modifying such software,” Casiño said.

He said FOSS is also development-friendly. “Users may customize certain features and programs without infringing on any copyright or license,” said Casiño.

Unlike propriety software, Casiño said that source codes of FOSS are accessible to the users and not restrained to the manufacturer.

The legislator also said that FOSS is less vulnerable to viruses. Because source codes are accessible, millions of users can find solutions. In propriety software, only the manufacturers can ‘cure’ the viruses,” he explained.

Casiño’s office, in cooperation with the House Committees on Information and Communications Technology and on Trade and Industry, sponsored a week-long exhibit of FOSS at the North Wing Lobby of the House of Representatives, Sept. 15-18.

FOSS users provided trainings for students and staff members of legislators.

Local IT industry

Casiño said that the use of FOSS by the business sector can spur the local information technology (IT) industry.

Under the FOSS business model, companies make money not by selling copies of their software but by creating, customizing and maintaining such products for specific users who are free to modify, copy or redistribute the software subject to very liberal copyright terms.

“In such a model, there would be no motive to ‘pirate’ software because everyone can copy and give away software to anyone. Instead, what will be encouraged will be the growth of companies who can modify, customize and maintain software and computer systems depending on a client’s needs,” Casiño said.

He said that while there are already companies using FOSS in the country, their clients are mainly from other countries.

Choice

Casiño is hopeful the bill will be passed. Their biggest obstacle, he said, is lack of information. His office has organized exhibits and discussions in schools.

He said that the Philippine Software Industry Alliance has expressed opposition to the bill, specifically the provision mandating government offices to use FOSS. The group, he said, also oppose the provision mandating schools to offer courses on FOSS.

“Government is a user. If the government wants to use FOSS, it is a choice. Besides, the bill does not prohibit the use of propriety software,” Casiño asserted. Bulatlat

Constitutional Issues to Determine Alignments in Senate Vote on the JPEPA

September 27, 2008

While the treaty’s sponsors, Senators Miriam Santiago and Mar Roxas, still have a lot to explain to their colleagues about the economic implications of the JPEPA – not to mention the still unresolved issues of toxic waste dumping and dubious gains for Filipino nurses and health workers – it seems that the issue of constitutionality will be the most contentious debate among the senators. Constitutionality has been emerging as a key factor that could determine alignments in the Senate once the JPEPA is put to vote.

BY ARNOLD PADILLA
Contributed to Bulatlat

It has been more than two years now since President Gloria Arroyo and Japanese premier Junichiro Koizumi signed the Japan-Philippines Economic Partnership Agreement (JPEPA) in September 2006. But the controversial treaty remains pending in the Senate and despite many delays continues to face rough sailing at the upper chamber.

While the treaty’s sponsors, Senators Miriam Santiago and Mar Roxas, still have a lot to explain to their colleagues about the economic implications of the JPEPA – not to mention the still unresolved issues of toxic waste dumping and dubious gains for Filipino nurses and health workers – it seems that the issue of constitutionality will be the most contentious debate among the senators. Constitutionality has been emerging as a key factor that could determine alignments in the Senate once the JPEPA is put to vote.

Conditional concurrence and side agreement

Since the joint committees on foreign relations, and trade and commerce, chaired respectively by Santiago and Roxas, closed public hearings in December 2007, the JPEPA has been hounded by questions on its constitutionality. Santiago , who has emphatically recognized the unconstitutionality of the JPEPA, has since insisted for a side agreement that will correct the constitutional flaws of the treaty. These legal infirmities pertain to the treaty’s investment provisions on national treatment, most favored nation (MFN) and prohibition of performance requirements.

By April 2008, the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) and the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) have yet to convince their Japanese counterparts on a detailed side agreement that will amend the country’s unconstitutional obligations in the JPEPA. At that time, Santiago had started to push for what she called “conditional concurrence” wherein the Senate will ratify the JPEPA based on the condition that a side agreement revising the treaty will follow.

Conditional concurrence, however, was criticized by some of her colleagues, notably Sen. Francis Escudero who pointed out that both the Constitution and the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties do not allow the Senate to issue a conditional concurrence on the JPEPA. More importantly, Malacañang knew that pushing for a conditional concurrence will put the Philippines in a position that could cause the Arroyo administration diplomatic embarrassment because Japan has remained adamant in its stance not to revise the JPEPA. For Japan , striking out the questionable investment provisions from the JPEPA will cancel the most important concessions that they got under the treaty.

Thus, Foreign Affairs Sec. Alberto Romulo had to ask Santiago to defer her scheduled April 28 sponsorship speech, when she was supposed to officially endorse conditional concurrence, and wait until the side agreement between the two governments has already been clinched. Negotiations for a side agreement continued but has not been produced until Congress took a break from its first regular session in June. JPEPA’s next opportunity to get Senate approval was further delayed to August when Congress resumes session.

During the congressional break, DTI secretary Peter Favila continued pursuing the detailed side agreement with Japan . Even Roxas flew to Tokyo in July and met with top Japanese trade and foreign affairs officials to help convince them on the need for a side deal so that the JPEPA could get the approval of the Senate. But Japan would not budge from its “no revision” position. By end-July, Santiago was forced to admit that the best they could get from Japan was a mere “general statement” of assurance that the JPEPA will not violate the Constitution instead of a detailed side agreement that effectively revises the country’s unconstitutional obligations in the treaty.

Exchange of notes

With the doors for a possible revision of the JPEPA effectively shut, Santiago is left with no option but to endorse concurrence on the treaty as it stands. Santiago , of course, is obliged to do this as political payback to Arroyo for nominating her to the International Court of Justice (ICJ). But Santiago and the JPEPA proponents still need to package the sponsorship for concurrence as if the earlier conditions have been met to counter the anticipated opposition from the public and some senators.

It is in this context that Santiago , in her August 6 sponsorship speech on the JPEPA, said that she is now endorsing (unconditional) concurrence on the treaty because the Japanese have already agreed to an “exchange of notes” that will supposedly correct the constitutional defects of the JPEPA. The exchange of notes actually has not been produced and made public until September 1, which further delayed interpellations in the Senate as some lawmakers including Roxas wanted to see its contents before proceeding with the interpellations.

Only five pages, the actual document is composed of: (1) the diplomatic letter of Romulo to Japanese foreign minister Masahiko Koumura, dated August 22, identifying four major points of “shared understanding” between the Philippines and Japan and (2) Masahiko’s reply to Romulo, dated August 28, citing verbatim the points he raised and a statement confirming the shared understanding.

The first two points of the shared understanding refer to general statements pertaining to the parties’ commitment to respect each others’ national laws, including their constitutions; and to implement the JPEPA in accordance with each other’s respective charters.

Point number three, meanwhile, enumerates the provisions of the 1987 Constitution that the Philippines clarified shall not be amended by the JPEPA. These include provisions in Article II (Section 15), Article XII (Sections 1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 10-12 and 14), Article XIV (Sections 4 and 12), and Article XVI (Section 11). The provisions cover, among others, the protection of Filipino enterprises from unfair foreign competition; restrictions on foreign ownership of public lands and in the exploration and exploitation of natural resources; limitation to Filipinos of certain investment areas; preferential rights, privileges and concessions granted to Filipinos covering the national economy and patrimony; regulation of foreign investments; regulation of technology transfer and promotion; and the promotion of preferential use of Filipino labor, domestic materials, and locally produced goods.

A useless document

A closer look at the contents of the exchange of notes reveals that the document is useless in so far as ensuring that the JPEPA will not undermine the Constitution. It could have been a stronger and more binding document if it explicitly amended the questionable provisions of the JPEPA, as originally proposed by retired Supreme Court justice Florentino Feliciano who first raised the constitutional issues during one of last year’s Senate hearings.

In fact, the exchange of notes could be a Trojan Horse just awaiting the opportune time to attack. A closer look at point number four of the shared understanding reveals the hidden intentions of the document:

“4. The present exchange serves only to confirm the interpretation of and does not modify the rights and obligations of the Parties under the provisions of the JPEPA.”   (emphasis added)

In other words, the unconstitutional provisions of the agreement remain and will still bind the Philippines once the JPEPA gets ratified. The exchange of notes did not resolve the constitutional issues but in effect just deferred the question to be tested by actual legal conflicts over the treaty’s implementation that may arise in the future. This places the Constitution under unnecessary duress because under the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, the Philippines could not raise unconstitutionality for failure to comply with its JPEPA obligations.

Legal luminaries share the same observation. In a paper, former UP College of Law dean Professor Merlin Magallona described the exchange of notes as a derogation of the Constitution. Magallona wrote: “The essence of a treaty in international law is that it creates legal relations between the state parties, and the core of such relations consists of rights and obligations embodied in the meaning of the text of the treaty in question. For this reason, instead, the Exchange of Notes appears as reaffirmation of the legal relations between Japan and the Philippines in JPEPA and has the effect of reinforcing the intent to adhere to the rights and obligations as provided in JPEPA”.

Magallona also argued that if the Senate ratifies the JPEPA, there is a danger that the treaty will supersede the Constitution in application and settlement of disputes over JPEPA’s interpretation. “In case of incompatibility between JPEPA and the Constitution as an issue to be decided by an arbitral tribunal that may be created by the parties pursuant to JPEPA, that tribunal will apply JPEPA over and above the Constitution pursuant to the fundamental principle of the pacta sunt servanda and in accordance with the basic norm of international law that a party to a treaty cannot invoke its internal law, including its Constitution, as a justification for failure to perform its obligation under the treaty,” Magallona wrote.

Professor Harry Roque, also of the UP Law, meanwhile, belittled the exchange of notes as a scheme to appease domestic opposition to the JPEPA. “The reality is that in a treaty, neither of the parties can invoke a violation of its domestic law as a ground for its non-compliance therewith. In short, even if the JPEPA were to violate the Philippine Constitution, it will not affect its binding nature. Hence, the exchange of notes is a superfluity”, Roque pointed out.

Both Magallona and Roque said that the remedy to the unconstitutionality of the JPEPA is not the exchange of notes but non-concurrence on the part of the Senate.

Emerging alignments

While Santiago claims that with the exchange of notes, the JPEPA could now breeze through the Senate and perhaps be finally ratified by October, the reality is that more and more senators are being convinced that the treaty is legally indefensible. Since the exchange of notes was made public, a bloc of senators has emerged pushing for a renegotiation of the JPEPA.

Among them is Senate Majority Floor Leader Francis Pangilinan who said that despite the exchange of notes, JPEPA’s ratification is not assured because he thinks it failed to cure the major defects of the treaty. He pushed for renegotiation as a “way out” of the debate over the pact. While Pangilinan is careful not to call the move a rejection of the treaty, a renegotiation will, in effect, mean Senate non-concurrence on the current JPEPA. As Santiago noted, “a call for renegotiation will effectively kill the treaty” and asked her colleagues to simply “love it or leave it”.

Sen. Benigno Aquino III has already confirmed that he belongs to the renegotiation bloc while Sen. Panfilo Lacson has also made public his proposal to renegotiate the treaty. Lacson shares the views that the exchange of notes “may be rejected by the Japanese Diet or could be questioned before an international court”. Unconfirmed reports also list Senators Jamby Madrigal and Antonio Trillanes IV as among those included in the renegotiation bloc although Madrigal has been consistent in her opposition to the JPEPA.

While not reported listed in the renegotiation bloc, Sen. Pia Cayetano has also been vocal since the onset about her serious misgivings on the JPEPA specifically on its environmental impact. In addition, reliable sources also disclosed that Escudero and Minority Floor Leader Aquilino Pimentel Jr. will likely vote against the treaty or support the call for a renegotiation. Santiago , interestingly, has also named Sen. Gringo Honasan as among those who want the JPEPA renegotiated although he has yet to make any public statement on this.

Thus, there is a fighting chance that the needed eight votes to block JPEPA’s ratification may be mustered as senators forge a consensus around the unconstitutionality of the JPEPA despite the exchange of notes. But nothing is certain at this point considering that the Japanese, according to Senate insiders, have been really aggressive in their lobbying efforts to get the JPEPA approved and unrevised. Also, the propensity of Malacañang to use all the (dirty) tricks in the book to push for its agenda must not be overlooked.

The challenge for anti-JPEPA advocates is to ensure that those who have already come out publicly against the JPEPA, whether for outright rejection or for renegotiation, will firm up their position. The exchange of notes must be further exposed to help convince the other senators who have not yet made up their mind. Public pressure, through the combination of one-on-one dialogues and briefing with targeted senators and direct mass actions to pressure the Senate as an institution to vote against the JPEPA must be intensified. Bulatlat

Arnold Padilla is the spokesperson of No Deal! Movement, an alliance of organizations opposed to unfair bilateral trade agreements.

A Day in the Life of a Jeepney Driver

September 27, 2008

Jeepney drivers work long days and endure a lot of difficulties in their struggle to eke out a daily living. At the end of the day, however, their earnings are far from enough to afford basic necessities.

BY ALEXANDER MARTIN REMOLLINO
Bulatlat

Sa maghapon
Ang buhay ay pamamasada
Tinitiis
Usok at init ng makina
At pag kulang pa ang kita
Kailangan pang umarangkada

Ganyan ang buhay-jeepney driver
Sa buong araw na kayod
Mga tuhod ay nanlalambot
‘Yan ang buhay-jeepney driver
Sa buong araw na pasada
“Jingle” lang ang pahinga
‘Yan ang buhay-jeepney driver
Pag may konti nang kita
Pwede nang pumarada

– Noel Cabangon, “Jeepney Driver”

These lines definitely apply to the case of Mang Vito Pulmon, who plies the route from Project 3 in Quezon City to Quirino Avenue in Manila and back.

A typical day for Mang Vito begins at around 6 a.m., when he does his first round trip along his route. He has to complete five such round trips everyday to be able to take home some money for his family.

This routine of his has not changed for the last few years, despite the recent rollbacks in prices of petroleum products.

Diesel prices last month came close to P55 ($1.23 at the August 2008 average exchange rate of $1:P44.88) as a result of a series of oil price hikes starting last January.

Oil firms have claimed that the frequent spikes in the prices of their products are offshoots of their supposed need to recover losses from the jumps in world oil prices. World crude prices increased at a seemingly uncontrollable pace with projections that it would hit $200 per barrel. But these peaked at $147 per barrel before going down steadily. Mainstream analysts claimed that diminishing oil reserves, weather disturbances, and geopolitical factors such as the impending war between the US and Iran caused prices to rise; although some attribute it to a speculation frenzy in the oil futures market, especially after the sub-prime mortgage crisis in the US when hedge fund managers lost millions of dollars.

In the Philippines, oil companies have implemented a total of seven rollbacks since last August. These rollbacks have brought down prices by P8.50 a liter for gasoline and P6.50 for diesel.

World crude prices in the oil futures market first hit the $100/barrel mark in January this year, while its spot price was around $92.93. The local pump price of unleaded gasoline in January was at P44.45 per liter and diesel at P38.45. World crude prices in the futures market hit $103/barrel in February and $110/barrel in March, with spot prices reaching $93.51 in February and $99.32 in March. Local pump prices in February and March ranged from P43.96 to P46.46 for unleaded gasoline and from P36.94 to P39.44 for diesel.

Brent crude oil for October delivery last traded at $99.43 and light, sweet crude at New York Mercantile Exchange at $101.74. Spot prices range between $93.06, for oil from the Urals, to $104.04 for Louisiana sweet oil. Local pump prices now range from P51.25-52.85/liter for unleaded gasoline, and P48.95-51.09/liter for diesel.

The current range of pump prices for unleaded gasoline and diesel is visibly still above the monthly averages for the period January-March 2008, bolstering the claims of drivers and militant organizations that the current oil price rollbacks are not enough.

“Hindi nararamdaman ng drayber y’ong rollback. Dapat, mas malaki ang ibaba ng presyo ng langis. Ang mahal-mahal ng langis, sa gasolinahan lang napupunta y’ong kita namin” (Drivers cannot feel the supposed benefits from the rollbacks. Oil prices should be reduced more. Petroleum products are so expensive that our earnings mostly go to the gasoline stations), Mang Vito said.

Sweating it out

I accompanied him one day last week for a few round trips along his route and got first-hand insight into what Mang Vito and other jeepney drivers have to go through everyday to eke out a living.

A trip from Project 3 to Quirino Avenue takes between 2 ½ to three hours on days when traffic is moderate. When traffic is heavy, Mang Vito said, it could take up to four hours.

It was very humid when we went on that trip, like it was going to rain anytime. But it did not rain. The weather was like that throughout the day.

On days like that it is an ordeal to be stuck in considerably heavy traffic, like what happened to us several times on E. Rodriguez Avenue in Quezon City, as well as on Espana Street in Manila which seem to be perennial traffic hotspots. As Mang Vito himself describes it, “masakit y’ong init” (the heat hurts).

The prolonged exposure to the sun’s heat comes on top of having to endure the high temperatures from the jeepney’s engine.

On rainy days, Mang Vito says, at least you don’t have to endure the excruciating heat. But a different problem arises. “Pag bumaha, hindi ka na makabiyahe” (When it floods, you can go on with your trip anymore), he says. And there are many flood-prone areas along his route.

There are many other things that a jeepney driver has to endure. Often he has to endure the grumbling of his stomach because he has to postpone his meals and his snacks until he completes a round trip along his route (it was over two hours past normal lunchtime, for instance, when we were able to have our lunch). With that also comes the fact that he often has to postpone relieving himself, sometimes by one hour or more: for some drivers, the alternative would be to stop somewhere along the route and relieve themselves on their vehicles’ wheels. Apart from that, drivers who ply Metro Manila routes have to deal daily with the dust and smoke that famously loom over the streets of the metropolis.

It would be late evening by the time Mang Vito completes his fourth round trip. By that time, he would have enough only to pay his boundary fee and make a return on what he spent throughout the day for diesel (he spends some P300 on diesel for every round trip). He has to make another round trip so he could earn a little money to take home to his wife and child.

Measly earnings

At the end of the arduous day – which, for Mang Vito, lasts up to 12 midnight or thereabouts – he gets to take home approximately P300 ($6.44 at the exchange rate of $1=P46.555). That is less than what minimum wage earners make in just eight hours of work. (Bulatlat.com)

US Troops Are Here to Stay, Concealed in Bases Within AFP Camps

September 27, 2008

Since losing a number of its major overseas bases in the 1990s, the US has had to make shifts in its basing strategy. It now increasingly relies on what its Department of Defense calls “Cooperative Security Locations” (CSLs), and there is now less emphasis on “Main Operating Bases” (MOBs). The US has a number of CSLs in the Philippines.

BY ALEXANDER MARTIN REMOLLINO
Bulatlat

Since losing a number of its major overseas bases in the 1990s, the US has had to make shifts in its basing strategy. It now increasingly relies on what its Department of Defense calls “Cooperative Security Locations” (CSLs), and there is now less emphasis on “Main Operating Bases” (MOBs). It has a number of CSLs in the Philippines, one of which is in Camp Navarro, Zamboanga City.

The US military installation within Camp Navarro was mentioned by Pacifico Agabin, dean of the Lyceum of the Philippines School of Law, during his presentation at the oral arguments against the RP-US Visiting Forces Agreement (VFA) before the Supreme Court on Sept. 19.

The 1987 Constitution does not allow foreign military presence on Philippine soil except through a treaty jointly recognized by both contracting parties. Art. XVIII, Sec. 25 of the Constitution provides that:

“After the expiration in 1991 of the Agreement between the Republic of the Philippines and the United States of America concerning military bases, foreign military bases, troops, or facilities shall not be allowed in the Philippines except under a treaty duly concurred in by the Senate and, when the Congress so requires, ratified by a majority of the votes cast by the people in a national referendum held for that purpose, and recognized as a treaty by the other contracting State.”

The VFA was ratified in 1999 by the Philippine Senate and signed by then President Joseph Estrada, but it was never ratified by the US Senate.

The first RP-US Balikatan military exercises under the VFA – which provides only for short stays by US troops – were conducted in 2002. There has been continuous US military presence in the Philippines since then, manifested through the CSLs.

“Visiting is quite an understatement, considering that the US forces have been with us for six years, and six years can hardly be considered a visit,” Agabin said during the Sept. 19 oral arguments. “It is really a continuous visit. It is really a kind of visit that wears out the hospitality of the host.”

Agabin then cited the presence of CSLs within Philippine military camps – specifically the one located in Camp Navarro.

The website GlobalSecurity.org defines the MOB and the CSL as follows:

A Main Operating Base (MOB) is an enduring strategic asset established in friendly territory with permanently stationed combat forces, command and control structures, and family support facilities. MOBs serve as the anchor points for throughput, training, engagement, and US commitment to NATO. MOBs have: robust infrastructure; strategic access; established Command and Control; Forward Operating Sites and Cooperative Security Location support capability; and enduring family support facilities. These are already in existence.

A Cooperative Security Location (CSL) is a host-nation facility with little or no permanent US presence. CSLs will require periodic service, contractor and/or host nation support. CSLs provide contingency access and are a focal point for security cooperation activities. They may contain propositioned equipment. CSLs are: rapidly scalable and located for tactical use, expandable to become a FOS, forward and expeditionary. They will have no family support system.

The US Department of Defense’s Dictionary of Military and Associated Terms, meanwhile, defines a base as “a locality from which operations are projected or supported,” reflecting clearly the role of these installations in war posturing.

In an article in the June 2005 issue of TheAtlantic.com, Robert D. Kaplan explains how CSLs work thus:

“A cooperative security location can be a tucked-away corner of a host country’s civilian airport, or a dirt runway somewhere with fuel and mechanical help nearby, or a military airport in a friendly country with which we have no formal basing agreement but, rather, an informal arrangement with private contractors acting as go-betweens. Because the CSL concept is built on subtle relationships, it’s where the war-fighting ability of the Pentagon and the diplomacy of the State Department coincide – or should. The problem with big bases in, say, Turkey – as we learned on the eve of the invasion of Iraq – is that they are an intrusive, intimidating symbol of American power, and the only power left to a host country is the power to deny us use of such bases. In the future, therefore, we will want unobtrusive bases that benefit the host country much more obviously than they benefit us. Allowing us the use of such a base would ramp up power for a country rather than humiliating it.

“I have visited a number of CSLs in East Africa and Asia. Here is how they work. The United States provides aid to upgrade maintenance facilities, thereby helping the host country to better project its own air and naval power in the region. At the same time, we hold periodic exercises with the host country’s military, in which the base is a focus. We also offer humanitarian help to the surrounding area. Such civil-affairs projects garner positive publicity for our military in the local media – and they long preceded the response to the tsunami, which marked the first time that many in the world media paid attention to the humanitarian work done all over the world, all the time, by the US military. The result is a positive diplomatic context for getting the host country’s approval for use of the base when and if we need it.

“Often the key role in managing a CSL is played by a private contractor. In Asia, for example, the private contractor is usually a retired American noncom, either Navy or Air Force, quite likely a maintenance expert, who is living in, say, Thailand or the Philippines, speaks the language fluently, perhaps has married locally after a divorce back home, and is generally much liked by the locals. He rents his facilities at the base from the host-country military, and then charges a fee to the US Air Force pilots transiting the base. Officially he is in business for himself, which the host country likes because it can then claim it is not really working with the American military. Of course no one, including the local media, believes this. But the very fact that a relationship with the US Armed Forces is indirect rather than direct eases tensions. The private contractor also prevents unfortunate incidents by keeping the visiting pilots out of trouble—steering them to the right hotels and bars, and advising them on how to behave. (Without Dan Generette, a private contractor for years at Utapao Naval Station, in Thailand, that base could never have been ramped up to provide tsunami relief the way it was.)”

According to Roland Simbulan, a professor of development studies at the University of the Philippines (UP) in Manila and an expert on RP-US foreign and military relations, the dismantling of the US bases in the Philippines following the Senate’s rejection of a new Military Bases Agreement in 1991 was a major contributor to the US shift in basing strategy.

The Philippines was once host to the largest US overseas bases. Subic Naval Base alone had an area of 6,658 hectares, while Clark Air Base covered 4,400 hectares.

Apart from these, the US had O’Donnell Transmitter Station (1,755 hectares), San Miguel Communications Station (1,100 hectares), Capas Naval Transmitter Station (356 hectares), John Hay Air Station (227 hectares), and Wallance Air Station (202 hectares).

All these spanned a total area of 14,698 hectares of arable land. “If you combine that, it would be bigger than Singapore,” Simbulan said in an interview.

“So the dismantling of the bases in the Philippines was a hard blow to the US. The US was really shocked by the 1991 vote against the new bases treaty… They were forced to shift to a new basing strategy.

“CSLs were developed to blunt political opposition to big military bases.”

The US maintains a number of CSLs, mostly in Africa, Latin America, and Asia. US officials claim that the CSLs particularly in Africa and Latin America exist for the purpose of combating the drug trade.

But this is just a cover, according to Simbulan. “The US has not been consistent in its fight against the drug trade,” he said. He noted that the US military, for instance, had colluded with drug syndicates in fighting revolutionary guerrillas and leaders in Colombia and Cuba.

In the Philippines, there are CSLs installed in Camp Aguinaldo, the General Headquarters of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP); as well as in Camp Navarro in Zamboanga City, in Cotabato City, and in Basilan.

Camp Navarro hosts the headquarters of the Joint Special Operations Task Force-Philippines (JSOTF-P).

The JSOTF-P was established by the US Special Operations Command Pacific (SOCPAC). It began its work when SOCPAC deployed to the Philippines Joint Task Force (JTF) 510. Based on an item on GlobalSecurity.org, JTF 510 was deployed to the Philippines “to support Operation Enduring Freedom.”

Operation Enduring Freedom is the official name given to the US government’s military response to the terrorist attack of Sept. 11, 2001 in New York City. It entails a series of anti-“terrorism” activities in Afghanistan, the Philippines, the Horn of Africa, Trans-Sahara, and Pakinsi Gorge.

“CSLs are off-limits to AFP personnel,” Simbulan disclosed. “I was able to talk with some AFP personnel at one time, and they told me they don’t really know what the US troops are doing in their offices within AFP camps.”

“The (main) purpose for these is for them to expand their operations so that when they have missions to Malaysia and Indonesia, they would have locations that are open to them,” he said.

Saimbulan also said that the CSLs in the Philippines are also used for “technical intelligence”, or surveillance, purposes. He said that the US troops conducting surveillance operations are particularly active in strategic areas like Southwestern Mindanao.

“They go around in civilian clothes,” he said. “Some of them disguise themselves as tourists.”

The immediate goal, he said, is for the US troops to consolidate their influence in Mindanao. “It follows that when they consolidate their influence there, US companies would have easier access to the area,” he said.

The long-term consideration, however, is that the US views China as a long-term threat, Simbulan said.

Simbulan said that between 100 and 500 US troops are deployed all year in the Philippines, working from these CSLs. These, he said, are apart from those who come to the Philippines periodically for the Balikatan military exercises.

Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita recently said that US troops come and go but they “all look alike,” so it is as though they never leave.

“They are replaced every now and then,” Ermita said. “They leave, contrary to the critics’ impression that they have not left.”

But this is not so, said Simbulan. “It is those who join the Balikatan who come and go, but those (in the CSLs) are deployed here for prolonged periods,” he said.

He recounted his conversation with the wife of a US official on one trip to Zamboanga, during which he learned that in the Camp Navarro CSL there is now a building for housing.

There is no treaty between the Philippines and the US which allows for the presence of CSLs on Philippine soil. (Bulatlat)

The Cruelty of Enforced Disappearances: An Abhorrent Crime Against Humanity

September 27, 2008

They are victims of the same abhorrent acts, although three decades apart. One has searched for a sister, the other is still looking for his parents. One shared the same belief as his sister, the other could not fully understand his parents’ work. But whether it happened during Martial Law or now that we are supposedly under a democracy, whether the relative is a sister, a brother, or a parent, or whether one is an activist or not, the pain one feels in having his or her relative forcibly disappeared by state security agents is still the same; it does not diminish the cruel effects of the crime.

BY RONALYN V. OLEA
HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH
Bulatlat

Sometime in July 1977, Rizalina Ilagan rendezvoused with nine companions Gerardo Faustino, Jessica Sales, Modesto Sison, Cristina Catalla, Ramon Jasul, Emmanuel Salvacruz, Salvador Panganiban, Virgilio Silva and Erwin de la Torre at the Makati Medical Center. That fateful day, they were abducted by state security agents and were never seen alive again.

Bonifacio Ilagan, Rizalina’s brother, believes that his sister’s abduction was the handiwork of a composite team of state security forces called the Ground Team 205. The team, he said, was comprised by agents from the 2nd Military Intelligence Group, 2nd Constabulary Security Unit and 231st Company of the Philippine Constabulary headed by a certain Col. Gallido.

An informant told Ilagan that there were 24 agents, including civilians, in the team. The team was operating in Southern Tagalog but could also strike anywhere. Rizalina et.al, later called as the Southern Tagalog 10, were forcibly abducted at the Makati Medical Center.

It was the single-biggest case of abduction during martial law.


Bonifacio Ilagan.

Ilagan related that before the incident, Rizalina got in touch with him and insisted on meeting him. Ilagan said he knew it would be dangerous. He knew he was placed under surveillance by the military to trace other activists. Rizalina then was in the underground movement.

A leader of the Kabataang Makabayan (KM), Ilagan was arrested in 1974 and released two years after. In 1977, he was still reporting to Camp Crame on a weekly basis and had re-enrolled at the University of the Philippines (UP).

It was early July of the same year when she met Rizalina. He felt she had something very important to say. Rizalina told him that some of their colleagues have been missing. They needed a halfway house. Ilagan agreed to look for a house and had set a date for their next meeting. Rizalina never came.

Not expecting the worst

Ilagan said an emissary later told him that Rizalina and nine others have been missing.

He said, “All the while, I thought my sister was just arrested… I didn’t expect the worst.”Ilagan said he thought then that Rizalina would be surfaced later, as what happened to him and to other political detainees during that period.

When they received no news about Rizalina, the family went to military camps and to the Ministry of National Defense to look for her. Ilagan said they even tried to look for contacts within the military but to no avail.

A month after the abduction, the family got in touch with someone who had contacts within the intelligence community, said Ilagan. The source promised he would try to help. When the man came back to them, the family was told, “It’s too late.” Ilagan said the man confirmed that Rizalina was in the hands of the military. The custody of Rizalina, they were told, was no longer within the regular procedure. The informant did not say if Rizalina was still alive.

Later, Modesto Sison’s body was found in Lucena City, Quezon province. Two others Virgilio Silva and Salvador Panganiban were found in a ravine in Tagaytay City, Cavite. The rest, including Rizalina, have not been found to this day.

Double whammy

Ilagan said their parents, especially their mother, took his arrest and detention and Rizalina’s abduction as a double whammy.

When he was released, his mother was somehow relieved. His mother would visit him regularly. “After two years, I was released out of her sheer determination,” said Ilagan.He said he was released not through the regular procedure. His mother tried to establish connections with relatives of Gen. Fabian Ver.

Ilagan was among the detainees held in maximum security prisons. From Day 1 until his release, intelligence agents served as their custodians. He was detained at the headquarters of the 5th Police Constabulary Security Unit in Camp Crame.

He said Rizalina’s disappearance had been too much for the family. He said that their parents believed that more harm could be inflicted on their daughter. Rizalina was the youngest daughter and sixth of the seven siblings. Ilagan was fifth. Two of their brothers were also activists during martial law.

No time to grieve

Ilagan said he did not have the time to grieve for they have not found her body.

But he said that after several years, he knew she was gone. “Going by the record of that [military] unit, walang bubuhayin (they will leave no one alive),” said Ilagan.

He said he got the information about the Ground Team 205 from a detainee held for years by the said unit, and was able to escape. They did not kill her but forced her to be an asset. Every time the soldiers would transfer to another safehouse, they would take the woman-detainee with them. Ilagan was able to talk with the woman after she escaped. She knew about the operations against Rizalina and her companions.

Rizalina’s case was included in the class suit filed against Ferdinand Marcos in Hawaii.

Still painful

Ilagan admitted that even today, whenever thoughts of Rizalina come to him, his heart becomes heavy.

“Dahil alam ko kung ano ang pwedeng nangyari sa kanya,” (Because I know what could have been done to her.) he said.

He said Rizalina and the other women with her were raped.

“Sana bigla na lang ang naging pagkamatay niya, hindi dahan-dahan.” (I wish she just had died instantly, not slowly.)

He showed a photo of her sister taken in 1971. During Rizalina’s birthday (June 19), he lights a candle. He named her daughter Dessa Rizalina.

Ilagan described his sister as very pleasant and gentle. Problems could not bring her spirits down, said Ilagan. They also had similar interests. Rizalina joined KM when she was only 15. Ilagan recruited her. He acted as a big brother to her, often taking her to his activities in school. When he joined the Dramatics Club, Rizalina joined, too. When he became active in the KM’s theater group in UP, Rizalina also did the same at the UP Los Baños.

He recalled giving her a copy of the new edition of Philippine Society and Revolution the last time he saw her.

He could also vividly remember the time Rizalina ‘visited’ him in prison.

Rizalina went with their mother one Saturday. She did not go inside the receiving room and just waited outside. Their mother told him Rizalina just wanted to see him. As Ilagan led his mother to the gate, he saw Rizalina. She smiled at him and raised her clenched fist. Ilagan said it was her way of saying goodbye before she took to the hills to join the underground movement. While talking about this particular day, Ilagan broke into tears.

The Southern Tagalog 10 went missing during martial law. Under the Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo government, enforced disappearances continue to inflict pain on the relatives of victims.

Both parents missing

Erloreb ‘Nooky’ Mendez’s parents Celina Palma and Prudencio Calubid were abducted by military agents on June 26, 2006 along Maharlika Highway near Sipocot, Camarines Sur.

Calubid was a consultant of the National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDFP). Mendez said before the incident, he saw Erlinda Cadapan and Connie Empeño on television. “Naawa ako sa mga estudyante,” he said. (I felt sorry for the students.) He was not expecting that both his parents would be missing too.

Looking up the same sky

On the same day, his younger brother Junjun sent him a text message saying that their parents were abducted. At first, he did not want to believe him.

When it dawned on him that what his brother told him about their parents’ abduction was probably true, he looked up the sky. It was late at night then. “Ito ang nakikita nila na nakikita ko rin, ang ulap. Sabi ko ‘Ma, ingat parati.’ (What I am seeing right now, the sky and clouds, are the same sky and clouds they are also seeing right now. I said, ‘Ma, take care always.’)

Missing their moments together

When his birthday (July 6) came, Mendez was hoping his father would call him as he always did. He did not receive any call.

Nooky is the eldest of three siblings. They grew up with their aunt. Their father visited them once a year, usually during Christmas break or summer. Their mother also visited them once in a while. Their parents sometimes took them during their trips.

Mendez recalled, “Tuwing magkikita kami, pinilipilit ni Papa na mag-usap kami as family. Kinukumusta kami isa-isa.” (Every time we were together, Papa would insist that we talk as a family. He would ask each one of us how we were doing.)


This photo of Prudencio Calubid was taken by his son using a cellphone.

Before, he found the habit corny. Now, he missed those times. He said the last time he was with his parents was in December 2005. His father was quite disappointed because the family was not complete. That time, his brother and sister were in another place. That year, too, Mendez was doing his thesis. He was a graduating student taking up Computer Science in a private school in their province.

Recalling how he felt when he learned about their parents’ enforced disappearance, he related, “Di ko alam gagawin ko. Hirap ako, di ko alam kung paano mag-move on. Di ko nga alam kung dapat bang mag-move on kasi di naman sila namatay, nawawala sila.” (I did not know what to do. It was so hard. I did not know how to move on. I did not even know if I have to move on because they did not die, they went missing.)

He could hardly concentrate on his studies. During those years, from 2006 to 2007, Mendez said he and his brother and sister did not talk about their parents. “Ang bigat-bigat.” (We felt heavy-hearted.)

During his graduation, Mendez said he immediately left after the program. “Malungkot naman. Nakita ko magulang ng ibang kaklase ko.” (It was so sad seeing my classmates with their parents.)On his cellphone, he has kept a video of his father taken last April 2, 2005 and a few photographs of his mother and father.

Same plight

In September 2007, he got in touch with Desaperacidos, an organization of families of the disappeared. “Dito ko nalaman na hindi lang pala ako ang nawalan, marami pa pala. Magandang makipag-usap sa mga taong nararamdaman ang nararamdaman mo,” said Mendez. (It was only then that I realized that I am not the only one with missing loved ones, there were several others. It feels good to talk with people who also feel the way you do.)

He said he has started ‘processing’ his emotions. He said they would cry whenever one of them is being interviewed. “Apektado kaming lahat.” (We are all affected.)

They also support each other, said Mendez. They join camp searches, fact-finding missions, filing of cases and other activities for the victims. He said he is also learning a lot from the other victims. He admitted he could not understand fully the nature of his parents’ work.

Mendez recalled that Elizabeth Principe said his father was kind and funny. Principe is also a consultant of the NDFP. She is detained at Camp Crame on trumped-up murder charges.

Perpetrators, cowardice

Asked if he believed the military took his parents, Mendez said yes.

He said a witness said so. Junjun, his younger brother was able to talk to the witness Antonio Lacno. Lacno was with Calubid, Palma and two others when soldiers in uniform on board a red Tamaraw FX and four other Toyota Revo vehicles blocked their vehicle. (See Man Hides for Days, Crosses Rivers to Escape Military Abduction

Junjun told him that Lacno was shaking when the latter was relating what happened, apparently traumatized. Mendez called the abductions as ‘acts of cowardice.’“Bakit nila dudukutin pwede namang sampahan ng kaso?” (Why would they abduct people if they can file cases instead?) asked Mendez.

He added, “Kung may kasalanan, sampahan nila ang kaso hindi iyong pahirapan ang buong pamilya ng mga tao.” (If someone has committed anything wrong, they should file a case and not make the families of victims suffer.)

Continuing search for their relatives and the pursuit of justice

Mendez said that after more than two years, he is still continuing his search for his parents. He admitted, however, it is difficult. “Di alam paano magse-search, safehouses ang pinagdalhan sa kanila.” (I do not know where to search for them, they were brought to safehouses.)

He also expressed disappointment over the dismissal of amparo petitions filed by other victims’ relatives. Their petition for habeas corpus was dismissed last year. “Kay Jonas Burgos, may ebidensya naman. Ano pang aasahan mo? Nadi-dismiss ang mga kaso namin.” (The relatives of Jonas Burgos has evidences linking the military to the abduction. What else can we hope for? The cases we filed are being dismissed.)

For Ilagan, he felt a sense of justice when the New People’s Army killed a certain Col. Sebastian, a member of the Ground Team 205 years after the abduction of the Southern Tagalog 10.

Doing the same abhorrent acts

Ilagan recalled that in December 2002, he and families of the Southern Tagalog 10 sought a dialogue with Mrs. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo. They had breakfast with Arroyo at the state dining room. Angelo Reyes, then defense secretary and Mercedita Guttierez, then acting justice secretary, also joined them.

They gave a letter to Arroyo stating that the government must take full responsibility for what happened to the Southern Tagalog 10. They also asked the government to make available all documents pertaining to the perpetrators. “Walang pagtutol si Gloria… Nag-volunteer pa na magtayo ng monument sa UPLB at sa Lucena,” said Ilagan. (Gloria did not object…She even volunteered to put up a monument at the UPLB and in Lucena City.)

Years later, nothing came out of the meeting, said Ilagan. “Ginaya niya pa ang mga kasong inirereklamo namin.” (She even did the same acts we are complaining about.)

Ilagan said, “At least Marcos declared martial law before he did all the things he did. GMA [initials of Arroyo], even without declaring martial law, is doing what Marcos did.”

Ilagan also noted that under the Arroyo administration, most of the victims of abductions, extrajudicial killings and other human rights violations are ordinary activists and supporters. During the time of Marcos, he said the targets are usually those who held high positions in the organization.

The same monster

Ilagan said that even when there is no martial law, one thing has remained – the same monster of a military organization.He said the military tasted unlimited power during the Marcos years. After people power in 1986, Corazon Aquino failed to reform the Armed Forces of the Philippines.

Under Arroyo, Ilagan said that those with fascist mentality and are very much anti-Left have the upper hand in government. He said that Arroyo, beleaguered with the issue of illegitimacy, clings on to the military for survival. “These are vested interests that have combined to cultivate a culture of impunity,” Ilagan said.

Must not forget

Ilagan said the Filipino people must not forget the dark days of martial law.The government, he said, has been trying to make us forget what happened during martial law. This, plus the relatively short memory of the public, said Ilagan, must be fought.

“There is a need to educate and organize,” he concluded. (Bulatlat)

Rice Importation Hurts Local Farmers, Costs NFA Billions in Losses

September 27, 2008

BY RONALYN V. OLEA
Bulatlat

For this year, the Arroyo government would import 2.296 million metric tons (MT) of rice.

Based on the estimated NFA stock inventory as of July 1 this year, 929,337 MT are imported rice, accounting for 97.99 percent of the NFA stock.

The NFA targets to import 971,145 MT of rice from July to December. Meanwhile, the planned local palay (rice grain) procurement during the same period is only 51,238 MT.

Fines Cosico, NFA grains operations officer, said the NFA normally imports about ten percent of the country’s annual rice requirement and and imported rice supposedly constitutes only three percent of its buffer stock.

More expensive

In a primer titled “100% Rice Self-Sufficiency and Self-Reliance Equals Genuine Food Security,” the NFA Employees Association (NFA-EA) stated that from 1968 to 2008, the price of wholesale imported rice per MT was more expensive than domestic rice for 21 years out of the 48-year period.

In January this year, the price of imported rice per MT was US$409 or P16,769. It rose to US$1,091 per MT or P44,731 in April. The landed cost of imported rice is estimated at P67,096 ($1,604 at the April exchange rate of $1=P41.82) per MT during the same period. The landed cost takes into account freight cost, insurance, tariff, equalization fee, among others.

Meanwhile, the wholesale price of local rice in April is P30,000 ($717) per MT or less than half the landed cost of imported rice.

Even private traders are not interested in importing rice due to the high cost.

Losses

The NFA-EA also said, “Rice importation has greatly contributed to the NFA’s losses especially with the imposition of the rice import tariff.”

From 2002 to 2006, the NFA paid more than P20 billion ($389,787,565 at the 2006 average exchange rate of $1=P51.31) to the Bureau of Customs – Department of Finance. The tariff on rice was pegged at 50 percent.

On top of this tariff, the NFA also spends for transport, handling, stevedoring, and arraste services, warehousing, pest management, among others.

It is only in 2007 when the Arroyo government exempted the NFA from paying tariff on rice imports.

WTO commitment

Why does the government insist on importing rice?

Even the Department of Finance (DoF) said that losses of the NFA may reach P43.1 billion ($925,786,703 at the September 19 exchange rate of $1=P46.555) if the price of rice in the world market increases to more than US$1,000 per MT.

Cosico said the Arroyo government’s rice importation program is in compliance with its commitment to the World Trade Organization (WTO). Under the WTO’s minimum access volume (MAV), the country is obliged to import a certain volume of rice whether or not there is a supply shortage.

Cosico said the Arroyo government seems to be telling them to buy imported rice at any cost. On the other hand, local procurement remains very low.

Local procurement

The NFA buys local palay at low prices.

The NFA-EA revealed that from February 1999 to October 14, 2007, the NFA bought palay at only P10 ($0.216 at the 2007 average exchange rate of $1=P46.148) per kilogram even as the actual farmgate price then reached P11.21 ($0.24).

Since October 15, 2008, the price of palay increased by P1.50 ($0.03) per kilogram.

In April this year, Mrs. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo increased the P0.50 incentive to farmers selling palay to the NFA to P5.50 per kilogram. Of the P17 ($0.365) per kilogram buying price of the NFA for clean and dry palay, farmers receive only P11.50 ($0.247) as cash payment and P5.50 ($0.118) as incentive.

Cosico said farmers who sell at least 50 kilograms are given P1,800 ($38.66) as subsidy for fertilizers.

In 2007, the NFA absorbed only 0.19 percent of the total local palay production of 16.237 million MT.

Not for poor farmers

Willy Marbella Kilusang Magbubukid ng Pilipinas (KMP-Philippine Peasant Movement) deputy secretary general said farm gate prices of palay remain low even as the cost of production increases.

Marbella said poor farmers cannot afford to sell their produce to the NFA and cannot avail of the subsidy on fertilizers. Landless peasants, he said, have to pay for land rent, interest payments for debts they incurred, and also have to shoulder all the expenses in production, said Marbella.

Cosico said that even with the NFA’s mobile procurement, poor farmers cannot sell their produce to the NFA. “Wala na rin silang maibenta… napunta na sa trader na pinagkautangan ng binhi at abono.” (They have nothing to sell…their produce goes to the trader from whom they loaned the seeds and fertilizers.)

Basic problems

Marbella said the Arroyo government should address the Filipino farmers’ basic problem of landlessness if it wants to resolve the rice crisis.

The KMP has been pushing for the passage of House Bill 3059 or the Genuine Agrarian Reform Bill filed by the late Anakpawis Representative Crispin Beltran.

Cosico who is also an officer of Agham (Science and Technology for the People) said the government must support local agriculture by providing continuous incentives and credit to farmers.

Marbella criticized the Arroyo government for various agriculture-related scams. “Ang dinadaya nila, 75 porsyento ng mamamayang Pilipino.” (They are cheating 75 percent of the Filipino people.)

She described as token the subsidies provided by the Arroyo government to farmers. “The Arroyo government has no decent policy to strengthen local agriculture,” said Cosico.

She also called for the mechanization of agriculture. Today, farmers pay for the use of irrigation facilities and other services, said Cosico.

Moreover, both the KMP and the NFA-EA are calling for the passage of House Bill 3958 or the Rice Industry Reform Act sponsored by Bayan Muna Representative Satur Ocampo.

The bill aims to strengthen the NFA’s domestic procurement capability, among others.

Cosico concluded that the country’s food security must be met through local procurement and enhancing local agricultural production. (Bulatlat.com)

Barangay RP Komix on Cellphone Hazard

September 27, 2008

LFS-Lanao Feeding Mission

September 27, 2008

Children’s Rehabilitation Center
Southern Mindanao Regional Office

Press Statement:
September 16, 2008

The Armed Forces of the Philippines consistently sings the same old tune as excuse for their merciless actions

The AFP is again using their same old lines of “collateral damage” and tagging children as “child soldier”, as alibi to escape from accountabilities of violating children’s rights.

These lines were again used by the AFP particularly by Col. Marlou Salazar of the 601st Brigade and Maj. Gen. Hernanie Perez of Philippine Air Force 3rd Air Division after the September 8 incident when 6 person including 4 children with an age range of 2 years old to 10 years old, were killed after an OV-10 aircraft of the Philippine Air Force randomly bombed the civilians who were on board a motor boat, evacuating from their community in Barangay Tee, Datu Piang, Maguindanao.

The AFP is habitually known of using it as an excuse every time they commit atrocities against civilians especially children, just like what happened to Grecil Buya, the 9 year old girl child whom they killed and tagged as child combatant . They alleged that Grecil was doing a maneuver with an M16 riffle while shooting at the soldiers. When their allegation was proven wrong by the parents and friends of Grecil, they immediately justified that Grecil was just caught in crossfire of a legitimate encounter between the AFP troops and the NPA, thus making her a collateral damage.

The lives of civilians especially the children are put into grave danger with these arrogant yet cowardly excuses. These would mean that children will become legitimate targets of the government troops who are already known of their cold blooded human rights and children’s rights violations. The arbitrary military actions that the AFP launched and to be launched will continue thus, there will be no distinction between their armed enemy to the civilians. In fact, these scenarios are already happening in Mindanao amidst the escalation of the military offensives ordered by President Gloria Macapagal- Arroyo.

Based on report, there are already 21 civilians killed including 7 children and 13 others including 7 children were wounded due to indiscriminate firing and indiscriminate artillery shelling and bombings perpetrated by the government troops particularly under the 601st Brigade.

The present all out war of the Arroyo administration in Central Mindanao has already affected and displaced more than 360,000 Moro and Christian individuals and they are still increasing.

We, together with other child rights organizations held the Arroyo government liable for the escalating conflict in Mindanao which only victimized civilians especially women and children.

As civil society organization, we demand justice and indemnification for the victims brought about by the callous actions committed by the Armed Forces of the Philippines under the leadership of President Arroyo. Prosecution should undertake to those who are liable for violations of International Humanitarian Law (IHL) and United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC).

We challenge the Commission on Human Rights under the leadership of Commissioner Dillema to conduct a speedy and impartial investigation on the death of innocent civilians particularly children and to the other human rights violations, and to file appropriate charges to the perpetrators.

The government forces as well as the MILF forces should stand firm in protecting the civilians especially the children, in undertaking military action by observing and respecting the protocols of war as stipulated in the Geneva Conventions.

The government should be serious in realizing its mandate in protecting the children as stated in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child which the Philippine Republic ratified, by means of initiating the resumption of peace talks with the MILF.

We call for the stoppage of war in Mindanao and for the resumption of peace talks between the Government of the Republic of the Philippines and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front.

For Reference:
John Birondo
Advocacy Officer
CRC-SMRO
Contact no. 09184417947

NEWS RELEASE
10 September 2008

For Reference: REP. LIZA LARGOZA MAZA 0920-9134540
Jang Monte (Public Information Officer) 0917-4049119

RISING CIVILIAN DEATH TOLL SHOULD PROD PEACE TALKS, IMMEDIATE
ABANDONMENT OF DDR -MAZA

“The deaths of women and children, the evacuation of hundreds of
thousands and the destruction of communities: This is what President
Arroyo’s obstinate DDR framework for peace has spawned. Only the
callous and the inhumane would insist for the AFP’s pursuit operations
and indiscriminate aerial bombings to continue.”

Thus said Gabriela Women’s Party representative Liza Maza as she
called for the immediate resumption of peace negotiations between the
government and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, not on President
Arroyo’s DDR or disarmament, demobilization and rehabilitation
framework but on a policy of peace that recognizes basic human right
and international protocols for the conduct of war.

Following the deaths of Aida Manunggal and her four children in the
indiscriminate bombing of Datu Piang communities, the militant
lawmaker sought an investigation into the Armed Forces of the
Philippines’ conduct of its pursuit operations in the ongoing military
offensives in Mindanao.

“With their aerial bombings and indiscriminate firing, the AFP has
continued to harm more civilians than their purported targets,” said
Maza who is set to file a resolution this week.

Maza noted news reports where a pregnant woman, Aida Mandi, 18, along
with Bailyn, 10, Zukarudin, 7, Adtayan, 5, and Faiza, 2 died Monday
morning as they were fleeing military bombardments in Datu Piang,
Maguindanao. Last August 28, the Children’s Rehabilitation Center –
Southern Mindanao Region reported that indiscriminate bombing in
Sambulawan, Midsayap that led to the death of 9 year old Homidi
Abdurrahman and injured his 7 year old sister Samera Abdurrahman.

“For as long as the AFP’s all-out war and military offensives
continue, peace remains an even more unconceivable concept for
Mindanao, especially for women and children victims of this conflict.” #


NEWS RELEASE
11 September 2008

DEATH OF 6 CIVILIANS IN DATU PIANG, MAGUINDANAO VIOLATION OF
INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW, AFP SHOULD BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE

For Reference:
REP. LUZ C. ILAGAN 0920-9213221
Abby Valenzuela (Public Information Officer) 0915-7639619

Gabriela Women’s Party Rep. Luzviminda Ilagan condemned today the
irresponsible attack of the Armed Forces of the Philippines in a
civilian area in Datu Piang, Maguindanao last Monday, which killed six
people, wounded and displaced many others, in the continuing effort to
hunt Moro Islamic Liberation Front Commander Umbra Kato.

“What the AFP did is a violation of the International Humanitarian Law
which states that the State is responsible for the protection of the
people living in conflict areas and not participating in the war. They
are especially accountable for the safety of women and children who
are the most vulnerable targets of war. As it turned out, it is the
supposed guardians who violated this law,” the Mindanaoan solon said.

“The government should conduct an investigation into the irresponsible
actions of its military, especially after reports that the forces
hunting down the MILF used bomber aircrafts to indiscriminately fire
at civilians resulting to the death of six members of the Manunggal
family, including four children and an unborn child.”

Ilagan wants the government to immediately conduct an investigation
and punish the military personnel involved in this recent atrocity to
give justice to Aida Mandi Manunggal, 23, pregnant, and her children
Bailyn, 10, Zukarudin, 7 Adtayan, 5 and Faida 2.

The victims, along with their neighbors in Barangay Te, were caught in
the crossfire and were fleeing for safer ground on board a banca when
an OV-10 aircraft dropped a bomb which exploded near their location.
Their bodies, once recovered, were riddled with shrapnel.

Manunggal’s husband, Daya, and her son, Khneg, both wounded, are still
missing.

“To stop the human rights violations against innocent people in
conflict areas, the Malacanang should immediately order a ceasefire
and a pull-out of AFP troops from Mindanao,” Ilagan said.

__._,_.___

ARKIBONG BAYAN

NFA to buy 800,000 bags of palay in Bicol

September 27, 2008

LEGAZPI CITY — The National Food Authority is aiming to buy 800,000 bags of palay harvested by local farmers in Bicol up to December.

NFA Bicol Assistant Regional Director for Operations Jose Guevarra said the procurement target is a self-imposed task after traders in the region lowered the buying price to P14 per kilo for dried and P11 for wet palay.

Guevarra said the NFA’s buying price for dry palay is pegged at P17 per kilo. “The NFA has bought 170,000 bags of palay since July.”

The agency is now operating 19 warehouses all over the region to accommodate the expected surge of palay sellers. Six of them are in Camarines Sur and nine in Albay.

Under the Department of Agriculture’s procurement program, 58,000 bags of palay were initially targeted, but this was raised to 166,000 then to 340,000 until the target was raised to 800,000 bags. NFA/PIA release

DOE warns RP energy supply hits critical level

September 27, 2008

LEGAZPI CITY — The country’s energy supply is on its critical level causing frequent power outages due to its inability to sufficiently support the demand and reserve margin, Irma C. Exconde, assistant director at the Department of Energy said.

“The country’s energy reached its critical period this year particularly in Mindanao which is now experiencing frequent power outages. By 2009, Visayas will also be facing energy crisis while Luzon will be affected by power crisis in 2010,” Exconde warned.

She said that the country’s energy requirement is 4,100 MW capacity where Luzon is in need of bigger energy requirement at 3,000 MW compared to Mindanao with 600 MW, followed by Visayas with 500 MW capacity requirement.

She said the years 2008 to 2017 should be strongly taken as a planning period for a power development plan in our country.

Jesus Tamang, another top executive at the DOE admitted before newsmen here that the country’s energy reserve was thinning and they are scouting for additional energy reserve through alternative and renewable resources to meet the high energy demand.

The DOE officials flew in this city to conduct series of consultation with stakeholders with the hope of drafting and coming up with plans to improve energy supply as well as tackle pressing regional concerns during the 8th Philippine Energy Plan (PEP) 2008-2030 held at Casablanca Hotel here.

Tamang said the government is a need of P1.42 trillion from 2008 to 2014 or for the next six years to firm up and generate 4,000 MW additional power reserve to meet the country’s energy sufficiency.

But the energy sufficiency would only be attained, according to Tamang, if appropriate energy power generation mix and expanded alternative infrastructure distribution package would be established by the government in partnership with the private sector to invest on solar, wind, hydro power, including coal resources.

Bicol is host to geothermal and hydroelectric generating plants which feeds the Luzon Grid. Two of the major geothermal fields are in Tiwi, Albay which is operated by Chevron and in Bacon (Sorsogon)-Manito (Albay), otherwise known as BACMAN which is separately operated by the Philippine National Oil Company (PNOC). Both geothermal plants have a combined installed capacity of 496.20 MW.

The region is also host to diesel power plants and a hydro-power plant which serve the island provinces of Masbate and Catanduanes.

Bicolano businessman and investor Elizaldy ‘Zaldy’ S. Co of Legazpi City has established a P800 million hydro power project in Catanduanes and another P900 million worth of combined investments for windmill, solar and hydro projects in Misibis, Cagraray Island in Bacacay, Albay in anticipation of the looming energy crisis in the country beyond 2010.

To address and achieve energy sufficiency, the government is pushing major programs this year according to Tamang which include increasing indigenous energy resources production of oil and gas, energy sector reforms, ensuring environmental sustainability, securing vital energy infrastructure and facilities, institutionalizing social mobilization in all energy initiatives, and exploring options for regionalization.

The Philippines is the second largest geothermal producer in the world. Currently, three geothermal service contracts were signed in July this year with investments amounting to $26 million for the first five years with expected foreign exchange savings of $1.8 billion or P76 billion from oil imports.

Tamang said that the government is also accelerating the renewable and alternative fuels program such as wind energy, solar, hydro and biofuel as well as eyeing long term energy diversification to meet sufficient energy requirements.

Three coal operating contracts (COCs) were also signed as of August 2008, 10 small-scale coal mining permits awarded mostly in Zamboanga where local high quality coals come from (BicolMail)

2 foreign builders tapped for huge Ecija dam project

September 27, 2008

By Liam, Anacleto

GEN. TINIO, Nueva Ecija – President Arroyo has asked two foreign builders to undertake the construction of the long-stalled P15-billion Balintingon Reservoir Multipurpose Project in this town. Rep. Rodolfo “Rody” Antonino (4th disctrict) told local media Ms Arroyo requested representatives of a South Korean corporation and a Japanese funding agency to
submit an unsolicited proposal within next week.

Antonino said the foreign investors, met with the President here last week when she attended the congressman’s birthday party in Barangay Langla.

He said that the Korean representative belongs to the KWater Corp., a firm engaged in all water projects in South Korea and which is owned by the South Korean. The Japanese entity is a funding agency similar to the Japan International Cooperating Agency, he added.

Antonino, a stalwart of Ms Arroyo’s Kabalikat ng Malayang Pilipino (Kampi), said the unsolicited proposal means that the government was not the one who sought the project but that it was subjected to the so-called “Swiss challenge,” meaning the proposal was not put up in the international community to know if there are parties interested to bankroll it.

The process, he said, would last up to 60 days. Antonino said the President wants the project to get off the ground. “She’s quite uneasy that there was no progress on the project,” he said of the BRMP which was first planned 32 years ago.

The BRMP was first conceived under the Irrigation Development Plan for Central Luzon, a reconnaissance study by the National Irrigation Administration and ECI Consultants Inc. in 1976.

The BRMP was programmed to irrigate 14,900 hectares of agricultural lands in the eastern section of Central Luzon, covering Bulacan and Nueva Ecija using the Sumacbao River in Gen. Tinio as water source.

It involves construction of an outdoor 69 kilovolt switchyard connecting the plant with the Luzon grid at the substation in Cabanatuan City, a 140-meter long, rockfill central core dam, a 19-meter high diversion weir, 109 kms. of main canals, 168 kms. of lateral and sub-lateral canals, 210 km of drainage facilities and service and access roads.

Once finished, it is programmed to benefit 9,152 families in Cabanatuan City, Gapan City, and the municipalities of Sta. Rosa, Gen. Tinio and Penaranda – all in Nueva Ecija and the Bulacan towns of San Ildefonso and San Miguel.

In 2004, the dam cost only P5 billion. Its cost rose to P8.3 billion in 2006 and to P15 billion at present.

A detailed feasibility study made by NIA in 1983 which was financed by the Italian government proposed the construction of the dam with a reservoir capacity of 572 million cubic meters to irrigate 18,800 hectares.

Antonino said that the project has been reprogrammed to supplement the water supply requirements of the Angat Dam. “With Balintingon, there will be adequate supply of water for Angat and there will be no problem anymore,” he said. (NorthernPhilippineTimes)

Panlilio hits board for declaring freedom park

September 27, 2008

By George Trillo

SAN FERNANDO, Pampanga – Gov. Eddie Panlilio assailed the provincial board last week of agitating picketers against him and his provincial administrator by issuing a mere resolution declaring the Arnedo Park in front of the provincial capitol here a freedom park.

Referring to dismissed provincial government workers who have been holding a picket at the park, Panlilio said, “Their slogans are disrespectful and provocative. A mockery of the governor and the provincial administrator is uncalled for.”

The picketers, who were dismissed from their jobs in the provincial government’s lahar sand quarrying operations, have been criticizing Panlilio for allegedly reneging on his promise to rehire them.

They have also been seeking the ouster of provincial administrator Vivian Dabu whom they have accused of being behind their dismissal.

Panlilio said the picketers are “transgressing on the rights of others more particularly the right to a peaceful working environment of the employees at the provincial capitol.”

He said apparently, the intent of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan in issuing Resolution No. 1338 was to further agitate the picketers.

But Vice Gov. Joseller Guiao denied this, saying civil society leaders, including former supporters of Panlilio, were the ones who asked the provincial board to issue the declaration of Arnedo as freedom park.

The park was named after former Pampanga governor Macario Arnedo who served at the turn of the 20th century. (NorthernPhilippineTimes)

Illegal sand quarrying unabated in Cagayan

September 27, 2008

TUGUEGARAO CITY – Despite protest from the local Catholic Church and lack of permits, illegal sand quarrying continues along the Cagayan River, threatening to cause floods and affect irrigation due to the flow of sea water into the river.

The quarrying operations, reportedly financed by Chinese groups, go on unabated in the northern coastal towns in Cagayan up to the mouth of Cagayan River. Fr. Rex Singson, of Camalaniugan town, said the illegal activities, if not stopped, would eventually destroy thousands of hectares of farmlands and irrigation systems, especially those near the mouth of Cagayan River.

“We earlier had made formal complaints with the DENR (Department of Environment and Natural Resources) on this matter but to no avail, since the contractors have not heeded our complaints,” Singson lamented.

Fr. Manny Catral, of the Archdiocese of Tuguegarao, echoed Singson’s fears, saying the continued quarrying could lead to the submerging of some villages in the northern coastal areas.

“What if the silt has become so deep, what if water from the sea will flow back and saltwater will begin to stream down, what will happen to our farms?” he asked.

Local contractors are reportedly being financed by Chinese groups to quarry sand from the Cagayan River delta because of its much higher value than inland sand. Lawyer Gil Aromin,
regional director of the DENR’s Environmental Management Bureau, said the quarrying operators do not have any environmental compliance certificate (ECC) from the government.

“Since this a violation of the law, we will be constrained to issue a cease and desist order against (them),” Aromin said.

But the church officials lamented the DENR’s alleged inability to stop the quarry operations despite being aware that they lack permits.

“I have seen it with my own eyes and we have already voiced out our complaints to the DENR but to no avail,” said Singson. — CL (NorthernPhilippineTimes)

21,000 Cordi seniors awaiting GMA’s P500

September 27, 2008

BAGUIO CITY — Some 21,000 senior citizens in the Cordillera are still awaiting the release of the promised, one-time P500 subsidy from President Arroyo.

The number of the prospective beneficiaries of the subsidy is still expected to increase in the coming days as more senior citizens are submitting their registration papers with local officials.
Social workers in the different local government units called on barangay officials to fast-track the submission of the names of the qualified senior citizens so that they could process the release of the subsidy.

So far, there are 21,636 senior citizens region-wide who were awaiting the release of the one-time P500 subsidy from the national government’s Katas ng VAT program.

The office of the Department of Social Welfare and Development in the Cordillera said beneficiaries of the program are poor, old people (60 years old and above) who have no definite source of income and are not receiving any pension from the government or private companies.

The Cordillera DSWD office called on barangays officials in the region who have responded to the survey conducted by the agency to facilitate the submission of the list of qualified senior citizens who are qualified to receive the subsidy. The list of qualified beneficiaries will be subject to validation to prevent alleged misrepresentation.

The “Katas ng VAT” program has been devised by the national government as one of the approaches to mitigate the negative impact of the rising cost of basic commodities. A previous survey conducted by concerned government agencies showed there are 44,875 senior citizens in the different parts of the Cordillera, but the number is expected to increase once the final list of the elderly folk is submitted by the barangays.

The leaders of senior citizens associations in the region lauded the one-time subsidy, saying that although the amount is not much, it could go a long way in helping the senior citizens who do not have sources of income.

Meanwhile, the leaders appealed to the concerned government agencies to help them in their campaign for the strict compliance by various companies and establishments with the law granting 20 percent discount to senior citizens.

They noted many establishments ignore the law and refuse to grant the required discount. These establishments include drugstores, restaurants, and public utility vehicles. At the same time, they expressed support for a bill in Congress granting an increase in the discount for senior folk from 20 percent to 32 percent.

They complained that the 20 percent discount is eaten up by the 12 percent value added tax, resulting in only an eight percent discount. – Dexter A See (PhilippineNorthernTimes)